Remove this Banner Ad

Round 18: Geelong vs. St.Kilda

  • Thread starter Thread starter GeeCat
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

GeeCat

Premiership Player
Joined
Sep 26, 2003
Posts
4,930
Reaction score
724
Location
TJBC
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
TDot, LFC
Easily the match-of-the-round.

Will be interesting to see how the boys go about their footy. St Kilda, though weakened with their injuries, will be looking to notch up another win and will no doubt rise up on such an occasion. Such a depleted Saints side will present us with the best oppurtunity to beat them.

The one-two forward punch of Gehrig-Riewoldt will once again prove to be a huge test for Scarlett and Harley, and with Hamill most likely not returning after his hip surgery, this should no doubt prove a big relief for an underdone Mooney, who will be able to play as a floater around the grounds. Guerra and Milne will need to be minded once again, as either can break open a game and prove a real handfull for any club. Our defence will be slightly weakened with Sanderson most likely out with his knee injury, which will require one of DJ, Callan, Hunt, Woj or Enright (if selected) to stand up.

The midfield battle will be a real highlight, even though we'll be missing the likes of Kel, Tweak, and Ricco. Hayes, Dal Santo, and Ball loom the biggest problems in the Saint's engine room, two wildcards being Heath Black with his running game and Rob Harvey. I'd like to see DJ kept in the squad to help Ling tag one of their midfielders. If King can get first hands on the ball and feed our onballers, we'll be giving ourselves every chance to beat their much vaunted midfield.

Down in their backhalf, the Saints will be missing their first five choice tall defenders in Penny, Maguire, Hudghton, Koschitzke, and Schwarze. This is a huge bonus for us and could very well prove the deciding factor in whether we come away with the points. If Graham, and Kingsley can dominate in the air and kick a bag, which mind you is more than achievable, then we could be in this game with a huge chance. The rest of our forwards will need to be on their game as well; presenting hard, being there for the crumbs, and giving the side every chance of scoring everytime the ball enters the forward fifty through consistent application of pressure on the St Kilda defence. Aussie Jones will need to be minded, as will Brett Voss. Rebounding half back flankers like Jones have proven X-Factors in previous losses, and whoever lines up on him needs to be defensively on guard as well as giving him a handful to work with during the game.
 
Should be one of the best games of the year. Very much looking forward to making the trip down to Geelong. Can some one tell me if there is a curtain raiser on?
 
I don't care what is going on with St Kilda at all because i am confident that we are going to win this match, it is extremely important to to win this match to give ourselves a go at the top four and Stkilda being the only top four side we play for the rest of the year we need to beat them now! Besides it will be good to beat them after the humiliating round 1 loss to them and the Wizard cup Grand Final. I heard that on K-Rock today that this match could 'very well be the match of the year' that is a pretty big thing to say but i believe it could be getting that way, no doubts that the match will be a sellout. I was reading in the Herald Sun today and saw an article with the headline sayin 'No fear, we are ready for the Saints', which aparently Lingy said last night. So hopefully they truely arn't afraid and we can still be undefeated down at Skilled after the weekend!
******GO CATS******
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Originally posted by SpRiGgZy
I was reading in the Herald Sun today and saw an article with the headline sayin 'No fear, we are ready for the Saints', which aparently Lingy said last night. So hopefully they truely arn't afraid and we can still be undefeated down at Skilled after the weekend!

They've talked the talked and failed to walk the walk against the saints earlier in the year, which may be in the back of our minds. But i think the team at the moment is mentally and physically tougher than it was in round 1. Also, our record against the top sides this year has been very encouraging, losing to saints in the first round, and port in port adelaide by 4 points after controlling the game for most of the day, which suggest we rise to the occasion against the better teams in the comp. An important game not only for ladder positions but also confidence heading into the finals as this is the last team we play that is higher on the ladder than us.
 
Some top preview from you guys , fair dinkum you should pushing Mike Sheehan out his chair. !!!

My thoughts about this week and the match up against the Saints.

Its fantastic to have a big , big game down at KP again.I really think that its a pure fluke that the regulars at Skilled have got to see this Mega Clash game, if it was up to others it would be moved and I bet we dont see the Saints down the highway next year.Mostly we pay a high premium for mainly interstate sides and less favouable vic sides, so to be fair and give value, it should be that we play one match against one of the big sides down at Skilled. One match against the Dons or Pies or from now on the Saints could be a pre-sold live to air extravaganza.One a year is not to much to ask.If we had lights we could even do it on Fri night.

In the Saints game, I think we should play to our strengths and their weakness. We can beat them in the ruck and I think as Mooney isnt quite right he could be the Ace in the hole up forward, they are scatching for tall backs and he would be stronger than most of them. My concern is that with him out of the middle, Tweek out , we are down on the type of mongrel that Gurrea likes to dish out. Question , can Koola be that player?Ling must play on DelSanto and I predict BG to kick 5.0

In/Outs , Sanderson will be out , anybody else?
who's up to come back in. Do we bring a BPP in or another mid.We could play Wojo back there and bring in Tenace? not sure it might depend on form.

Im really looking forward to this match , probably the most since the hey days against WC
 
Yep, there is a great rivalry developing between these two sides.

I'ts going to be a very exciting game. I think home ground advantage will get us over the line.
 
