Competitions The 2012 AFC Drafting Game: The Premiership Table at the end of the Minor Round

[Mego Red]

So - here are the final scores. First number is the AVERAGE score out of 100 that each side got; the next score is an adjusted score, where I divided each score by that voter's overall score, which was my way of adjusting for difference in marking. Embarrassingly, I seem to be the person who has benefited from this the most (and probably benefited from folks being a bit generous with me), so I am completely fine with disregarding it. Especially if you're BACCS, who was in the final 8 on average score but not on adjusted score.

Apologies if this doesn't display well (someone shoot me some html if you want it updated; I'm too dumb), and I hope the lower finishing teams don't feel embarrassed that I've outed their scores. I'm not going to publish what scores people actually voted, but if you want to publish your scores, go ahead.

I was sort of imagining we'd do a final series - 1st v 8th, say, and everyone would vote on who they'd think would win, and we do a deadline of 9am the next day for votes and the the winner goes on. But I'm easy (as long as it isn't a pain in the ass to administer; some of us have to work for a living).


THE PREMIERSHIP TABLE

Kristof - The Stringer Bellends: 75.29 | 66.69
Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks: 76.31 | 63.60
Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165: 75.00 | 62.41
Roo2macca - The Maccaroos: 74.31 | 62.12
Carl Spackler - The Gophers: 74.56 | 61.91
Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters: 73.31 | 60.91
Faith - Faith FC: 73.25 | 60.86
Lawrst - The Memes: 72.33 | 60.40

BACCS - The Sloanedawgs: 71.25 | 59.25
Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination: 69.69 | 58.06
Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows: 69.34 | 58.04
Stripple - the Thundercats: 69.19 | 57.80
Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team: 64.65 | 57.18
Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions: 68.06 | 56.79
Hdecure - The Crippled Crows: 67.00 | 56.23
ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs: 67.75 | 56.00
Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters: 66.16 | 55.00
Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes: 63.56 | 53.07

Most generous marker: Hdecure
Least generous marker: Ringo200

Biggest difference between their highest and lowest score: Lawrst (81 & 59).

 

[Mego Red]

Let me know if I should pull any other stats from the scores ...

 

[Freddy Bassett]

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers- 73
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows-68
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes-58
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters-64
5. Stripple - the Thundercats-62
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs-71
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos-73
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions-59
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks-79
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters-79
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165-72
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows-70
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends-74
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs-66
15. Lawrst - The Memes-65
16. Faith - Faith FC-74
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team-60
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination-68

This is how I marked it.....
You guys judged me more kindly than I judged myself, so cheers...

Also happy to discuss why I had any of you too low or high!

Looking at it, I got everyones score pretty well near the overall average...

Except I was generous towards HDecure and Hendo

And harsh towards Buzz and Madfan, sorry! If Israel Folau turns out well, I have been unfair to Stripple.... If he has a great year, Stripples team could be a serious challenger fr end of year title

 

[FAITH]

Pretty happy with my score.
Are we looking more so at the first or second score?

Cant believe FootyPie32 didnt make top 6

So what happens now who do we vote for for finals?

 

[FAITH]

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers- 73
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows-68
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes-58
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters-64
5. Stripple - the Thundercats-62
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs-71
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos-73
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions-59
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks-79
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters-79
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165-72
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows-70
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends-74
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs-66
15. Lawrst - The Memes-65
16. Faith - Faith FC-74
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team-60
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination-68

This is how I marked it.....
You guys judged me more kindly than I judged myself, so cheers...

Also happy to discuss why I had any of you too low or high!

Looking at it, I got everyones score pretty well near the overall average...

Except I was generous towards HDecure and Hendo

And harsh towards Buzz and Madfan, sorry!

My scores were pretty similar to the averages i think cept footypie i had extremely high.
you FB i had 3rd.

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

A bit disappointed to be ranked so poorly, but my forward line, led my Walsh and Watts really wasn't too impressive. Had a stack of fun in this game though and hopefully my selections will be vindicated come round 23!

 

[Mego Red]

My scores were pretty similar to the averages i think cept footypie i had extremely high.
you FB i had 3rd.

You have Footypie four points higher than anyone else, and ten points higher than their average.

 

[FAITH]

A bit disappointed to be ranked so poorly, but my forward line, led my Walsh and Watts really wasn't too impressive. Had a stack of fun in this game though and hopefully my selections will be vindicated come round 23!

I had you 4th buzz because i thought many of your players would improve dramatically this year.

 

[Footypie32]

Considering I got a 1st and a 2nd place from 2 of you, some of you guys must have rated me really badly for me to finish 11th?!! Oh well, I'll remember that for next year...

