Shane Tuck

[mdc]

FWIW; Rhyce Shaw >>>> Shane Tuck and look what Rhyce fetched.

You have to take into account Rhyce had some off-field trouble + last year's draft was a fair bit stronger...but generally I agree. There's just no way Tuck fetches a 2nd rounder, nor is he worth it.

 

[Rohan25]

For the most part, I tend to trust the club with their drafting and recruiting decisions. However if we gave Richmond a pick inside the top 60 for Shane Tuck, then I will just shake my head in disbelief.

First or second round pick?? They are going to cut him anyway!

 

[Barnzy]

First or second round pick?? They are going to cut him anyway!

We're not going to 'cut him anyway', he's just a perfect candidate for trade. 27, going on 28 year old who has played some decent football over the last few years and may have some currency compared to our other players. Perfect trade bait, especially when the team is years away from doing anything.

 

[Optimax]

he is going to get cut barnzy

 

[Barnzy]

he is going to get cut barnzy

Trading is different to cutting players, do you understand that? If he's not traded, he won't be de-listed.

 

[Optimax]

Trading is different to cutting players, do you understand that? If he's not traded, he won't be de-listed.

yet he got dropped and was then played majorly out of position

So please dont pretend to be all high and mighty and talk down to any of us especially me, Tuck is a chance for delistment whether you admit it or not and too think he is worth a second rounder at least is pretty much asking to be ridiculed

 

[Barnzy]

yet he got dropped and was then played majorly out of position

So please dont pretend to be all high and mighty and talk down to any of us especially me, Tuck is a chance for delistment whether you admit it or not and too think he is worth a second rounder at least is pretty much asking to be ridiculed

He's not a chance of de-listment at all. If he isn't traded, he won't be going anywhere. I think I would know more about Richmond matters than you mate.

 

[Optimax]

He's not a chance of de-listment at all. If he isn't traded, he won't be going anywhere. I think I would know more about Richmond matters than you mate.

then explain they dropping, the playing out of position and the ball butchering?

then we can get onto the lunancy of second round draft picks and ben reid trades

 

[Barnzy]

then explain they dropping, the playing out of position and the ball butchering?

then we can get onto the lunancy of second round draft picks and ben reid trades

When did I even mention 2nd rounder draft picks or Ben Reid trades in this thread or did you make that up too in your own little fantasy world?

 

[Optimax]

When did I even mention 2nd rounder draft picks or Ben Reid trades in this thread or did you make that up too in your own little fantasy world?

read the thread numnut
and stop dodging the questions, dropping, out of position return and ball butchering

 

[Barnzy]

read the thread numnut
and stop dodging the questions, dropping, out of position return and ball butchering

I've read it and I'm asking you where I even mentioned 2nd round draft picks or Ben Reid trades, since you're calling me up on it. What does his dropping have anything to do with what we're talking about? As I said, if he isn't traded, he won't be going anywhere...especially as he has a contract for 2010. So yes, I know more about this matter than you do.

 

[Optimax]

I've read it and I'm asking you where I even mentioned 2nd round draft picks or Ben Reid trades, since you're calling me up on it.

where did i say you said?

comprehension barnzy its not difficult

I said first explain to me these three things
Why was he dropped?
Why on return did he get played out of position
Why does he butcher the ball?

then i said we could talk about the lunancy of 2nd round draft picks and ben reid trades, now i never said you said it but they were brought up as trades in the thread were they not?

Now barnzy one last go, answer the 3 questions and stop stalling. We have finals to pay attention even if you have a long summer ahead

 

[Barnzy]

where did i say you said?

comprehension barnzy its not difficult

I said first explain to me these three things
Why was he dropped?
Why on return did he get played out of position
Why does he butcher the ball?

then i said we could talk about the lunancy of 2nd round draft picks and ben reid trades, now i never said you said it but they were brought up as trades in the thread were they not?

Now barnzy one last go, answer the 3 questions and stop stalling. We have finals to pay attention even if you have a long summer ahead

Why would I have to explain to you those 3 things if I didn't even bring up the Ben Reid of 2nd round draft pick trade ideas? Come on now, comprehension is not difficult. As I've said already, if he isn't traded he won't be going anywhere...he also has a contract for 2010.

 

[Optimax]

ill bump this when he is either traded for pick 90 odd or cut

 

[Barnzy]

ill bump this when he is either traded for pick 90 odd or cut

Okay, look forward to it.

 

[smiddaz123]

Tuck won't be delisted.....Richmond have plenty of shit to get through before Tuck.

 

[Spluff]

ill bump this when he is either traded for pick 90 odd or cut

I'll be back to bump this thread when neither of those things happen. If you think that'd happen, you seriously have NFI.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Now that Shane himself has agreed to a trade, Collingwood need to get on that shit QUICK.

I want him at the Pies.

 

[Optimax]

Now that Shane himself has agreed to a trade, Collingwood need to get on that shit QUICK.

I want him at the Pies.

so you are afraid to play a GF with Obree but you want Tuck?

my head hurts

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

so you are afraid to play a GF with Obree but you want Tuck?

my head hurts

Tuck is better than O'Bree.

I apologise if you believe otherwise.

 

[Optimax]

Tuck is better than O'Bree.

I apologise if you believe otherwise.

both get clearances

Both get contested possessions

Both have battle hardened bodies

Both often blaze when they kick

No to me its same same, give me blair/mccarthy/macaffer/wellingham if we must remove Obs now not a plyer that got dropped from richmond

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

both get clearances

Both get contested possessions

Both have battle hardened bodies

Both often blaze when they kick

No to me its same same, give me blair/mccarthy/macaffer/wellingham if we must remove Obs now not a plyer that got dropped from richmond

So according to you we shouldn't have picked up:

- James Clement (Fremantle)
- Brodie Holland (Fremantle)
- Paul Medhurst (Fremantle)
- Leigh Brown (Fremantle/North)

I mean, they all came from shit sides didn't they? Surely good players don't exist in shit sides? Surely some players don't just need a change of scenery?

Christ, if you were running the show, you might as well not have a trades in the AFL at all. smh.

 

[Optimax]

So according to you we shouldn't have picked up:

- James Clement (Fremantle)
- Brodie Holland (Fremantle)
- Paul Medhurst (Fremantle)
- Leigh Brown (Fremantle/North)

I mean, they all came from shit sides didn't they? Surely good players don't exist in shit sides? Surely some players don't just need a change of scenery?

Christ, if you were running the show, you might as well not have a trades in the AFL at all. smh.

all of them bar leigh brown were younger then Tuck

Leigh al cost a 5th rund draft pick in a draft

Basically you trade to improve your side considrably, at best tuck will improve the side a little even then its questionable

Besides if it was up for you we would have no young KPPs

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

all of them bar leigh brown were younger then Tuck

Leigh al cost a 5th rund draft pick in a draft

Basically you trade to improve your side considrably, at best tuck will improve the side a little even then its questionable

Besides if it was up for you we would have no young KPPs

Then you must misread all my posts.

If it were up to me, the only KPP players I'd trade would be one or two of Cloke, Reid and Dawes.

That still leaves, ONE of those 3, N Brown, Sean Rusling and John Anthony.

 

[i_hate_scams]

straight swap with one of Johnson, Cox or Goldsack imo, nothing more. or draft picks that we are not going to use.