Round 3 Trades

[Axly]

I think option 3 is clearly the best of those.
Not sure why you're keen to bring in either Garlett or Barry though. If I had viable, affordable options they'd be the first of my rookies to go.

Cheers!

What other MiD rookies should I be looking at?
Currently rookies I have:

DEF: Naughton, Murray, Finlayson, Doedee, Murphy

MiD: Kelly, Holman, Banfield, Brayshaw, Clark

FWD: ZGL, Fritsch, Ryan, D.Fogarty

[emoji16]

 

[AN1611]

Naughton to murphy
Bell to mclean
1 forward rookie of fristch or liam ryan
3 mid rookies - kelly holman brayshaw

Or

Naughton to Murphy
Bell to cogz
2 forward rookies from fristch,ryan and garlett
Mid rookies: kelly holman (brayshaw on bench)

Currently leaning towards mclean as he is more chance of a top 8 fwd than cogz a top 10mid
What do you guys think?

 

[Jonzi]

Option 1
Out: Crouch and Brayshaw/Naughton
In: Danger and Barry/Murphy
19.5k left

Option 2
Out: Crouch and ZGL
In: McLean and Barry
234k and 5 premo fwd

 

[Squiba]

I'm going to be tight for cash Gen now Langdon is out. Have non-playing rookies in Keefe, Ahern and Langdon and Cameron on every line. Need to use trades on more pressing issues, while reserving trades for later.

Honestly hoping Danger does a shoulder or something and scrapes out a 9 or 10 pointer, before coming back a week too early and doing it again. At this point I'll have to wait till after the bye at best otherwise.

 

[Squiba]

Option 1
Out: Crouch and Brayshaw/Naughton
In: Danger and Barry/Murphy
19.5k left

Option 2
Out: Crouch and ZGL
In: McLean and Barry
234k and 5 premo fwd

Option 1 every day of the week.

 

[hoddo]

Cheers!

What other MiD rookies should I be looking at?
Currently rookies I have:

DEF: Naughton, Murray, Finlayson, Doedee, Murphy

MiD: Kelly, Holman, Banfield, Brayshaw, Clark

FWD: ZGL, Fritsch, Ryan, D.Fogarty

[emoji16]

That's the problem as the cheaper options are either scoring badly and/or have poor JS. If you trade in Bonner then your mid rookie probably has to be Barry, Garlett, Fogarty(Geel) or O'Connor. I have a big opinion of O'Connor but he was a late inclusion last week so his JS is very shaky. He would allow you to move Finlayson between defence and the midfield though. Bottom line is that it's a risk. Any or all of them could be dropped at any time.

 

[bUCKET__]

So you selected him in your original team expecting to get some bad games, suspensions and a good average.
Now your trading him because you got a bad game, a suspension and a good average (94).

Definitely a hold for me.

The most rational plans can fall apart when you finally get there and feel what it is like. Otherwise, why would anyone do something as stupid as invest time in supercoach, or marriage?

But yeah, I'm probably holding too. Only after I imaginary trade him out of my team in every conceivable way before lockout

 

[hoddo]

The most rational plans can fall apart when you finally get there and feel what it is like. Otherwise, why would anyone do something as stupid as invest time in supercoach, or marriage?

But yeah, I'm probably holding too. Only after I imaginary trade him out of my team in every conceivable way before lockout

I'd love to quote that, but I'm really not game to

 

[Hai_Newman]

Oh...i like her. Note to Board, please phrase your questions to Judd Magic appropriately.

OK I'm first...
Judd_Magic can your splendid Trade Genie show us her cute puppies, thanks in advance.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I think he is.
I remember this same question last year in regards to otten and Hampton.

Wasn't the question also of Newman? ......is he a must get ? ......i said nah

 

[Judd_Magic]

Oh...i like her. Note to Board, please phrase your questions to Judd Magic appropriately.

LOL!

I will do my best to answer all questions with the Judd_Magic 8 ball.

I use it when making a decision on my own trades and it rarely lets me down....

 

[Tuco]

LOL!

I will do my best to answer all questions with the Judd_Magic 8 ball.

I use it when making a decision on my own trades and it rarely lets me down....

Studies have proven men think better after...um...the 'correct' visuals.

50k here i come.

 

[Judd_Magic]

OK I'm first...
Judd_Magic can your splendid Trade Genie show us her cute puppies, thanks in advance.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Ive considered hibberd to shaw but ill absolutely kick myself if he spuds it up again. Started with him last year and now ive possibly burned myself again with the wrong high priced defender.

Funny thing is Yeo was my D1 most of the preseason where as hibberd was my d3. Come lockout Hibberd is there but Yeo isnt d'oh

Yeap, I'm feeling exactly the same...

No ****'n way!!

I just can't make myself trade the evil burnman in, it still hurts man...

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Options

Hibberd to Heater
Naughton to Bonner

Or.

Hibberd to Heater
ZGL to Ryan

In leaning towards option 1. Thoughts?

 

[Hai_Newman]

Here2tellyouwhy its happening....

 

[Andrewy]

The most rational plans can fall apart when you finally get there and feel what it is like. Otherwise, why would anyone do something as stupid as invest time in supercoach, or marriage?

But yeah, I'm probably holding too. Only after I imaginary trade him out of my team in every conceivable way before lockout

hahahaha

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Yeap, I'm feeling exactly the same...

No ****'n way!!

I just can't make myself trade the evil burnman in, it still hurts man...

Lolz at gif

 

[toxic]

 

[Walshy_The_Goat]

Was going to trade Brayshaw out for Barry this week to hand me $80k and help build bank for Danger.

Is it more worthwhile waiting and week, missing out on Barry and trading Brayshaw after his first price rise to someone like O’Connor, who will be on the bubble (provided he plays this weekend). The other advantage is O’Connor is dual position DEF/MID, allowing me to swing Finlayson if need be.

Does anyone know of Brayshaw’s projected price rise?

 

[Girthquake]

Was going to trade Brayshaw out for Barry this week to hand me $80k and help build bank for Danger.

Is it more worthwhile waiting and week, missing out on Barry and trading Brayshaw after his first price rise to someone like O’Connor, who will be on the bubble (provided he plays this weekend). The other advantage is O’Connor is dual position DEF/MID, allowing me to swing Finlayson if need be.

Does anyone know of Brayshaw’s projected price rise?

$28,500 if he scores his 60 projected

 

[Blackhawk42]

Only went Brandon Ellis to Bonner. 298k in the bank. Considered trading Sicily for Naughton to have over 500k to spend, but saving the trades while my team is performing is well seems the better choice. Always run out of trades too early but i've usually made 4 by now. Only 1 so far this season.

 

[Significant]

Is it worth going Hibberd > Shaw instead of Simpson to fund Naughton > Bonner?

If I did swap Hibberd > Simpson my only other option would be to trade Sicily or Lobb down to Bonner and keep about $200k in the kitty

 

[toxic]

Bonner = the 2018 burnman

Everyone aboard the burn train

 

[Andrewy]