Selection table for Round 15

[vicpride99]

OUT-
Kelly
Rahilly
Mackie
Haynes

IN-
Spriggs
Callan
Gardiner
Koulouriotis

If Rooke is fit play him in replacement of Callan.

 

[rizzo]

Id say Tenace ahead of Koula and Callan before Rooke

 

[JUBJUB]

Out : Kelly [inj],Rahilly,Haynes,Mackie

In : Callan,Gardiner,D Johnson [if fit],Byrnes [if promoted to senior list]

If DJ & Monty aren't picked due to injury and non-promotion,then keep Koula & Spriggs could be an option.

 

[Inside 50]

Although Haynes and Rahilly probably both deserve to be dropped the selectors may keep one or both of them in just because of the fact that they have a little more experince which is what we will need in such a huge game.

 

[nananana catman]

Will tenace be fit enough after having played limited games recently? or will it have made him better prepared to run out a game?

 

[Tweak Talent]

OUT:
Kelly
Rahilly
Haynes

IN:
Koula
Callan
Gardiner

koula's form of late in the 2's has been good and should be given a chance .
Callan has been outstanding all year and with Rahilly's lack of disposal skills should be replaced.
Haynes has been out of form and should be replaced to find some form in the 2's.

 

[nananana catman]

what will the matchups look like downback should Farser play forward? Tarrant - Scarlett
Rocca - Mooney (bigger body against rocca)
Fraser - Harley

smalls arent worth matching up, sanderson would play on didak imo. Rahilly is therfore disposable and should be dropped for Callan who has had an swesome season in the VFL. awesome.

in: Gardiner Callan Tenace
out: Kelly Rahilly Mackie

 

[catattack]

Originally posted by nananana catman
Tarrant - Scarlett

Tarrant is under an injury cloud, and as far as I know is still in doubt.

 

[holdencaulfield]

Callen and spriggs probobly deserve to be first up.Haynes and Rahlly deserve to be dropped. Josh Hunt will be very lucky if selected.

 

[Turbocat]

Can anybody tell me how our rucks went in the VFL.Our centre bounce setup is predictable to other teams and Malthouse would be right on to it and would find a way to block us up again.
We have played our best football this year when we have run and rebound.We seemed quick with Wojo and Tenace but not now.I feel we played better with the tall mid mooney because he was not manned up and he gave us more movement and ran forward to give us more options.King is not ready to do this yet. What does Blake play like is he like his old man, thump the ball 10 to 20 or is he a tap ruckman.If he is up to it, this week would be a good time to come in as the Pies are not strong in this area.
Mackie also looked lost in those conditions, just not strong enough.
Kelly = Spriggs
Mackie=Gardiner
Rahilly=Enright
Haynes=Blake/Chambers/Playfair

 

[JUBJUB]

Originally posted by holdencaulfield
Josh Hunt will be very lucky if selected.

A bit harsh on Hunt.One slightly bad game and you want his head.

 

[Inside 50]

If Enright is not included this week I think there's gotta be something wrong down at Kardinia Park.