Phantom Draft Scotteydog's Phantom Draft Top 50 with extra's

[scotteydog]

1. R.Thilthorpe (Adel.)
2. L.McDonald (Roos)
3. JUH (bid) (WB)
4. DGB (Syd.)
5. E.Hollands (Haw)
6. B.Campbell (bid) (Syd.)
7. T.Bruhn (Gcs)
8. A.Perkins (Ess.)
9. N.O'Driscoll (Ess.
10. Z.Reid (Ess.)
11. L.Jones (bid) (PA)
12. W.Phillips (Adel.)
13. O.Henry (Gws)
14. N.Cox (Roos)
15. J.Carroll (Freeo)
16. H.Chapman (Gws)
17. R.McInnes (Coll)
18. K.Baldwin (Rich.
19. C.Downie (bid) (Haw)
20. F.McCrae (Melb.)
21. B.Cook (Melb.)
22. T.Powell (Coll.)
23. E.Gulden (Syd.)
24. B.Laurie (Gws)
25. Z.Dumesny (Adel.)
26. E.Ford (St.K) h.f\ Ins.Mid.
27. Z.Trew (Adel.)
28. B.Coleman (Bris.)
29. M.Heath (Gcs)
30. S.Neale (Ess.)
31. B.Walker (bid) (Freeo)
32. C.Poulter (Roos)
33. L.McMahon (Rich.)
34. C.Stone (Gcs)
35. Z.Maher (Carl.)
36. I.Winder (Roos)
37. J.Callow (Adel.)
38. L.Edwards (Gws)
39. S.Berry (Carl.)
40. M.Rioli Jnr. (bid) (Rich.)
41. J.Ginnivan (Adel.)
42. K.Lane (Gws)
43. S.Mitchell (Carl.)
44. B.Lake (Melb.)
45. M.Allison (Hawks)
46. J.Bowey (PA)
47. F.Rosman (Hawks)
48. O.Davis (Gee)
49. S.Collins (Bris.)
50. L.Kolar (WB)
? R.Angwin (Saints) h.b.f
? J.Cardillo (Saints) wing
? M.Pescad (Saints) h.f.f

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

Wouldn’t Brisbane select someone else at 28 and the use later picks to cover a bid for Coleman when it comes.

also gc no longer have picks 27,37

also Phillips pick 12

 

[scotteydog]

1. R.Thilthorpe (Adel.)
2. L.McDonald (Roos)
3. JUH (bid) (WB)
4. DGB (Syd.)
5. E.Hollands (Hawks)
6. B.Campbell (bid) (Syd.)
7. T.Bruhn (Gcs)
8. A.Perkins (Ess.)
9. N.O'Driscoll (Ess.
10. Z.Reid (Ess.)
11. L.Jones (bid) (PA)
12. W.Phillips (Adel.)
13. O.Henry (Gws)
14. N.Cox (Roos)
15. J.Carroll (Freeo)
16. H.Chapman (Gws)
17. R.McInnes (Coll)
18. B.Laurie (Gws)
19. T.Powell (Coll.)
20. C.Downie (bid) (Hawks)
21. K.Baldwin (Rich.)
22. F.McCrae (Melb.)
23. B.Cook (Melb.)
24. L.Edwards (Gws)
25. E.Ford (St.K)
26. E.Gulden (Bid) (Syd.)
27. L.Edwards (Gws)
28. Z.Dumesny (Adel.)
29. Z.Trew (Adel.)
30. B.Coleman (Bris.)
31. K.Lane (Gws)
32. M.Heath (Gee)
33. B.Lake (Melb.)
34. C.Poulter (WB)
35. B.Walker (bid) (Freeo)
36. I.Winder (Roos)
37. C.Stone (Carl.)
38. L.Kolar (WB)
39. J.Bowey (Port)
40. L.McMahon (Rich.)
41. F.Rosman (Syd.)
42. M.Rioli Jnr. (bid) (Rich.)
43. Z.Maher (Carl.)
44. S.Neale (Roos)
45. J.Callow (Adel.)
46. M.Heath (WB)
47. M.Curruthers (WB)
48. N.Stevens (Syd.)
49. C.Brand (Ess.)
50. M.Allison (Hawks)
? R.Angwin (Saints)
? J.Cardillo (Saints)
? J.Pescad (Saints)

Made quite a lot haha, of change's to my 1st draft.

 

[scotteydog]

Good Points, Cheers.

Also i've picked Bruhn for G-Coast, coz I reckon he compliments Rowell more, maybe? And is one of the better kicks in the draft, which a young outfit could benefit more from. Phillips would takeover from Sloane eventually, so would fit better there I feel. I know it's a big call, especially as he is mates with Anderson & Rowell, but maybe having too many mates at a club, could hinda, there progress too?

 

[PMBangers]

You're missing a few picks and got some out if order

 

[blueiris]

I doubt we take Coleman early unless we have too we’re likely to take match Coleman later as we’re only expected to be drafting 2 players and leave 2 spots available Twomey has Us linked to Carroll at 25-32

 

[Blue Steal]

1. R.Thilthorpe (Adel.)
2. L.McDonald (Roos)
3. JUH (bid) (WB)
4. DGB (Syd.)
5. E.Hollands (Haw)
6. B.Campbell (bid) (Syd.)
7. T.Bruhn (Gcs)
8. A.Perkins (Ess.)
9. N.O'Driscoll (Ess.
10. Z.Reid (Ess.)
11. L.Jones (bid) (PA)
12. W.Phillips (Adel.)
13. O.Henry (Gws)
14. N.Cox (Roos)
15. J.Carroll (Freeo)
16. H.Chapman (Gws)
17. R.McInnes (Coll)
18. K.Baldwin (Rich.
19. C.Downie (bid) (Haw)
20. F.McCrae (Melb.)
21. B.Cook (Melb.)
22. T.Powell (Coll.)
23. E.Gulden (Syd.)
24. B.Laurie (Gws)
25. Z.Dumesny (Adel.)
26. E.Ford (St.K) h.f\ Ins.Mid.
27. Z.Trew (Adel.)
28. B.Coleman (Bris.)
29. M.Heath (Gcs)
30. S.Neale (Ess.)
31. B.Walker (bid) (Freeo)
32. C.Poulter (Roos)
33. L.McMahon (Rich.)
34. C.Stone (Gcs)
35. Z.Maher (Carl.)
36. I.Winder (Roos)
37. J.Callow (Adel.)
38. L.Edwards (Gws)
39. S.Berry (Carl.)
40. M.Rioli Jnr. (bid) (Rich.)
41. J.Ginnivan (Adel.)
42. K.Lane (Gws)
43. S.Mitchell (Carl.)
44. B.Lake (Melb.)
45. M.Allison (Hawks)
46. J.Bowey (PA)
47. F.Rosman (Hawks)
48. O.Davis (Gee)
49. S.Collins (Bris.)
50. L.Kolar (WB)
? R.Angwin (Saints) h.b.f
? J.Cardillo (Saints) wing
? M.Pescad (Saints) h.f.f

Blues Will Take Corey Durdin With One Of Their Pick' s.☺

 

[Seedsfan]

1. R.Thilthorpe (Adel.)
2. L.McDonald (Roos)
3. JUH (bid) (WB)
4. DGB (Syd.)
5. E.Hollands (Haw)
6. B.Campbell (bid) (Syd.)
7. T.Bruhn (Gcs)
8. A.Perkins (Ess.)
9. N.O'Driscoll (Ess.
10. Z.Reid (Ess.)
11. L.Jones (bid) (PA)
12. W.Phillips (Adel.)
13. O.Henry (Gws)
14. N.Cox (Roos)
15. J.Carroll (Freeo)
16. H.Chapman (Gws)
17. R.McInnes (Coll)
18. K.Baldwin (Rich.
19. C.Downie (bid) (Haw)
20. F.McCrae (Melb.)
21. B.Cook (Melb.)
22. T.Powell (Coll.)
23. E.Gulden (Syd.)
24. B.Laurie (Gws)
25. Z.Dumesny (Adel.)
26. E.Ford (St.K) h.f\ Ins.Mid.
27. Z.Trew (Adel.)
28. B.Coleman (Bris.)
29. M.Heath (Gcs)
30. S.Neale (Ess.)
31. B.Walker (bid) (Freeo)
32. C.Poulter (Roos)
33. L.McMahon (Rich.)
34. C.Stone (Gcs)
35. Z.Maher (Carl.)
36. I.Winder (Roos)
37. J.Callow (Adel.)
38. L.Edwards (Gws)
39. S.Berry (Carl.)
40. M.Rioli Jnr. (bid) (Rich.)
41. J.Ginnivan (Adel.)
42. K.Lane (Gws)
43. S.Mitchell (Carl.)
44. B.Lake (Melb.)
45. M.Allison (Hawks)
46. J.Bowey (PA)
47. F.Rosman (Hawks)
48. O.Davis (Gee)
49. S.Collins (Bris.)
50. L.Kolar (WB)
? R.Angwin (Saints) h.b.f
? J.Cardillo (Saints) wing
? M.Pescad (Saints) h.f.f

Why on earth would Collingwood use their first pick on McInnes if no bid has come for him yet

 

[scotteydog]

Why on earth would Collingwood use their first pick on McInnes if no bid has come for him yet

Do the pies have picks later on, to match. They seem to be into him & it seem's a fair pick for his talent.

 

[scotteydog]

1. R.Thilthorpe (Adel.)
2. L.McDonald (Roos)
3. JUH (bid) (WB)
4. DGB (Syd.)
5. E.Hollands (Haw)
6. B.Campbell (bid) (Syd.)
7. T.Bruhn (Gcs)
8. A.Perkins (Ess.)
9. N.O'Driscoll (Ess.
10. Z.Reid (Ess.)
11. L.Jones (bid) (PA)
12. W.Phillips (Adel.)
13. O.Henry (Gws)
14. N.Cox (Roos)
15. J.Carroll (Freeo)
16. H.Chapman (Gws)
17. R.McInnes (Coll)
18. K.Baldwin (Rich.
19. C.Downie (bid) (Haw)
20. F.McCrae (Melb.)
21. B.Cook (Melb.)
22. T.Powell (Coll.)
23. E.Gulden (Syd.)
24. B.Laurie (Gws)
25. Z.Dumesny (Adel.)
26. E.Ford (St.K) h.f\ Ins.Mid.
27. Z.Trew (Adel.)
28. B.Coleman (Bris.)
29. M.Heath (Gcs)
30. S.Neale (Ess.)
31. B.Walker (bid) (Freeo)
32. C.Poulter (Roos)
33. L.McMahon (Rich.)
34. C.Stone (Gcs)
35. Z.Maher (Carl.)
36. I.Winder (Roos)
37. J.Callow (Adel.)
38. L.Edwards (Gws)
39. S.Berry (Carl.)
40. M.Rioli Jnr. (bid) (Rich.)
41. J.Ginnivan (Adel.)
42. K.Lane (Gws)
43. S.Mitchell (Carl.)
44. B.Lake (Melb.)
45. M.Allison (Hawks)
46. J.Bowey (PA)
47. F.Rosman (Hawks)
48. O.Davis (Gee)
49. S.Collins (Bris.)
50. L.Kolar (WB)
? R.Angwin (Saints) h.b.f
? J.Cardillo (Saints) wing
? M.Pescad (Saints) h.f.f

Please disregard this 1st draft & go to my updated one, Thanks.

 

[scotteydog]

I doubt we take Coleman early unless we have too we’re likely to take match Coleman later as we’re only expected to be drafting 2 players and leave 2 spots available Twomey has Us linked to Carroll at 25-32

I think Carroll will go to Freeo at pick 15. He's a good home grown talent, that they won't wanna let slip by.

 

[M Malice]

Can't see Will Phillips sliding that far, absolute gun, however if he does I hope we try a draft night trade to get up and take him, maybe our current 25 and the Demons 1st next year could get it done.

 

[scotteydog]

Thanks Banger's, have done an updated one.

 

[blueiris]

I think Carroll will go to Freeo at pick 15. He's a good home grown talent, that they won't wanna let slip by.

Freo are linked to O’Driscoll

 

[scotteydog]

BLUEIRIS, yeah I know, but think he will go to the Bomber's earlier. They seriously need taller bigger-bodied, (eventually) midfielder's. Bruhn who is linked with them, is just too similar to what they already have there.

 

[scotteydog]

1. R.Thilthorpe (Adel.)
2. L.McDonald (Roos)
3. JUH (bid) (WB)
4. DGB (Syd.)
5. E.Hollands (Haw)
6. B.Campbell (bid) (Syd.)
7. T.Bruhn (Gcs)
8. A.Perkins (Ess.)
9. N.O'Driscoll (Ess.
10. Z.Reid (Ess.)
11. L.Jones (bid) (PA)
12. W.Phillips (Adel.)
13. O.Henry (Gws)
14. N.Cox (Roos)
15. J.Carroll (Freeo)
16. H.Chapman (Gws)
17. R.McInnes (Coll)
18. K.Baldwin (Rich.
19. C.Downie (bid) (Haw)
20. F.McCrae (Melb.)
21. B.Cook (Melb.)
22. T.Powell (Coll.)
23. E.Gulden (Syd.)
24. B.Laurie (Gws)
25. Z.Dumesny (Adel.)
26. E.Ford (St.K) h.f\ Ins.Mid.
27. Z.Trew (Adel.)
28. B.Coleman (Bris.)
29. M.Heath (Gcs)
30. S.Neale (Ess.)
31. B.Walker (bid) (Freeo)
32. C.Poulter (Roos)
33. L.McMahon (Rich.)
34. C.Stone (Gcs)
35. Z.Maher (Carl.)
36. I.Winder (Roos)
37. J.Callow (Adel.)
38. L.Edwards (Gws)
39. S.Berry (Carl.)
40. M.Rioli Jnr. (bid) (Rich.)
41. J.Ginnivan (Adel.)
42. K.Lane (Gws)
43. S.Mitchell (Carl.)
44. B.Lake (Melb.)
45. M.Allison (Hawks)
46. J.Bowey (PA)
47. F.Rosman (Hawks)
48. O.Davis (Gee)
49. S.Collins (Bris.)
50. L.Kolar (WB)
? R.Angwin (Saints) h.b.f
? J.Cardillo (Saints) wing
? M.Pescad (Saints) h.f.f

Please disregard this 1st draft & go to my updated one, Cheers!

 

[scotteydog]

Blues Will Take Corey Durdin With One Of Their Pick' s.☺

I am thinking that Sam Berry would be a good fit, for the blues also, could not fit him into the top 50, maybe later.

 

[Seedsfan]

Do the pies have picks later on, to match. They seem to be into him & it seem's a fair pick for his talent.

But they wouldn’t use their first pick, could see the logic with the second of their first round picks but would be stupid with the first

 

[scotteydog]

Can't see Will Phillips sliding that far, absolute gun, however if he does I hope we try a draft night trade to get up and take him, maybe our current 25 and the Demons 1st next year could get it done.

Yeah interesting, I know he's a gun. I just think the players I've picked before him, suit those clubs better. No doubt really, that he goes earlier, to play with his mates at GCS. Every draft has its slider though.

 

[scotteydog]

But they wouldn’t use their first pick, could see the logic with the second of their first round picks but would be stupid with the first

I've only got the two picks for you in the top 50. 17 & 22 yeah. Mclnnes & Powell, would be great pick ups in that range. If you can match a bid, then sure go for it.

 

[scotteydog]

I've only got the two picks for you in the top 50. 17 & 22 yeah. Mclnnes & Powell, would be great pick ups in that range. If you can match a bid, then sure go for it.

Also, the pies could get K.Baldwin (risky) & j.Callow, on a more needs basis, then get Mcinnes hopefully.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

We're one of a very few clubs who could afford to take the risk on Baldwin.But not at 17.36 maybe but not 17.

 

[scotteydog]

We're one of a very few clubs who could afford to take the risk on Baldwin.But not at 17.36 maybe but not 17.

Poor kid really, if not for the two knee reco's, certainly would of been in the top 20 mix.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Poor kid really, if not for the two knee reco's, certainly would of been in the top 20 mix.

Yep.Same mould as your boy McCartin.
No luck.