Round 7 Trades

[Juddy88]

Don't know their current prices but I would go Hodge.

Both good though.

 

[foley4brownlow]

Don't know their current prices but I would go Hodge.

Both good though.

hodge is 394 000 odd and murph 384 000 i rekan i mite go with murph hes gana run wild this year with all the attention on judd and stevens and hodgey wil cop a fair bit for the hawks as wel

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

thanks heaps man your a legend

No probs
Anytime

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Don't know their current prices but I would go Hodge.

Both good though.

Why Hodge.
I say Murphy by quite a distance. His BE is low and his price is average!

Great pick up

 

[ozwarne]

I'm going to go Schammer and Ellis out and Gilbee and Myers in and then next week Hill out B Johnson in. What does everyone think?

 

[AdamG03]

After finding out Symes isnt going to play, I will have to play Scott D. Thompson. Add to that the thought of Cox not playing, but if that happens, in my league match i would just have Leuenberger VS. Kruezer.

At the moment my Backs and Centres look like:
BAC: Milburn, Birchall, Mattner, Symes, Brett Jones, Gram, Ellis (Pfeiffer/SDT)
CTR: Corey, Cross, Salopek, Stevens, Johnstone, Palmer (Dyson/Bird)

Option 1 (Ibbotson on CTR Reserve):
OUT: Dyson, Johnstone
IN: Ibbotson, Kornes
Salary Cap Remaining: 87,800

Option 2 (Armitage on CTR Reserve):
OUT: Dyson, Johnstone
IN: Armitage, Kornes
Salary Cap Remaining: 95,700

Option 3 (Ibbotson starting as 7th Back with Pfeiffer/SDT Reserves):
OUT: Ellis, Johnstone
IN: Ibbotson, Kornes

I want to do whats best for my team. Rucks and Forwards are settled.
What option would people think is best based on Ellis/Dyson peaking?
Keep in mind Symes is a late withdrawal, however i want to keep him in my team.

Thanks
AdamG03

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

After finding out Symes isnt going to play, I will have to play Scott D. Thompson. Add to that the thought of Cox not playing, but if that happens, in my league match i would just have Leuenberger VS. Kruezer.

At the moment my Backs and Centres look like:
BAC: Milburn, Birchall, Mattner, Symes, Brett Jones, Gram, Ellis (Pfeiffer/SDT)
CTR: Corey, Cross, Salopek, Stevens, Johnstone, Palmer (Dyson/Bird)

Option 1 (Ibbotson on CTR Reserve):
OUT: Dyson, Johnstone
IN: Ibbotson, Kornes
Salary Cap Remaining: 87,800

Option 2 (Armitage on CTR Reserve):
OUT: Dyson, Johnstone
IN: Armitage, Kornes
Salary Cap Remaining: 95,700

Option 3 (Ibbotson starting as 7th Back with Pfeiffer/SDT Reserves):
OUT: Ellis, Johnstone
IN: Ibbotson, Kornes

I want to do whats best for my team. Rucks and Forwards are settled.
What option would people think is best based on Ellis/Dyson peaking?
Keep in mind Symes is a late withdrawal, however i want to keep him in my team.

Thanks
AdamG03

Well I dont know who is on your bench. If you dont want to show it publicly you can PM it too me.

If you do have centres playing whom are on your bench I would step away from trading Johnstone (Anyone know how long he is out for?)

IMO Option 3.
Its time for Ellis to go.
I was going to do Ellis --. Goddard this week but there were more important situations.

Hopefully in my situation Ellis has a ripper and Goddard has a down game.

 

[Drummond]

Hmmm whether to get Ibbotson or not. And in what position?

Back reserves are Pfeiffer and Hansen, mids Dyson and Houli.

I am getting a 0 in my defence due to Symes.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

I'm going to go Schammer and Ellis out and Gilbee and Myers in and then next week Hill out B Johnson in. What does everyone think?

Sounds great to me.
I just did Scott Selwood ---> Myers because it was an emergancy.

Also did Pfieffer ---> Ibbotson

 

[Still_Crowin23]

My 2 trades this week are:

Dyson > Armitage
Ellis > Goddard

Then that leaves me with the decision to play either Armitage or Ibbotson on the field? What do people think?

 

[Outburst]

cornes > shaw
thornton > goddard

 

[AdamG03]

Well I dont know who is on your bench. If you dont want to show it publicly you can PM it too me.

If you do have centres playing whom are on your bench I would step away from trading Johnstone (Anyone know how long he is out for?)

IMO Option 3.
Its time for Ellis to go.
I was going to do Ellis --. Goddard this week but there were more important situations.

Hopefully in my situation Ellis has a ripper and Goddard has a down game.

