MVP Round 9; Richmond VS Essendon

[yaco55]

5 Watson
4 Hibberd
3 Dempsey
2 Goddard
1 Hocking

 

[monty1104]

5. Watson
4. Hibberd
3. Dempsey
2. Stanton
1. Goddard.

 

[Summer Nights]

Number them Yaco.

 

[Bombers36]

5. Watson
4. Dempsey
3. Hibberd
2. Zakka
1. Heppell

 

[Knight Ryders]

5. Watson
4. Hibberd
3. Goddard
2. Dempsey
1. Zaharakis

Stants unlucky, but Zaka great when it counted early. Carlisle and Hooksy also awesome again

 

[eaglespremiers]

Sorry for the intrusion but were Stanton's 39 touches not particularly good?
Can't figure out how he could be left out of the votes.

 

[Bombers36]

Sorry for the intrusion but were Stanton's 39 touches not particularly good?
Can't figure out how he could be left out of the votes.

Maybe he deserves 1 or 2 votes but no more - he dropped 2 or 3 simple chest marks, and whilst he found plenty of the ball I don't think he was as good as at least 3 or 4 other on the ground

 

[Doss]

5. Watson
4. Dempsey
3. Hibberd
2. Stanton
1. Goddard

 

[Burzum]

5. Jobe
4. Hibberd
3. Hocking
2. Goddard
1. Dempsey

 

[Loonerty]

5. Watson
4. Stanton
3. Hibberd
2. Dempsey
1. Goddard

A lot of HM's. Kommer played well, as did Carlisle and Hooker.

 

[simoro1]

5. Watson (Why oh why did i not choose this week to make him my SC captain... )
4. Stants
3. Hibberd
2. Goddard
1. Dempsey

 

[mad_monkey_j]

5. Watson
4. Dempsey
3. Hibberd
2. Stanton
1. Goddard

 

[The Speaker]

5 - Watson
4 - Dempsey
3 - Hibberd
2 - Stanton
1 - Goddard

 

[eaglespremiers]

Maybe he deserves 1 or 2 votes but no more - he dropped 2 or 3 simple chest marks, and whilst he found plenty of the ball I don't think he was as good as at least 3 or 4 other on the ground

Thanks mate.
From what I saw of the game I thought he put in a really good 4 quarter effort.
From his 39 touches, 74.4% efficiency and 3 clangers, which suggests that he generally used the ball pretty well.
I realise that Watson was better, and Zaka as well (despite fading out a bit). Just not sure how someone with 29 effective touches could be only 6th-8th best on ground.

 

[Kong]

5) Watson
4) Hibberd
3) Goddard
2) Dempsey
1) Heppell

 

[hunterrory]

5. Watson
4. Hibberd
3. Hocking
2. Dempsey
1. Stanton

 

[monty1104]

Thanks mate.
From what I saw of the game I thought he put in a really good 4 quarter effort.
From his 39 touches, 74.4% efficiency and 3 clangers, which suggests that he generally used the ball pretty well.
I realise that Watson was better, and Zaka as well (despite fading out a bit). Just not sure how someone with 29 effective touches could be only 6th-8th best on ground.

They were effective, but not overly damaging. He played a lot of his kicks safe. Dempsey and Hibberd were much more damaging with their run and carry, IMO.

 

[rines]

5. Watson (has got to be the value bet for back to back Brownlows...)
4. Dempsey
3. Zaka
2. Hibberd
1. Goddard

Too close to call: Heppell, Stanton, Carlisle, Hooker,Kommer

 

[monty1104]

5. Watson (has got to be the value bet for back to back Brownlows...)
4. Dempsey
3. Zaka
2. Hibberd
1. Goddard

Too close to call: Heppell, Stanton, Carlisle, Hooker,Kommer

He'd have to be odd on you'd think, considering he is the only player in the running for back to back brownolws

 

[Summer Nights]

5. Watson
4. Hibberd
3. Dempsey
2. Goddard
1. Stanton

 

[Red Black and Blue]

5. Watson
4. Hibberd
3. Dempsey
2. Goddard
1. Zaharakis

 

[DONatron]

5. Watson
4. Hibberd
3. Dempsey
2. Goddard
1. Howlett

 

[NOTdapperdon]

5. Watson - Outstanding, this is what good captains do.
4. Hibberd - AA performance continues
3. Stanton - Love his gut running.
2. Dempsey - He plays, we are much better.
1. Hocking - Put a hold on both Deledio & Cotchin

Unlucky- Kommer, Carlisle, Goddard, Howlett & Zaharakis

0. Jack Riewoldt for being such a petulant bitch. I bet he's still whining he didn't get to kick that goal his team scored.

 

[Ben the Gooner]

5. Watson
4. Stanton
3. Goddard
2. Hocking
1. Hibberd

 

[Blind Turn]

5/ Watson - does something every time we need a lift.
4/ Dempsey - please don't be a nuffy again with Instagram.
3/ Hibberd - oh the jealousy of every club that missed this gem.
2/ Goddard - rounds us off as a team.
1/ Stanton - weight of disposals through sheer workrate gets him in ahead of Hocking who I found it very difficult to leave out. And I can't put Zaka in the votes until he can give us 4 qtrs of the damaging stuff he gave us in bursts tonight.