Scott West or Robert Harvey???

[ORTALANA07]

Currently who would you rather have???

I say, Westy by a mile

 

[cleveland]

Why the need to ask these questions.

Both champions but harvey has 2 brownlows (even though he didnt deserve 1)

 

[Astro_]

hasnt this been done?

start a thread asking why channel 7 have moved 24 to wednesday nights @ 10:30pm.

 

[wce4premiership]

currently, west easily.

 

[Bring-Back-Powell]

Robert Harvey by the length of the Flemington Straight.

West would be lucky to play for Werribee 2nd's.

 

[Fireballs]

Both champs, but Harvey. He is just so much more damaging.

 

[Claude Balls]

Currently who would you rather have???

I say, Westy by a mile

Of course you would, you're a Bulldog's supporter.

But rather than label you a pathetic joke, I will merely state that you are wrong.

 

[borgy]

At the moment West, he is still one of the best mids in the game, not taking anything away from Harvey though, he is still serviceable.

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Both champions but harvey has 2 brownlows...

Why do people always fall back on medals, flags and AA selections as arguments for one player over another? They prove nothing.

 

[Richo83]

hasnt this been done?

start a thread asking why channel 7 have moved 24 to wednesday nights @ 10:30pm.

Because it's s*** and no-one watches it.

Harvey for me. Done more and his best was better than West's. West's best season was probably 2000 or last year, Harvey in 1997 was amazing.

 

[HBK619]

Harvey, just because of the 2 brownlows and his amazingly consitent performences at his age.

 

[St 07]

I'm not even gonna say anything other than..why the hell move 24 to wednesday 10:30! good freakin question..i was hoping the beast would stay on tues/thurs like last time for the majority

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

Harvey has had a better career than West. No shame in that though Harvey has IMO had a better career than any other midfielder going around in the AFL, particularly now Voss has retired. He is the bee's knee's.

West is better now, but Harvey is still a damn fine player and if fully fit he is hopefully capable of dominating once again

 

[jnash196]

Now West but if I could go back in time to 1990 I would take Harvey.

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

both champions.


harvey cause im bias



harvey matchwinner - west not

 

[trueblue_91]

Has too be harvey, in his day he was unstoppable

 

[mudgeathon]

Why do people always fall back on medals, flags and AA selections as arguments for one player over another? They prove nothing.

What else do you use?

Statistics? .... That as you said would make Kane Cornes and Heath Scotland the best players in the league..

So if I was to compare Ben Cousins to Scott West, how would you compare them...Cousins is more decorated and has more awards [but you say they are pointless and prove nothing]

Not having a go at you, but just want to hee how you would compare players?

 

[G.O.B]

Well, seeing as West is at best a poor man's Harvey, I'll stick with the guy from Moorabin.

 

[nick_savo]

Currently anybody is going to say Westy,maybe you should of asked over the course of their careers or something.

 

[wce4premiership]

both champions.


harvey cause im bias



harvey matchwinner - west not

Harvey isn't really a match winner.

 

[cleveland]

Harvey isn't really a match winner.

When Harvs was in his hayday Stkilda were ******** apart from say 97/98

 

[Ando_4]

Currently who would you rather have???

I say, Westy by a mile

Currently yes but i'd take Harves at his best.