POTY Round 18 vs Adelaide

[scaryness]

5- (BOG)
4-
3-
2-
1-
YPOTY-

YPOTY eligible players:
Harry Cunningham
Isaac Heeney
Brandon Jack
Jake Lloyd
Tom Mitchell
Toby Nankervis

 

[swansfan51]

5 - Tippett
4 - Mitchell
3 - Hannebery
2 - K Jack
1 - McVeigh

YPOTY - Mitchell

 

[SilentHunter_]

5 - Hanners
4 - K Jack
3 - Tippet
2 - McVeigh
1 - Jetta

YPOTY - Mitchell

 

[The King!]

5 Kurt Tippett
4 Tom mitchell
3 Dan hannebery
2 lewis jetta
1 kieran jack

Ypoty mitchell

 

[Swans322]

5. Hanners
4. Jack
3. McVeigh
2. Jetta
1. Tippett

YPOTY - Mitchell

 

[Superstar swan]

5.hanners
4. Jack
3.tippett
2.kennedy
1. Jetta

Ypoty:mitchell

 

[robbieando]

5 - Tippett
4 - Hannebury
3 - McVeigh
2 - Rampe
1 - Jack

POTY - Mitchell

 

[Mick Oxlong]

5. Jack
4. McVeigh
3. Rampe
2. Tippett
1. Mitchell

YPOTY: Mitchell

How good is Rampe? A couple of seasons ago he was a SFL player and now he's an attacking, quick, intelligent, creative AFL player. His skills are far better than those with perceived more talent that grew up in an Aussie rules state. Bert Newton once said 'I like the boy'!

 

[MF]

5. Tippet
4. Mcveigh
3. Mitchell
2. Hanneberry
1. Jack

Ypoty Mitchell

 

[Maddhew]

Hanners had a lot of it, and butchered a lot of it, not sure he was BOG

 

[scaryness]

Hanners had a lot of it, and butchered a lot of it, not sure he was BOG

He did butcher it at times, but hard to ignore 40 & 3.

 

[kangle4]

5- Tippett
4- Mcveigh
3- Rampe
2- Jetta
1- K. Jack

YPOTY- Mitchell

 

[NinjaSwan]

5 - K. Jack
4 - Tippett
3 - Hanners
2 - Rampe
1 - McVeigh

YPOTY - Mitchell

 

[V9x18]

5. hanners
4. tippett
3. shaw
2. rampe
1. jetta

 

[BarneyBent]

5. Jack
4. McVeigh
3. Rampe
2. Tippett
1. Mitchell

YPOTY: Mitchell

How good is Rampe? A couple of seasons ago he was a SFL player and now he's an attacking, quick, intelligent, creative AFL player. His skills are far better than those with perceived more talent that grew up in an Aussie rules state. Bert Newton once said 'I like the boy'!

Broadly agree, but for all his skills he has an uncanny knack of missing basic passes. It's like when he doesn't have to kick through the ball, he over thinks it.

 

[Number37]

5. Tippett
4. Jack
3. Smith
2. Jetta
1. Rampe

YPOTY: Lloyd

 

[Jeffers]

5. Hannebery
4. Tippett
3. K Jack
2. Rampe
1. Kennedy

YPOTY Mitchell

 

[S120]

5. Kurt Tippett
4. Dan Hannebery
3. Tom Mitchell
2. Kieren Jack
1. Lewis Jetta

YPOTY: Tom Mitchell

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Broadly agree, but for all his skills he has an uncanny knack of missing basic passes. It's like when he doesn't have to kick through the ball, he over thinks it.

NB: that said, there are 21 other players in the team!

 

[grimlock]

5. K.Tippett
4. D.Hannebery
3. L.Jetta
2. K.Jack
1. T.Mitchell

YPOTY Titchell

 

[Jack2Jack]

5. Tippett
4. Hannebery
3 K. Jack
2. Mitchell
1. Jetta

YP - Mitchell

 

[Klim]

5- Tippett
4- Hanners
3- K Jack
2- Mitchell
1- Jetta
YPOTY- Mitchell

 

[BloodRet]

5. Hannebery
4. Tippett
3. Mcveigh
2. Rampe
1. Jetta

YPOTY Mitchell

 

[bungee]

5. Macca
4. Jetta
3. Kizza
2. Kennedy
1. Laidler

YPOTY : Mitchell

He did butcher it at times, but hard to ignore 40 & 3.

Hanners turned it over so often under no pressure that I couldn't give him the votes this week. He's so damn good that he'd be elite if he could hit targets, as might Parker. Rampe also missed my vote due to frustrating turnovers whereas Laidler and Shaw showed pinpoint, accurate attacking rebound which set up a lot of play. Laidler brave and magnificent efforts in defence. Grundy, Rampe, Smith special mentions too.

 

[bungee]

5. Jack
4. McVeigh
3. Rampe
2. Tippett
1. Mitchell

YPOTY: Mitchell

How good is Rampe? A couple of seasons ago he was a SFL player and now he's an attacking, quick, intelligent, creative AFL player. His skills are far better than those with perceived more talent that grew up in an Aussie rules state. Bert Newton once said 'I like the boy'!

I trust moonface