Interesting to see that the boys from the Sunday footy show are coming down for the game:
http://gfc.com.au/default.asp?pg=news&spg=display&articleid=162497
I guess that this means that everybody sees this as the match of the round.

I think that we should walk away with the 4 points and I cant wait to see the match up of the two form forwards of the comp against the to form back men of the comp.
 
3 simple words:take out chambers......no offense at all but i think he played horrible on the weekend and didnt play to well against the swans either. Bring back Tenace and give Koula another game!
 
Originally posted by SpRiGgZy
3 simple words:take out chambers......no offense at all but i think he played horrible on the weekend and didnt play to well against the swans either. Bring back Tenace and give Koula another game!

Chambers played well against Sydney actually.
 
Horses for courses, King and Mooney can handle the St Kilda ruck division, the worst aspect of the St Kilda team. What we need to stop is what's happening on the ground and up forward. Bring in someone like Enright just to give us another option. Outside of the ruck contests, I can't see Chambers contributing much.
 
GAJ didnt train today

Bartel and Harley had a light run


ricco and moloney ran laps as did graham.

mooney also had a light run
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Does anyone know anything about the rumour that GAJ was supposed to miss last week?

Is he carrying an injury? How is his OP?
 
Originally posted by LongBomb
Does anyone know anything about the rumour that GAJ was supposed to miss last week?

Is he carrying an injury? How is his OP?

Krock Reported that against calton before they went out he could hardly bend over and really struggled
 
Originally posted by rizzo
...... ran laps as did graham.

I don't want Graham running laps, I want him practicing goal kicking for two hours solid. And when he's done that, do another two hours solid of goal kicking practice. Then go home, get dinner, watch some tv, go to bed and then get up and do more goal kicking practice.
 
Originally posted by Jim Boy
I don't want Graham running laps, I want him practicing goal kicking for two hours solid. And when he's done that, do another two hours solid of goal kicking practice. Then go home, get dinner, watch some tv, go to bed and then get up and do more goal kicking practice.

Kent can join him!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Originally posted by Inside 50
Just looking at the extended cats bench. If H was to play would he slot into the backline as an extra tall defender due to the fact that Hamill is playing?

If H does manage to play, you'd think Moons would get Hamill before H would; Hamill would quite simply outmuscle H too easily in contests.

That being said, since Moons is likely to be stuck on Hamill for the day, expect H to take Moons' position as that back-up ruckman who'll drift up forward during the course of the game.
 
Originally posted by GeeCat
If H does manage to play, you'd think Moons would get Hamill before H would; Hamill would quite simply outmuscle H too easily in contests.

That being said, since Moons is likely to be stuck on Hamill for the day, expect H to take Moons' position as that back-up ruckman who'll drift up forward during the course of the game.

I didn't think that H was setting the world on fire in the VFL so I thought him playing as an extra tall backmen would be the reason for his recall.

Teams:
GEELONG FC

PLAYERS
B: J. Corey M. Scarlett D. Milburn
HB: J. Hunt T. Harley C. Enright
C: D. Wojcinski C. Ling D. Johnson
HF: K. Kingsley C. Mooney J. Bartel
F: S. Johnson B. Graham C. Gardiner
Followers: S.King, P. Chapman, G. Ablett
Interchange: T. Callan, P. Chambers, S. Byrnes, P. Koulouriotis, D. Spriggs, K. Tenace, H. Playfair

ST KILDA FC

PLAYERS
B: S. Baker S. Fisher B. Voss
HB: A. Jones M. Ferguson B. Goddard
C: H. Black R. Harvey L. Ball
HF: B. Guerra N. Riewoldt A. Hamill
F: S. Milne F. Gehrig N. Dal Santo
Followers: T. Knobel, A. Thompson, L. Hayes
Interchange: J. Blake, J. Peckett, L. Montagna, X. Clarke, R. Clarke, N. Stone, B. Moyle
 
Originally posted by Inside 50
I didn't think that H was setting the world on fire in the VFL so I thought him playing as an extra tall backmen would be the reason for his recall.

Perhaps another reason was the cloud hanging over Moons? If Moons didn't play we'd be short of that versatile tall who can ruck, and play forward or back; H gives us that option.
 
Originally posted by GeeCat
Perhaps another reason was the cloud hanging over Moons? If Moons didn't play we'd be short of that versatile tall who can ruck, and play forward or back; H gives us that option.

Good point. All of this being said H has to actually be selected first. Which brings me to my next point, just wanted to get everyones thoughts on should be named on the bench.

I'd nominate Callan, S Byrnes, Chambers, Tenace
 
Originally posted by Inside 50
Good point. All of this being said H has to actually be selected first. Which brings me to my next point, just wanted to get everyones thoughts on should be named on the bench.

I'd nominate Callan, S Byrnes, Chambers, Tenace

H could very well give Chambers a run for his money to keep his spot in the team. I think H gives us a much more versatile option with his ability to hold down a key post as well as his overall mobility around the ground, something I believe Chambers can't provide.

Would dearly love to see Tenace get a gig this week, but it'd be hard pressed to see a player like Koulouriotis, Callan, Byrnes, or DJ give up their spot on the team for him, as all are very much worthy of keeping their spots themselves.

For me it's:

In: Enright
Out: Sanderson

Final Bench: Callan, Byrnes, Chambers, Koulouriotis
Emergencies: Tenace, Playfair, Spriggs
 
Tenace Bynes Callan and Koula for me
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom