Scully or Trengove

[Andy_Mac]

Simple really. If we only had one pick who would you choose?

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

I went Scully but would be interested to see why people may chose JT. Seems after it was almost confirmed that Scully was locked in people started to talk about JT and the hype over came some people due to the volume of discussion and media, despite Scully being almost 100% confirmed.

 

[omit]

Trengoves form in the SANFL is impossible to Ignore and if we only had one pick I would go with JT

 

[Demon 16]

Hasnt this been done?

In any case Scully for me because it all starts in the engine room. Tough call though.

 

[CM Sean]

I'd go with Scully. Because I think he will end up being the better player, I like what I've seen and just for argumenet's sake... there's no "go-home" factor (unless he tried to duck us for richmond, which won't happen due to our success in the near future)

 

[goDees22]

Hasnt this been done?

In any case Scully for me because it all starts in the engine room. Tough call though.

Trengove will be playing there too.

Scully because of his animal workrate i reckon

 

[Demon 16]

Trengove will be playing there too.

Scully because of his animal workrate i reckon

I know he will, but Scully is a true extractor - kind of like Greg Williams used to be. Trengove will get plenty of football, has a more penetrating kick and better marking ability but Scully will give us first use of the ball more than Trengive will.

 

[deeswant13]

I would pick Trengove, but it's awesome we don't have to worry. Got them both. Here's hoping Butcher slides to 11.

 

[CM Sean]

Port Adelaide will take Butcher imo.

 

[The Dr]

Very, very happy we don't have to choose between the two, but I went with Trengove just because he's already proven himself against men, which gives him a very slight edge against Scully at this stage.

 

[Dez!]

Who cares? We get both.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Who cares? We get both.

Geez Dez… Who’s taken the jam out of your donut

 

[Dez!]

Geez Dez… Who’s taken the jam out of your donut

I don't see the point in talking about choosing one or the other when we don't need too.

Rather talk about how Scully is going to extract the ball out of the stoppage, dish it out to Trengove who is then going to deliver a bullet straight onto the chest of Watts.

Then repeat the process another 20-25 times.

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

I don't see the point in talking about choosing one or the other when we don't need too.

Rather talk about how Scully is going to extract the ball out of the stoppage, dish it out to Trengove who is then going to deliver a bullet straight onto the chest of Watts.

Then repeat the process another 20-25 times.

 

[The Professor]

would you prefer a bj from Miranda kerr or adriana lima?

I'll take both thanks.

 

[davey_magik]

I don't see the point in talking about choosing one or the other when we don't need too.

Rather talk about how Scully is going to extract the ball out of the stoppage, dish it out to Trengove who is then going to deliver a bullet straight onto the chest of Watts.

Then repeat the process another 20-25 times.

 

[AFL is Number One]

Who cares? We get both.

Absolutely....who cares we get both !

..and to think...if Tigers missed THAT goal after the siren and we won THAT game, , we would now be spewing over the fact that we would have missed out on one of these two beauties....probably Trengrove.

I'm still ruing the fact that we could have goth both Watts & Naitanui if .....( you know the rest )

Anyway...that's past now...

A game of inches hey? About time we got some luck.

 

[CM Sean]

Who needs Naitanui... we got Jurrahcane

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Exactement

Would pick Trengove, but it could go either way...