Sam Mitchell vs Chappy as a centre?

[blaisee]

MItchell 393800 average 96
Chappy 377200 average 95

I would like to leave chappy for a trade in the fwds but

Tippet and Gamble are not yet ripe.

Purely as centres who would you pick.

Rest of team looks like this

Backs CCornes, Symes Shaw Bradshaw B Jones Moore Hansen Selwood Wona
Centre Gablett Cross Hayes Kornes Palmer Ibbotson Houli Browne
Rucks Cox Simmo Leuey Krueze
Fwds Roo Pav BJ Buddy Burton Brown Tippett Gamble Jetta

Plan to do Hansen to Myers and Houli to Mitchell/Chappy

DOnt know who to choose 130k in the bank 13 trades left

 

[Big Kitty]

Grab Mitchell for midfield and leave Chappy for forward line.

 

[brent-83]

Houli OUT Swan IN.

Chapman next week in the forwards.

 

[blaisee]

So you reckon swan> mitchell/chappy?

 

[brent-83]

Yes. Chapman in the midfield is like DT blasphemy.

Chapman needs to be in the forward line. Swan > Mitchell for sure.

 

[blaisee]

Yes. Chapman in the midfield is like DT blasphemy.

Chapman needs to be in the forward line. Swan > Mitchell for sure.

I agree with the chapman thing.

BUt do you mind if I ask Why Swan> Mitchell.

 

[Cat for Life]

Look back at their averages the last few years and you'll see why.
Swan's game is made for DT, with plenty of marks and a penchant for kicking, also has a knack of finding space by himself and avoiding tags. Mitchell while a gun, does suffer when he is heavily tagged, and with this status as the leader of that midfield and his clearance ability will tend to attract them them more than Swan.

Also I think the break has done Swan good, nearing peak fitness now.

 

[Hirdy_5]

Save Chapman for the fowardline, Also Scotland is another option in the Mids, Very, Very cheap..

 

[Schulzenfest]

Scotland, Swan, Scott Thompson > Mitchell

 

[Ricketts]

No one is > Sam Mitchell i'm afraid.

 

[54Dogs]

To play Chappy in the mids would break DT rule 4.

Having said that, I traded out Chad 2 weeks ago which broke DT rule 1.

 

[54Dogs]

Save Chapman for the fowardline, Also Scotland is another option in the Mids, Very, Very cheap..

Was cheaper 3 weeks ago at 357K.

 

[54Dogs]

Look back at their averages the last few years and you'll see why.
Swan's game is made for DT, with plenty of marks and a penchant for kicking, also has a knack of finding space by himself and avoiding tags. Mitchell while a gun, does suffer when he is heavily tagged, and with this status as the leader of that midfield and his clearance ability will tend to attract them them more than Swan.

Also I think the break has done Swan good, nearing peak fitness now.

What he said.

Swan > Mitchell @ DT
Mitchell > Swan @ Aussie Rules

 

[happy_eagle]

What he said.

Swan > Mitchell @ DT
Mitchell > Swan @ Aussie Rules

and i suppose

DT > Aussie rules

 

[Jimhouse]

and i suppose

DT > Aussie rules

Yep

 

[Tippaz]

Dane Swan mate.

surely you're not basing it on the fact he plays Geelong this week

Mitchell will have to face em' in rd17 too ya know

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

Agree with the general sentiment that Swan is the best value at present.
But if you want to get Chapman then you probably want it to be this week. His be is ridiculously low (~60 iirc) so you probably want to get him sooner rather than later. He will probably increase in price by more than Rioli and Gamble combined.

 

[Cat for Life]

Agree with the general sentiment that Swan is the best value at present.
But if you want to get Chapman then you probably want it to be this week. His be is ridiculously low (~60 iirc) so you probably want to get him sooner rather than later. He will probably increase in price by more than Rioli and Gamble combined.

His b/e is 69 and Gamble's is 17 according to Wallsy's site, Gamble will still increase by more for this week at least. However, this is the week to get Chappy at his cheapest though.

 

[54Dogs]

His b/e is 69 and Gamble's is 17 according to Wallsy's site, Gamble will still increase by more for this week at least. However, last week was the week to get Chappy at his cheapest though.

Edited for accuracy Cats

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Id get Swan, spewing i chose Mitchell over Swan at the start of the year.

 

[pezz]

upgrading houli this week and have 403k to spend is marc murphy the best option? or maybe swan, mitchell or scotland... Im thinking they are all much the same...

any advice gotta make a good choice on this one

 

[Jeremias]

upgrading houli this week and have 403k to spend is marc murphy the best option? or maybe swan, mitchell or scotland... Im thinking they are all much the same...

any advice gotta make a good choice on this one

All of them are good choices and you can't really go wrong with any of them.

I love Murph but I am unsure whether he'll keep this up the whole season, he's only young remember.

The other 3 are all DT stars.

 

[pezz]

thanks for the thoughts, i think your right about murphy, might just toss a coin between mitchell and swan.
Felt so good to have a decent amount of money in the bank for a change, shame it never lasts to long