Remove this Banner Ad

Select the player we should take with our 1st pick Cannot change once selected

  • Thread starter Thread starter THE_GUN
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Select which player you would like with our 1st selection once selected you cannot change it


  • Total voters
    130
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Probably Robey.
We need a ruck so CDT makes sense, but you might grab a similar type at pick 38.
Really like Cummings, speed, power etc, but we have a lot of mids. Maybe pick 4.

Robey is a lead up forward who at 192cm with good speed/strength/marking will be hard to match up on. He also has midfield ability which will only improve. He's a bit of a gamble, but worth it if he develops as projected.
 
Can we change our vote once we've selected it?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

i doubt he'll be there at 3 (or four, or five? how many bids are there) but i've gone for duff man
The Simpsons Animation GIF by FOX TV
 
I've gone with Sharp. I accept that the game has moved towards outside runners, but i think we can get this type of player with later picks.

Gun players will always be gun players and the first hands, clearance players will never go out of fashion. Look at Neale, Butters, Cripps, Serong, Newcombe etc. They are not quick, but tough, in & under players that lead from the front.

This is what Sharp has done at every level he's played at. Including Captaining SA to u/18's champions and winning the Larke medal. Only exception is when he played senior SANFL footy this year for a few games but was pushed to a forward flank, so really couldn't have the same impact.

Sharp is the best all round player available at our pick. I don't like taking ruckmen with early picks, Robey looks like he could be anything but with the lack of exposed form I think he's too big a risk this early, Taylor & Grlj are the later picks we should look at but not the matchwinner we need to select with pick 3.

Sharp would replace Prestia as the our 1st rover/ centreman (ok I'm a dinosaur) and could be a great combination with Lalor & Smillie in a few years time. And I place a premium on leadership and character - Sharp appears to have both.
 
Ive come around to Robey.
I think he has the potential to be a A+ player.
Grilj will be a gun but i think we will pass on him.
He does alot of things that the Bont does but more foward craft and very strong mark
Has the potential to become that beast foward/Mid if he is in a AFL club training facility and coaching
Could also become 194/195 95kgs
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I dont want to vote because I might want to change it

too much pressure
 
I've voted. I have a cunning plan to change my vote after the draft so I look like I had inside knowledge. Damn, did I say that out loud?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I've voted. I have a cunning plan to change my vote after the draft so I look like I had inside knowledge. Damn, did I say that out loud?
Don't do it, it's against the rules
 
I was going to select them all and at least 1 would have been correct, however, I selected 2 and cast aside BBQ, Sharpie markers, ETA and IBM XT.
 
Cant believe we have 2 votes for Grlj

I thought Groupie_ would be the only 1 to vote for him and only because he thinks its grill chicken
im more a fan of louie cumming
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom