Remove this Banner Ad

Sack Malthouse

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Dave The Man

Dave The Man

Cancelled
Collingwood Magpies - Alan Didak 2009 Player Sponsor
Sep 17, 2006
9,697
12
Vic
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Storm,Victory,Blue Jays
Why:

Can't Coach
1 Style Of Play
Can't Improve Players
Can't Recruit the Right Players
Does not Make the Hard Descion

Any More?
 
So you havn't seen the way he has Thomas and Pendlebury going about it in their second seasons????

You don't think he has improved Cox as a player who was lucky to be picked up as a rookie.

You couldn't see how he lifted us with 3 first gamers last week.

Collingwood are lacking a few things player wise. But they are not lacking a good creative coach. I'm behind Malthouse. We are simply in a faze where we are seeing out the old and bringing in the new. Seriously we have all ready debuted 4 players this season.

Injuries also don't help.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Banned
  • #3
didaka said:
So you havn't seen the way he has Thomas and Pendlebury going about it in their second seasons????

You don't think he has improved Cox as a player who was lucky to be picked up as a rookie.

You couldn't see how he lifted us with 3 first gamers last week.

Collingwood are lacking a few things player wise. But they are not lacking a good creative coach. I'm behind Malthouse. We are simply in a faze where we are seeing out the old and bringing in the new. Seriously we have all ready debuted 4 players this season.

Injuries also don't help.
Click to expand...

I must admit his Drafting in the Last 2 Years has Been Good But Why Didn't we Have No Ruckman
 
Dave The Man said:
I must admit his Drafting in the Last 2 Years has Been Good But Why Didn't we Have No Ruckman
Click to expand...

You'll find thats the recruiting staff would be behind that. While he does have some say come draft day I don't think Mick in his very busy schedual would be able to travel the country each week looking for the best ruckman in the juniors.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Dave The Man said:
Why:

Can't Coach
1 Style Of Play
Can't Improve Players
Can't Recruit the Right Players
Does not Make the Hard Descion

Any More?
Click to expand...

When i saw this thread i knew it was going to be '' Dave The Fool ''
You unfortunately are a moron. The only thing worse than your opinion is your spelling and grammer.
 
Dave The Man said:
Why:

Can't Coach
1 Style Of Play
Can't Improve Players
Can't Recruit the Right Players
Does not Make the Hard Descion

Any More?
Click to expand...

You're pathetic...we lost to a full strength team with not much to write home about (Johnson, Clement our best out there coming back from injury, No Medhurst, Buckley, Didak, Holland).

I think, in some cases, we are lucky to be 2-2, and were a sniff away from being 3-1. I hate bandwagoners like you...if we make September, you'd be all aboard the Malthouse train.

I repeat...You're Pathetic!
 
Dave The Man said:
Dave will be taking a short break
Click to expand...

Sums it up really,

People like you just LOVE to see Collingwood lose so you and your mates can give it to the coach, the players, gee, even the supporters who actually support the team...I can only imagine if you went through the 58-90 era :rolleyes:
 
  • Thread starter
  • Banned
  • #9
Lonie_from_50 said:
Sums it up really,

People like you just LOVE to see Collingwood lose so you and your mates can give it to the coach, the players, gee, even the supporters who actually support the team...I can only imagine if you went through the 58-90 era :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

I have been Calling for MM sacking for 2 Years Now

And your the Type who thinks he is the Smartest Person in the World.
 
Dave The Man said:
I have been Calling for MM sacking for 2 Years Now

And your the Type who thinks he is the Smartest Person in the World.
Click to expand...

I was walking back to the car tonight annoyed with Malthouse, but I don't come onto BigFooty when I get home and write Sack the Coach after a 3-goal loss to a side with the best ruckman with possibly the best clearance player (Burgoyne). They were all class, and then their is Chad Cornes, who if he didn't play, we would've won!

Malthouse had a great style last year, and we were top 4...we lose a game, SACK THE COACH...it's ridiculous and repetitive.

Also, from your last post, if you don't get a holiday I will be amazed. We might start winning, you may get your privelages back, and start supporting the team, I dunno.
 
Lonie_from_50 said:
I was walking back to the car tonight annoyed with Malthouse, but I don't come onto BigFooty when I get home and write Sack the Coach after a 3-goal loss to a side with the best ruckman with possibly the best clearance player (Burgoyne). They were all class, and then their is Chad Cornes, who if he didn't play, we would've won!

Malthouse had a great style last year, and we were top 4...we lose a game, SACK THE COACH...it's ridiculous and repetitive.

Also, from your last post, if you don't get a holiday I will be amazed. We might start winning, you may get your privelages back, and start supporting the team, I dunno.
Click to expand...
We Were Fantastic in the 1st Half of Last Year and Ify at Best In the 2nd Half.

Thats not Crash Hot Coaching.

Mick is Alright But We Can get A better Coach.

People are Saying Roos in a Couple of Years:D
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Johnson#26 said:
Well, according to many...

Get a grip on things, Dave - it's four weeks in, we're 2-2, a handy start and something to build on. We were ok for 3.5 quarters.
Click to expand...

We were good for 2 and Bit quarters. The Last quarter was Disgusting
 
Dave The Man said:
We Were Fantastic in the 1st Half of Last Year and Ify at Best In the 2nd Half.

