Swans4eva Mock Draft first 2 rounds

[swans4eva]

1. Melbourne- Jack Watts
2. West Coast- Nic Natuani
3. Freo- Daniel Rich
4. Port- Tyrone Vickery
5. Ess- Michael Hurley
6. Carlton- Jack Ziebell
7. Brisbane- Steele Sidebottom
8. Richmond- Hamish Hartlett
9. North- Shaun Mckernan
10. Adelaide- Lewis Johnston
11. Collingwood- Sam Blease
12. Sydney- Jackson Trengrove
13. St Kilda- Chris Yarran
14. WB- Ayce Cordy
15. Geelong- Tom Swift
16. Hawthorn- Matthew Broadbent
17. Melbourne- Mitch Robinson
18. West Coast- Aaron Cornelious
19. Melbourne- Jordan Roughead
20. West Coast- Stephen Hill
21. Freo- Nick Suban
22. Port- Clancee Pearce
23. Ess- Rhys O' Keefe
24. Freo- Michael Walters
25. Brisbane- Jordan Lisle
26. Richmond- Shoenmakers(Worng spelling i know)
27. North-Matt Deboer
28. Adelaide- Tom Lynch
29. Collingwood- Paul Cahill
30. Sydney- Neville Jetta
31. WB- Nick Heryne
32. WB-Mitch Brown
33. Geelong- Mitch Banner
34. Hawthorn- Ashley Smith

Any Thoughts?

 

[tommyboy101]

1. Melbourne- Jack Watts
2. West Coast- Nic Natuani
3. Freo- Daniel Rich
4. Port- Tyrone Vickery
5. Ess- Michael Hurley
6. Carlton- Jack Ziebell
7. Brisbane- Steele Sidebottom
8. Richmond- Hamish Hartlett
9. North- Shaun Mckernan
10. Adelaide- Lewis Johnston
11. Collingwood- Sam Blease
12. Sydney- Jackson Trengrove
13. St Kilda- Chris Yarran
14. WB- Ayce Cordy
15. Geelong- Tom Swift
16. Hawthorn- Matthew Broadbent
17. Melbourne- Mitch Robinson
18. West Coast- Aaron Cornelious
19. Melbourne- Jordan Roughead
20. West Coast- Stephen Hill
21. Freo- Nick Suban
22. Port- Clancee Pearce
23. Ess- Rhys O' Keefe
24. Freo- Michael Walters
25. Brisbane- Jordan Lisle
26. Richmond- Steve Gaertner
27. North-Matt Deboer
28. Adelaide- Luke Stanton
29. Collingwood- Paul Cahill
30. Sydney- Neville Jetta
31. WB- Nick Heryne
32. WB-Mitch Brown
33. Geelong- Mitch Banner
34. Hawthorn- Ashley Smith

Any Thoughts?

dont rate stanton (28) that high at all. considering you've got him above the likes of strauss and shuey im not a big fan

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Gaertner way too high, 4th round at best

 

[year of the cat]

From a Geelong perspective i would expecrt that if we went with Swift in the first round we may well go tall and take Shoenmakers/Cahill in the second if either are still available.

I reckon that quite a few clubs will go that way - either tall or short in the first round and the opposite in the second. With the raft of good talls in this draft and the fact that it will be increasingly difficult to access quality talls in the next couple of years it sounds like a pretty sound strategy.

 

[sinepari]

Im looking forward to seeing a draft that explores the possiblity that WC WONT take Walters, Hill or Yarran.

Yes it might happen, but that's all that's being thrown around at present.

 

[__aria__]

i would be pretty unhappy with that

 

[Quigley]

Im looking forward to seeing a draft that explores the possiblity that WC WONT take Walters, Hill or Yarran.

Yes it might happen, but that's all that's being thrown around at present.

When I do mine Sinepari I will be sure to pass on them for you. Its a shame you don't rate them.

 

[scotty4]

i think stanton and gaertner too high and maybe lisle a little higher

 

[swans4eva]

i think stanton and gaertner too high and maybe lisle a little higher

I edited it, but i dont agree with you for lisle

 

[sblack]

Hartlett is a better midfield prospect than Sidebottom. Sidebottom rated higher if you are looking for thr utility type player. I would rather have Hamish at Brisbane over Steele

 

[peggles]

pretty good for us

 

[halfback dasher]

When I do mine Sinepari I will be sure to pass on them for you. Its a shame you don't rate them.

so,when are you doo,n yours Quig,s................

 

[Warwick]

Any Thoughts?

Yes.

What are Brisbane meant to do with Jordan Lisle?

Add him to the pile already containing Merrett, Patfull, Roe, Tyler, Clouston, Clark, and Henderson?

 

[budge11]

I'd rather Yarran, Swift or Trengove at pick 9 than McKernan.

I'd rather Heyne or Banner or even Post at pick 27.

 

[SUPASTARR]

Yes.

What are Brisbane meant to do with Jordan Lisle?

Add him to the pile already containing Merrett, Patfull, Roe, Tyler, Clouston, Clark, and Henderson?

Other than Mitch Clark and Lachie Henderson are any of those any good? Didn't think so