Shane Edwards

[Pirate]

He has never been any more than a player with promise , but after 5 years all he has done is lose games for us with his shocking kicking & decision making .... We will never get to the top with idiots like that playing for us . Give some kids the chance that he's had and we will find the players to lift us up .

Every line of your post is not "tru".

 

[aislegi]

this thread is not about split opinions its about getting people to at the least be honest with themselves.
seems some players or most players for some around here can never do any wrong and never play a bad game.

Get real, Santa - there will always be a horde of people who see themselves as truer supporters than the rest of us because they refuse to take off their blinkers and see the glaring deficiencies of large numbers of our players; the ones who are just not up to it. But don't worry - when the players in question get delisted it kind of settles the argument.

 

[nick1408]

I am not a fan of Edwards but he looks like he has talent. He has some very good game and some very poor games. If he could get some consistency he will be dangerous.

Much like Tambling.

In saying that if we got a similar deal as what Adelaide gave us for Tambling I think the club would be silly not to consider it.