Thats not Crash Hot Coaching.

Mick is Alright But We Can get A better Coach.

People are Saying Roos in a Couple of Years:D
Click to expand...

Lets sack Mick after round 4 (hang on, when we lost in Perth by a couple you wanted Mick sacked then, so lets say round 2), lets just get Guy McKenna in to coach the rest of the year, or maybe Gavin Brown.

Malthouse is the sixth most successful coach in the VFL/AFL history, twice a premiership coach, and coached a team to 5 grand finals, coached a side to the finals 14 times...and Malthouse only got his side to finish 5th last season (despite being expected to finish bottom 4).

It is a stupid call, which you have done twice out of two possible losses. You have only been on this forum for four games...we've lost two games, you've asked for him to be sacked after both games. We win one...where's Dave?, we win again...where's Dave? where's the Sack MM thread after a win?

:rolleyes:
 
Dave The Man said:
We Were Fantastic in the 1st Half of Last Year and Ify at Best In the 2nd Half.

Thats not Crash Hot Coaching.

Mick is Alright But We Can get A better Coach.

People are Saying Roos in a Couple of Years:D
Click to expand...

Not that i really care for your opinion, but im sure ill get it anyways (this is also open to everyone else) At this point in time, is there a better proven option?
 
Dave The Man said:
We Were Fantastic in the 1st Half of Last Year and Ify at Best In the 2nd Half.

Thats not Crash Hot Coaching.

Mick is Alright But We Can get A better Coach.

People are Saying Roos in a Couple of Years:D
Click to expand...

ROOS!? You'd rather someone who coachs the shittest,ugliest,boringest brand of footy coach Collingwood rather then Mick Malthouse?

Roos tactic maybe working but no one wants to see shithouse footy like them!
 
Lonie_from_50 said:
Lets sack Mick after round 4 (hang on, when we lost in Perth by a couple you wanted Mick sacked then, so lets say round 2), lets just get Guy McKenna in to coach the rest of the year, or maybe Gavin Brown.

Malthouse is the sixth most successful coach in the VFL/AFL history, twice a premiership coach, and coached a team to 5 grand finals, coached a side to the finals 14 times...and Malthouse only got his side to finish 5th last season (despite being expected to finish bottom 4).

It is a stupid call, which you have done twice out of two possible losses. You have only been on this forum for four games...we've lost two games, you've asked for him to be sacked after both games. We win one...where's Dave?, we win again...where's Dave? where's the Sack MM thread after a win?

:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Life as a Supporter:rolleyes:

I only don't say Sack Mick after a Win because It would sound Stupid.

I would be Happy if Gavin or Guy Coached for the Rest of the year. I wouldn't care
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Lonie_from_50 said:
You're pathetic...we lost to a full strength team with not much to write home about (Johnson, Clement our best out there coming back from injury, No Medhurst, Buckley, Didak, Holland).
Click to expand...


Brogan, Pearce and Motlop would all be considered first 22 players for Port, while Adam Thomson and Troy Chaplin would be in most Port supporters' best 22 also.

Not trolling, but we weren't quite at full strength.
 
Dave The Man said:
Life as a Supporter:rolleyes:

I only don't say Sack Mick after a Win because It would sound Stupid.

I would be Happy if Gavin or Guy Coached for the Rest of the year. I wouldn't care
Click to expand...

Yes, it almost would almost sound as stupid if you said it after a Collingwood loss which happened in 5 mins of football. (5/120!)

As I said, you love to see the Pies lose just so you can have a rant about how shit we are. Earlier in the year you were telling everyone that we'd be up there. We win, you can't spot the negatives, just going with the flow, and we lose...Oh, brickwall, Collingwood Suck, Collingwood Suck...pathetic.

And everyone on here is as disgraced as I am with the bullshit after a loss...no wonder Sheedy called us nuff nuffs.
 
PJ Power said:
Brogan, Pearce and Motlop would all be considered first 22 players for Port, while Adam Thomson and Troy Chaplin would be in most Port supporters' best 22 also.

Not trolling, but we weren't quite at full strength.
Click to expand...

Then again, all it took was your three All-Australians. Lade, Burgoyne and Cornes...while ours were on the sidelines or coming back from injury.

And by "all it took" I mean, to get the difference between four points and no points...or Collingwood are the best or Sack MM/How shit are we
 
Lonie_from_50 said:
Yes, it almost would almost sound as stupid if you said it after a Collingwood loss which happened in 5 mins of football. (5/120!)

As I said, you love to see the Pies lose just so you can have a rant about how shit we are. Earlier in the year you were telling everyone that we'd be up there. We win, you can't spot the negatives, just going with the flow, and we lose...Oh, brickwall, Collingwood Suck, Collingwood Suck...pathetic.

And everyone on here is as disgraced as I am with the bullshit after a loss...no wonder Sheedy called us nuff nuffs.
Click to expand...
What Like People Like You
 
Johnson#26 said:
No, Dave.

Calling for the head of the coach after a last quarter fade out in wet conditions is ludicrous [read: not constructive]. Is it all MM's fault? It's easy to pick the top target, but answer me this, Dave - what would you do if you were MM? What moves would you have made that he didn't?
Click to expand...

Put Fraser Foward and Play Richards and Bryan as Rucks
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Sack Malthouse

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top