Phantom Draft Smythe's Draft Thread 2019 *UPDATED* 2 ROUNDS

[Mike Dawson]

1. D.Williams 188-82 mid/fwd
2. M.Rowell 178-75 mid/fwd
3. S.Flanders 183-81 mid/fwd
4. T.Green 188-85 mid
5. N.Anderson 188-86 mid
6. M.O'Niell 181-70 mid/fwd
7. C.Taheny 185-75 mid
8. C.Serong 178-82 mid/fwd
9. B.Kemp 191-80 def
10. J.Rayner 192-89 def
11. L.Delahunty 191-90 fwd
12. J.Rossiter 191-78 def
13. J.Sharp 185-72 mid/def
14. L.Ash 186-77 mid
15. L.Jackson 195-90 ruck/fwd
16. E.Jeka 197-87 fwd
17. H.Young 186-80 mid/def
18. C.Stephens 187-70 mid/def
19. D.Robertson 180-66 mid
20. L.Potter 185-70 def
21. J.Mead 181-83 mid
22. K.Pickett 171-65 fwd
23. H.Ralph-Smith 186-70 mid
24. T.Bianco 180-70 mid
25. J.Mahony 176-70 fwd
26. C.Watts 196-87 def
27. R.Gardner 184-72 mid/def
28. D.Cassar 183-75 mid/fwd
29. D.Sladojevic 192-91 fwd
30. R.Cox 172-69 fwd
31. M.Georgiades 189-82 mid
32. D.Stephens 180-64 mid/fwd
33. F.McAsey 195-86 fwd
34. K.Tozer 194-84 fwd
35. D.Mott 182-73 mid/def
36. J.Musika 175-65 mid/def

I'm going to throw a smokey in the mix. Kid from WA. Jack Allen. Came to the sport later but developing fast.
KPP 194cm/93kg. Last testing had a 94cm running vertical and did 21.4 Yo-Yo. Be interesting to watch next year.

 

[Blakey123]

What are your thoughts on Mitch O’Neill

 

[yaco55]

We don't need the same question asked in three threads - Ask it in one thread and the experts will answer.

 

[foodles05]

I

Its a little of column B. I do rate him (at under 18 level) but cannot put him on there at his height transitioning into AFL. I really loved watching him play this year and i hope next year he plays different positions and/or works on his speed away from contests as well as delivery or has a growth spurt. Because similar to Kyle Reid this year unless some of those things change i dont see an AFL spot for him.

I'd be astounded if he wasn't picked up. Only issue might be his agility but has good speed and is a fantastic kick. He is a bit in the Shannon Hurn mould for mine. Not sure about his endurance but he could even be a big mid maybe. Loves to hurt and his size transitions to AFL. He will still be very big and powerful at the next level.

 

[philthy05]

I


I'd be astounded if he wasn't picked up. Only issue might be his agility but has good speed and is a fantastic kick. He is a bit in the Shannon Hurn mould for mine. Not sure about his endurance but he could even be a big mid maybe. Loves to hurt and his size transitions to AFL. He will still be very big and powerful at the next level.

Yep I’m a Gould fan and I don’t understand the concerns over his height

There are plenty of sub 193cm defenders in the afl especially when they are strong and Gould looks a beast

Also I don’t think he has to be that fb anyway. Shown he can intercept and use the ball so no problems being the 3rd or 4th defender.

 

[Smythe]

PICK	TEAM	BIDS	PLAYER
1	GOLD COAST		M.ROWELL
2	GOLD COAST		N.ANDERSON
3	MELBOURNE		L.JACKSON
4	GWS		L.ASH
5	GWS		T.GREEN
6	SYDNEY		D.ROBERTSON
7	ADELAIDE		D.STEPHENS
8	FREMANTLE		H.YOUNG
9	FREMANTLE		S.FLANDERS
10	CARLTON		B.KEMP
11	MELB BID	FREO MATCH	L.HENRY
12	MELBOURNE		K.PICKETT
13	HAWTHORN		M.BERGMAN
14	PORT		F.MCASEY
15	WB		C.WEIGHTMAN
16	GEELONG		C.SERONG
17	GOLD COAST		D.WILLIAMS
18	PORT		W.DAY
19	GEELONG		J.WORRALL
20	PORT		W.GOULD
21	RICHMOND		C.STEPHENS
22	GOLD COAST		E.TAYLOR
23	BRISBANE		T.RIVERS
24	ADELAIDE		J.RANTALL
25	ADELAIDE		S.DEKONING
26	GEELONG		M.GEORGIADES
27	SYD BID	HAWKS MATCH	F.MAGINNESS
28	SYDNEY		J.SHARP
29	NORTH		T.BIANCO
30	NORTH		J.MAHONY
31	MELBOURNE		M.O'NIELL
32	BRISBANE		C.TAHENY
33	NORTH BID	PORT MATCH	MEAD
34	NORTH		S.PHILP
35	ESSENDON		R.BYRNES
36	SYDNEY		H.SCHOENBERG
37	ESSENDON		H.JONES
38	BRISBANE		D.HILDER
39	COLLINGWOOD		J.RICCARDI
40	GEELONG		C.COMBEN
41	ADELAIDE		K.FINLAY
42	RICHMOND		D.CASSAR
43	RICHMOND		C.SHARMAN
44	GWS		R.O'CONNOR

 

[THE_GUN]

I would be extremely surprised if Henry lasts to pick #13

But i like Cooper Stephens for Richmond with our first selection

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Dylan Williams goes undrafted then?

 

[Smythe]

Dylan Williams goes undrafted then?

I knew i missed one. I rubbed him out to change the pick but forgot who it was. For the sake of this i will edit it and put him in where i had him

 

[Apex36]

Pretty sure Port don’t have priority access to Pickett...

 

[Yojimbo]

Cumberland Is Brisbane Academy, just while your fixing the Pickett one.

 

[bmaurizio]

Great outcome for the Blue Baggers enjoyed reading your work.

 

[Mutineer]

Pretty sure Port don’t have priority access to Pickett...

Absolutely they don't.

 

[Smythe]

Cumberland Is Brisbane Academy, just while your fixing the Pickett one.

Pretty sure Port don’t have priority access to Pickett...

Apologies on the pickett one...im not sure where on earth i got that from. I will fix this tomorrow

 

[briztoon]

Brisbane won’t draft a tall forward. We’re after mids and HBF’ers.

Happy with Bianco at our second pick. Gould or Cooper Stephens at our first.

And we’re looking at taking two academy kids, Keidean Coleman who we kept in our NEAFL team all year, and Cumberland.

 

[Smythe]

Fair enough on the cumberland one. And i know what happened with pickett. In my rough draft i crossed off ports last few picks believing they wont use them but had them taking pickett. So when (tiredly) looking at my rough notes and typing them up i mistook port not using those picks as port losing those picks to match a bid. My apologies. Its been a long week already and its only tuesday.

 

[Smythe]

I would be extremely surprised if Henry lasts to pick #13

But i like Cooper Stephens for Richmond with our first selection

Me too. henry is great and i loved watching him play this year. There are whispers that melb may bid at 3, there are whispers they may go for jackson at 3. Until the day comes we never really know.

 

[mike91]

Me too. henry is great and i loved watching him play this year. There are whispers that melb may bid at 3, there are whispers they may go for jackson at 3. Until the day comes we never really know.

Henry at #3? Lol, just lol

 

[theGav56]

Me too. henry is great and i loved watching him play this year. There are whispers that melb may bid at 3, there are whispers they may go for jackson at 3. Until the day comes we never really know.

If Melbourne really want him, then 3 would do it. I think that would be beyond what Fremantle would pay, as it effectively would cost their first two picks. The alternative for Fremantle would be to take any two of Serong/Flanders/Jackson/Stephens/Robertson/Ash, and I am confident they would do that. Could also trade down their second pick to get a look at Rivers, Sharp and Taylor.

 

[Smythe]

Henry at #3? Lol, just lol

Exactly. I dont think he is worth it. Plenty above him already playing at a higher level and ready to go at round 1. Henry will need to add size first. Not worth the 3 in my mind. More at the 8-15 range for mine. That's why i have him at 13

 

[David C]

Dylan Williams goes undrafted then?

Pick 29?

 

[Yojimbo]

Pick 29?

He edited him in yesterday after erasing him and forgetting to put him back in.

 

[sunsofanarchy]

Do you think Day is better than Gould? Or do you think GC want the family connection?

On SM-G960W using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gorringe Can Suck One]

Surely GC draft Bianco and Williams to get all the Oakley boys together?

 

[Smythe]

Do you think Day is better than Gould? Or do you think GC want the family connection?

On SM-G960W using BigFooty.com mobile app

They are completely different players. i do think day has a higher ceiling if all goes right for the young guy, but gould is a plug and play straight away if thats what they want, but if you read my write up on gould there is a big chance he goes earlier.