Round 3 trades

[GotTheGoodes]

Byrnes to Kennedy or Macaffer to Kennedy? (option 2 leaves me with less cash obviously)

I don't mind Byrnes as a player but as a fantasy option I'm not sold. Macaffer will at least give you a more consistent output IMO. Tough otpions though mate. Good luck.

 

[Lotch]

Karnezis to Dwyer...

Yes or No

Already have Neade on field and Macaffer on the bench

Struggling to decide.

 

[StoneX]

Thinking Karnezis to Dwyer and Vlaustin to Heath... Everything else is pretty good. Roughy is the only other minor issue but he can hang out for now First 2 trades and everyone playing except Macaffer who can come on if Coxy gets 150+

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Karnezis to Dwyer...

Yes or No

Already have Neade on field and Macaffer on the bench

Struggling to decide.

Yes. Wait no..... No Yes. Yes no. No Yes. Yes No. No.... Yes.... Get me...

 

[Danco]

Karnezis to Dwyer...

Yes or No

Already have Neade on field and Macaffer on the bench

Struggling to decide.

Yes... puts you in the same position as me

I went Karny to Dwyer. Have Neade on field and Mac on bench.

 

[Raveneyes]

Early focus is cash, cash & more cash.

So I traded Ryder to Leuenberger, avoiding Ryder's drop and making 200k+ in the process.

Now that Ryder has kicked a 40 point goal for 120+, Looey will need to ton up for me.
I am confident he can!

 

[Knighta21]

Early focus is cash, cash & more cash.

So I traded Ryder to Leuenberger, avoiding Ryder's drop and making 200k+ in the process.

Now that Ryder has kicked a 40 point goal for 120+, Looey will need to ton up for me.
I am confident he can!

yeah Ryders 145 means he only lost about 20k... EEK! could have waited a week for Luey

 

[TheBuzz]

Am I nuts for:

A) keeping Karnezis & trading out Macaffer? ( will be hard for Macaffer to break back in ahead of other Pies waiting to return)

B) not wanting to trade in Josh J Kennedy ( I know he's playin the Dees & his price is sure to rise, but he's burnt me before.)

 

[Judd_Magic]

Am I nuts for:

A) keeping Karnezis & trading out Macaffer? ( will be hard for Macaffer to break back in ahead of other Pies waiting to return)

B) not wanting to trade in Josh J Kennedy ( I know he's playin the Dees & his price is sure to rise, but he's burnt me before.)

Crazy you are on B)

 

[GOAUS!]

Yes. Wait no..... No Yes. Yes no. No Yes. Yes No. No.... Yes.... Get me...

Hi Shane Watson.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Got Pittard already, Hmmm yeah Brown is an option too. Again he is in that group so you would go Brown over both of these?

Sorry I did'nt get back to you (i had to shoot off to work) yeah i think brown has good js i am thinking off getting him for a non playing rookie.

 

[mdippa]

Koby Stevens to Dwyer for me. Having 30 trades made my decision easier.

 

[Raveneyes]

yeah Ryders 145 means he only lost about 20k... EEK! could have waited a week for Luey

I did want Leuy for the cash jump, and wasn't sold on which forwards were gonna dominate, and I already had JJK, LeCras and the gun rookies. So Luey was en easy choice.

But I guarantee that if I held Ryder, he would have stunk and scored 70 odd, then dropped 70 or 80k.
That's supercoach for you!
Sometimes the trade works, sometimes it fails.

 

[Kadog]

Yep. Hindsight is a wonderful thing. I traded Karni & Tex and for a while I was seriously considering JJK & Fyfe.
My boner for Watson and the fact that every man and his dog has JJK, got in the way so I went Watson & Lee.

Big mistake. Left alot of points on the board. Fyfe 129, JJK 136....Watson 66 Lee 59 bench

 

[Krujan]

Traded out Dangerfield (84) for Westhoff (150). Very happy with the extra points, but even happier with the 120k difference in money made/lost. Danger lost 54k whilst Westhoff made 64k with another huge price increase on the cards this week. My best trade of the season so far. Just stoked having the extra 200k made from that 1 trade in the bank to play with now.

 

[Adz]

Who's a good swap for LeCras?

 

[GOAUS!]

Who's a good swap for LeCras?

Why would you want to swap him for?

 

[Adz]

Woops, meant Waters!

 

[GOAUS!]

Woops, meant Waters!

Hanley is the one that immediately springs to mind.

 

[Patty Healey]

Hanley is the one that immediately springs to mind.

Hanley or Birchall is best if you can afford him.

 

[toxic]

Woops, meant Waters!

Head overseas to Scotland

 

[Adz]

Already have Hanley and wouldn't go anywhere near old man Scotland.

 

[Bollox]

If he scores say a 100 this week and his rnd 1 score rolls off...whats the downside on Gazza ?
Blue horseshoe sells "avoid the rush, SELL SELL SELL !!"

He's washed up i tell ya..finished. Been exposed

p.s. Will be shopping around for a reasonably priced used Ablett in a cpl of weeks.

 

[toxic]

Already have Hanley and wouldn't go anywhere near old man Scotland.

Why do people rate on age?? he is durable and averages arround the 100 each and every season and reasonably consistent to boot....
Dean Cox is 31 but no-one questions his age

 

[Patty Healey]

Why do people rate on age?? he is durable and averages arround the 100 each and every season and reasonably consistent to boot....
Dean Cox is 31 but no-one questions his age

I think there are better options than Scotland at that price. EG> Birchall.

But yep agree, people should not be rated on age but more so scoring ability obviously.