Round 6 Trades

[WaynesWorld19]

Dustbin is like the 90th ranked midfielder for total points and 70th ranked for average...... He can EAD the stupid campaigner.

Yet 6 weeks ago, he was one of the first players picked ......loyalty is such a fragile commodity

 

[Benno_900]

I'd be looking to off-load all of those spuds sooner than later. I never had Burgo & Balta and thankfully turfed Scott & Setters already. Bench rookies need to be either making $$$ every week or making themselves useful by not playing at all.

Burgess is pissing me off by staying in the team.

Been hanging to loop these defence rookies all season.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

there's some talk of a role change to defense amongst Dee's supporters.

thoughts?

You mean Oscar McDonald is finally getting dumped ?

 

[PoopingHindi]

You mean Oscar McDonald is finally getting dumped ?

Oscar getting dumped is last weeks news

 

[Gene Simmons]

How do these trades sound?

Clark -> Lockhart
Constable -> Rockliff (M7)

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

and here I was thinking it was just Dark Sharks way of asking Moustachio out on a date.

They're already on a first name basis

 

[mochacinolatte]

How do these trades sound?

Clark -> Lockhart
Constable -> Rockliff (M7)

Do no trade Constable. Still has like 90k to make.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Oscar getting dumped is last weeks news

Oh, is he already out of the side ?? .....i just concentrate each week on SC prospects, so I wouldn't have noticed

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Ouch ! ..... I see your problem here .....a distrust of your own gut feel

Can I suggest you ask Here2tellyouwhy for his opinion ....and then do the opposite

But my opinion is puppies and to win SC...

 

[RoughysMullet]

So can someone decide for me whether I get Ross or Baker or both?? Thanks

 

[Gene Simmons]

Do no trade Constable. Still has like 90k to make.

Cheers, alternatively I could do:

Collins -> Lockhart
Atkins -> Rockliff

Atkins to Rockliff is a no brainer, however Collins has excellent JS so i am hesitant to pull the trigger on him.... Thoughts?

 

[Plugger35]

This is another round I wish I had 3 trades to trade in Hore, Ross and Baker.

I wouldn't have had this problem though if I didn't panic trade Hore to Wilkie after Rd 1 when Hore got dropped.

 

[Papa Caz]

I'd be looking to off-load all of those spuds sooner than later. I never had Burgo & Balta and thankfully turfed Scott & Setters already. Bench rookies need to be either making $$$ every week or making themselves useful by not playing at all.

Holding balta has been named and might play more back line this week just needs more TOG, burgess also playing back this week with Colbert back will help him alot.

Scotts BE isn't to high no point trading and setterfield is the same.

 

[Bollox]

So can someone decide for me whether I get Ross or Baker or both?? Thanks

No,
but get Ross*





* If I'm wrong, happy to be forever hated and abused. You did ask though.

 

[Red Syrah]

Thoughts on Sheppard as an upgrade target?

considering bringing in a D4/5 to move on a rookie. Sheppard averaging 100 and scores are improving. Can he keep the scoring going?

Or Caleb Daniel instead (via Moore)

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Why are not many considering baker, has a negative 80 odd break even and seems to have good job security and good scoring ability with 2 scores around 90. Should make a lot of cash or am I missing something

 

[Barnzy]

Holding balta has been named and might play more back line this week just needs more TOG, burgess also playing back this week with Colbert back will help him alot.

Scotts BE isn't to high no point trading and setterfield is the same.

Balta won't play back.

 

[Barnzy]

So can someone decide for me whether I get Ross or Baker or both?? Thanks

Baker. Can play forward if Graham and Cotchin come back. Ross can only play midfield. Scores slightly better and he's been in the system longer (fitter).

 

[WaynesWorld19]

So can someone decide for me whether I get Ross or Baker or both?? Thanks

Really hard to give serious advice, without seeing your team .....the advice depends on your team situation, # of trades ...and scoring at present

 

[Dark Sharks]

Too many campaigners talking me back into sexy Rockpig.

Nup nup nup, it'd mean chucking Kentstable on the bench, and that just won't do fam.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Holding balta has been named and might play more back line this week just needs more TOG, burgess also playing back this week with Colbert back will help him alot.

Scotts BE isn't to high no point trading and setterfield is the same.

Could last weeks game by Balta, just give him the confidence to score more

 

[Bollox]

Why are not many considering baker, has a negative 80 odd break even and seems to have good job security and good scoring ability with 2 scores around 90. Should make a lot of cash or am I missing something

costs 40-50K more than we like to pay for a downgrade, and our rooks haven't matured yet to get good cash.
no other reason other than his few crappy games last year.
its a lottery between ross and baker
JS about the same...ask two tiges fans and they'll differ on who is likely to get more games

 

[hoddo]

there's some talk of a role change to defense amongst Dee's supporters.
thoughts?

Seems a real possibility. Melbourne have lost 2 players from defence, (Jetta and JWagner), and the ins are players who usually play in mid/fwd positions. Garlett will be the small forward, so it seems likely Lockhart will go back.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

costs 40-50K more than we like to pay for a downgrade, and our rooks haven't matured yet to get good cash.
no other reason other than his few crappy games last year.
its a lottery between ross and baker
JS about the same...ask two tiges fans and they'll differ on who is likely to get more games

If you do Moore to baker it makes about 170k and baker is due to go up 70k this week, it’s a risk but could be worth it

 

[Bollox]

Thoughts on Sheppard as an upgrade target?

considering bringing in a D4/5 to move on a rookie. Sheppard averaging 100 and scores are improving. Can he keep the scoring going?

Or Caleb Daniel instead (via Moore)

Plenty better options than Sheppard. He's going alright at the moment but not enuff to believe its anything other than a good patch, and there's always plenty of those happening that draw the eye. Daniel a better bet long term i reckon.