Trades Round 3 trades

[Son_Of_God29]

Round 2 Trade.

Dangerfield > Mitchell


Round 3 Trades

Cripps > Selwood

H. Jones > Warner

85k left in bank






Thoughts?

 

[stevebbb]

Narrowed down to two options, Phillips and Taranto can stay. Neale can't - see you when you're 500k campaigner.

1. Neale -> Titch, Bruhn -> Impey
2. Neale -> Brayshaw/Ridley, Bruhn -> Tex.

Nice trades either way

I even think you have a third option, Brayshaw/Ridley + Impey, save the cash for an early upgrade.

 

[SC fish]

Round 2 Trade.

Dangerfield > Mitchell


Round 3 Trades

Cripps > Selwood

H. Jones > Warner

85k left in bank


View attachment 1090229



Thoughts?

Selwood is a nice price but will he be managed through the season?

 

[Sun of a Biatch]

Disagree with this. I think one non-playing rookie is fine as long as they look like getting a decent crack at it, like Downie.

Yep. Need rookies to trade down to.

 

[Barnzy]

Pies might bring in Greenwood for the tag. Levi was one of the best taggers in the comp for a short period of time, not sure if he's still got it, especially with his age and after a knee, but it'll be interesting to see.

I'll believe it when I see it.

Collingwood playing hard tags or any tag at all is pretty rare.

 

[Shinboner1]

Round 2 Trade.

Dangerfield > Mitchell


Round 3 Trades

Cripps > Selwood

H. Jones > Warner

85k left in bank


View attachment 1090229



Thoughts?

I don't mind the selwood trade and think he'll do ok. Obviously scoring well atm.
The only issue is as the season goes on I don't think he'll be a top 8-10 scorer and that's who id be looking to bring into my side as a keeper.
You might be better suited using that cash on a defender that you can swing via A FYFE into the mids.
They are around the 500k mark but wont be for very long.

 

[JRyan23]

No Cookies | The Advertiser

No Cookies

www.adelaidenow.com.au

Can’t see the post, but reporting Neale hurt at training, probably click bait but yeah

Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Saints_Man]

Gaff to Brayshaw or Gaff to Ridley (Clark into the mids)?

Already have Lloyd, Daniel, Laird and Short as premos in defence and Macrae, Merrett, Titch and Dunkley as my premos in the midfield.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Am I the only one thinking Butters is just going to be this years Rozee??

Butters 2021 - Rd 1 - 98, Rd 2 - 163. Ave 131.

Rozee 2020 - Rd 1 - 125, Rd 2 - 145. Ave 135. 2020 average - 70.1

 

[SC fish]

Gaff to Brayshaw or Gaff to Ridley (Clark into the mids)?

Already have Lloyd, Daniel, Laird and Short as premos in defence and Macrae, Merrett, Titch and Dunkley as my premos in the midfield.

Brayshaw and Ridley both great trade ins. Which suits your byes better?

 

[Hava Alle]

Am I the only one thinking Butters is just going to be this years Rozee??

Butters 2021 - Rd 1 - 98, Rd 2 - 163. Ave 131.

Rozee 2020 - Rd 1 - 125, Rd 2 - 145. Ave 135. 2020 average - 70.1

Butters averaged near 90 last year and is destined for more midfield minutes. Also Butters doesn't have a foot issue.

 

[Barnzy]

Am I the only one thinking Butters is just going to be this years Rozee??

Butters 2021 - Rd 1 - 98, Rd 2 - 163. Ave 131.

Rozee 2020 - Rd 1 - 125, Rd 2 - 145. Ave 135. 2020 average - 70.1

No reason to think Butters averages less than last year's 87.

Natural improvement should see 95-100. Although people bringing him in expecting a 110 average will be disappointed.

Butters is still a half forward who pushes up the ground a bit but not as much as you'd ideally like. He is not a mid. Works great when he can feast on shit teams which Port excel at. Against good teams I can still see some days where he scores 70-80 pushing his average back down a bit.

 

[Anythings_sipposible]

Cripps and Sharp > Tex and D Howard (++ pp)

Or Cripps and Sharp > Bowes and Impey (+pp)

Or Hold Cripps (neutral pp)

Or Cripps > Brayshaw ( no pp)

 

[Spanish Sahara]

77k in the bank.