Sorry I thought I listed my reserves.
Back Reserves: Pfeiffer/Scott D Thompson
CTR Reserves: Dyson/Craig Bird (Palmer Starting as 6th midfielder)
Ruck Reserves: Leuenberger/West
FWD Reserves: Tippett/Gamble

And i wanted to get rid of Johnstone cos for me, Hes good, but I want Kornes in and Palmer and Stevens are nowhere near peaking.
Plus Johnstone is more inconsistent than Salopek.

 

[LemmingMaster]

If you planned to downgrade Pfeiffer who would you pick?

Proud?
Ibbo?
Myers?


They're potential replacements, if you can think of anyone else feel free to tell me. (I already have SD Thompson).

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

My 2 trades this week are:

Dyson > Armitage
Ellis > Goddard

Then that leaves me with the decision to play either Armitage or Ibbotson on the field? What do people think?

Thats a hard one!!!!!!!
Ummm...
I would go Ibbo

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

If you planned to downgrade Pfeiffer who would you pick?

Proud?
Ibbo?
Myers?


They're potential replacements, if you can think of anyone else feel free to tell me. (I already have SD Thompson).

I downgraded him to Ibbo and downgraded Selwood to Myers...

I think I would go Ibbo as he looks like he has deffiently seccured his spot in the side

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Sorry I thought I listed my reserves.
Back Reserves: Pfeiffer/Scott D Thompson
CTR Reserves: Dyson/Craig Bird (Palmer Starting as 6th midfielder)
Ruck Reserves: Leuenberger/West
FWD Reserves: Tippett/Gamble

And i wanted to get rid of Johnstone cos for me, Hes good, but I want Kornes in and Palmer and Stevens are nowhere near peaking.
Plus Johnstone is more inconsistent than Salopek.

True!
If you got my private message (and understood it) It says why I think option 3.

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Hey fellas

Got a sticky situation here

In that email with the recommend trades both of my midfielders are recommended in getting rid of

They being Griffen and Morton

Now I have 183600 in the bank

Here are my trade options, if you had the choice what would you do

Option 1:

Cale Morton > Armitage - Myers - Cotchin

Griffen > Jimmy Bartel

70 - 100k Remaining
Option 2:

Morton > Anyone under 401600

Option 3:

Griffen > Joel Corey

So what would you do?

 

[foley4brownlow]

Hey fellas

Got a sticky situation here

In that email with the recommend trades both of my midfielders are recommended in getting rid of

They being Griffen and Morton

Now I have 183600 in the bank

Here are my trade options, if you had the choice what would you do

Option 1:

Cale Morton > Armitage - Myers - Cotchin

Griffen > Jimmy Bartel

70 - 100k Remaining
Option 2:

Morton > Anyone under 401600

Option 3:

Griffen > Joel Corey

So what would you do?

go option 2 and jump aboard the murphy train as i wil be when i process the trade in a number of minutes

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Option 2 will leave me no 'ready' cash cows for upgrading Nicoski

With Griffen's B/E at 110 and playing against Sydney

Im not gonna take the chance

Now which midfielder should I get

Go for the best and get Joel Corey

or are there any roughie picks?

 

[Athomas]

How long is Symes out for?

I have Chad and only 1 playing Emergency.

I figure Symes had peaked and been good anyway, Morton has a high BE.

Morton to Browne
Symes to Goddard/Milburn

then next week
Jack/Bird to Murphy/Gun.


Thoughts?
How long is Symes out for?

 

[foley4brownlow]

Option 2 will leave me no 'ready' cash cows for upgrading Nicoski

With Griffen's B/E at 110 and playing against Sydney

Im not gonna take the chance

Now which midfielder should I get

Go for the best and get Joel Corey

or are there any roughie picks?

there are some good cheapies in mitchell hodge bruce swan and my man murphy

 

[longytap]

who reckons stanton will get tagged out of it by kornes this week?? might stick him on the pine. thoughts

 

[Athomas]

who reckons stanton will get tagged out of it by kornes this week?? might stick him on the pine. thoughts

Be stupid to put him on the Pine.

I have Kornes and Stanton... tough 1. Hope they both own

 

[Drummond]

How long is Symes out for?

I have Chad and only 1 playing Emergency.

I figure Symes had peaked and been good anyway, Morton has a high BE.

Morton to Browne
Symes to Goddard/Milburn

then next week
Jack/Bird to Murphy/Gun.


Thoughts?
How long is Symes out for?

Almost came up this week. All Stars game next week, he will only miss this week.

 

[Geelongs God.]

I need some extra dough. Which one would you go for?

OUT: Pfeiffer IN: Scott Thompson.
OUT: Tuck IN: Dave Myers.