At this stage thinking no trades. Have all the rookies and no real obvious trades elsewhere that I can see. Opinions welcome though!

 

[SC fish]

Cripps and Sharp > Tex and D Howard (++ pp)

Or Cripps and Sharp > Bowes and Impey (+pp)

Or Hold Cripps (neutral pp)

Or Cripps > Brayshaw ( no pp)

Option 2 or 4

 

[talkingparrot]

Round 2 trades:

danger to butters
Rowell to macrae

couldn’t have worked out better

round 3 trades:
As appealing as tex and Impey are I’m still missing Warner so it’s going to most likely be

Caldwell to warner
Dow to Jordan
326k in the bank

 

[Pocket Aces]

Bit random, but Hawkers:
What is up with Worpel?
Don’t have him but honestly didn’t mind the pick / grabbing him in draft, what has happened with him?
Played out of position? Injured? Just down on form?
Rate him but at least SC-wise he’s miles of it.

His best year was when Mitchell was out, less of the sc pie to go around now as Mitchell takes a big chunk of that, we are probably bottom 4 this year as well so less points to begin with.

 

[Saints_Man]

Brayshaw and Ridley both great trade ins. Which suits your byes better?

round 12: Titch
round 13: Dusty, short, Macrae, Merrett, Daniel, Dunkley
round 14: Gawn, Grundy, Laird, Lloyd

Yeah so probably bringing in Brayshaw since he has that rd 14 bye. Will be looking to trade in Ridley after his bye.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Neale >>> Brayshaw

Docherty >>> Bowes

Leaves me with $495k in the bank and I don't think my team is any worse off.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I have 2 questions..

Do I trade Dow to Warner?

Which would then leave me with enough $ to go Taranto to Brayshaw..

Is it worth it?

As fast as your little fingers can tap away at that keyboard, complete the trade ......do not hesitate

 

[GT619]

I'm open to all options

 

[Petrify]

16k in the bank. Forced to trade Danger + Rowell, need to trade Draper + Caldwell.

Main options being considered:

A) Draper + Caldwell to Butters + Meek + 148k in bank (Flynn/Meek to R2 feels like the best option for me since I have taranto + phillips to worry about too)
B) Draper + Caldwell to Nicnat + Warner + 5.9k in bank (worried about Nicnats durability and having 3 swans rookies up fwd)
C) Draper + Caldwell to Lycett + Impey + 10k in bank (not a huge believer Lycett keeps these scores up)
D) Taranto + Caldwell to Oliver + Warner + 18k in bank (solve Draper problem next week and keep Flynn at R2. 3 swan rookie problem still)
E) Taranto + Caldwell to Dunkley + Impey + 46k in bank (move a DPP to mid and put dunkley up forward)
F) Taranto + Caldwell to Butters + Jordon + 223k in bank (next week should be able to upgrade draper to Grundy)

I'm in a world of hurt and have a million options for trades

 

[Andrew Birch]

I'm open to all options View attachment 1090287

Neale > Ridley via Laird to M4
Caldwell > Dusty

Gives you an extra premo.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

I am really torn with what to do this week... Oscar McIrnenry alrady ruled out.. considering trading him for Meek and then using the additional $ to change Menandue to Bowes.. Anyone got a better idea?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

View attachment 1090282

16k in the bank. Forced to trade Danger + Rowell, need to trade Draper + Caldwell.

Main options being considered:

A) Draper + Caldwell to Butters + Meek + 148k in bank (Flynn/Meek to R2 feels like the best option for me since I have taranto + phillips to worry about too)
B) Draper + Caldwell to Nicnat + Warner + 5.9k in bank (worried about Nicnats durability and having 3 swans rookies up fwd)
C) Draper + Caldwell to Lycett + Impey + 10k in bank (not a huge believer Lycett keeps these scores up)
D) Taranto + Caldwell to Oliver + Warner + 18k in bank (solve Draper problem next week and keep Flynn at R2. 3 swan rookie problem still)
E) Taranto + Caldwell to Dunkley + Impey + 46k in bank (move a DPP to mid and put dunkley up forward)
F) Taranto + Caldwell to Butters + Jordon + 223k in bank (next week should be able to upgrade draper to Grundy)

I'm in a world of hurt and have a million options for trades

Hold Taranto. He's not hurting you for the moment.