 

[FAITH]

You have Footypie four points higher than anyone else, and ten points higher than their average.

FootyPie obviously was underated by others, he was my fav team for sure, so many options in that team.
Where did you have FP Kristof?

 

[Mego Red]

Considering I got a 1st and a 2nd place from 2 of you, some of you guys must have rated me really badly for me to finish 11th?!! Oh well, I'll remember that for next year...

Bottom score of 59.

Which I actually think is a bit harsh, but that's the game, I guess.

 

[Mego Red]

FootyPie obviously was underated by others, he was my fav team for sure, so many options in that team.
Where did you have FP Kristof?

FWIW - I had Footypie at 71pts and 10th. I thought it relied a bit too much on youth and I tend to favor strong midfields. That being said, there's some talent in that squad across the ground, and their structure works.

 

[blackbird_RGB]

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers 79/100
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows 70/100
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes 71/100
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters
5. Stripple - the Thundercats 72/100
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs 75.5
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos 76.5/100
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions 75/100
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks 76.5/100
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters 72/100
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165 78.5/100
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows 74/100
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends 76.5
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs 72/100
15. Lawrst - The Memes
16. Faith - Faith FC 76/100
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team 68.5
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination 74/100


I think this is what I pmd kristof. If so, sorry lawrst. embarassing. Fix it when I get home...

 

[FAITH]

FWIW - I had Footypie at 71pts and 10th. I thought it relied a bit too much on youth and I tend to favor strong midfields. That being said, there's some talent in that squad across the ground, and their structure works.

His midf wasnt too bad. Just wondering if it was a consideration that most of his Fwrds/Hfws/Hbs could easily slip into the midf at any time and perform very well?

 

[Mego Red]

FWIW - here's my scores. I wouldn't take them too seriously, because I think subconciously I was trying be polite and make sure there wasn't an enormous spread.

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers. 76
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows. 72
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes. 63
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters. 75
5. Stripple - the Thundercats. 70
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs. 76
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos. 79
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions. 63
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks. 74
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters. 75
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165. 76
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows. 70
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs. 72
15. Lawrst - The Memes. 72
16. Faith - Faith FC. 78
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team. 63
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination. 74

 

[Footypie32]

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers 79/100
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows 70/100
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes 71/100
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters
5. Stripple - the Thundercats 72/100
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs 75.5
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos 76.5/100
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions 75/100
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks 76.5/100
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters 72/100
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165 78.5/100
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows 74/100
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends 76.5
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs 72/100
15. Lawrst - The Memes
16. Faith - Faith FC 76/100
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team 68.5
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination 74/100


I think this is what I pmd kristof. If so, sorry lawrst. embarassing. Fix it when I get home...

Another 2nd placing!! Kristof, this a conspiracy!! RECOUNT!!

 

[Mego Red]

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers 79/100
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows 70/100
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes 71/100
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters
5. Stripple - the Thundercats 72/100
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs 75.5
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos 76.5/100
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions 75/100
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks 76.5/100
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters 72/100
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165 78.5/100
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows 74/100
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends 76.5
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs 72/100
15. Lawrst - The Memes
16. Faith - Faith FC 76/100
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team 68.5
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination 74/100


I think this is what I pmd kristof. If so, sorry lawrst. embarassing. Fix it when I get home...

I gave Lawrst the average of his other scores for you Blackbird (you muppet).

But I DID get the average wrong because of that ... Fixed original post now. Average adjusted up, which actually makes a lot more sense next to the adjusted score, which was right.

 

[Allefgib]

This is what I sent kristof on his criteria...

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers - 80.5
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows - 70.5
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes - 67.5
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters - 68
5. Stripple - the Thundercats - 69
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs - 70
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos - 67.5
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions - 70.5
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks - 75
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters - 75.5
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165 - 73
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows - 68.5
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends - 81
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs - 62
15. Lawrst - The Memes - 69
16. Faith - Faith FC - 80.5
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team - 59
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination - 67

You got'em on structure mate. Every spot in the ground had quality. So you got marks for structure.. then every spot had a reasonable score because you had quality everywhere.

Given you set the criteria...

 

[Mego Red]

This is what I sent kristof on his criteria...

And what excellent criteria they were!

 

[Allefgib]

And then my own criteria... Happy to share/disscuss details.

1. Carl Spackler - The Gophers - 7.49
2. Footypie32 - The Anti-Crows - 6.51
3. Mad Fan of AFL - Sando's Spikes - 6.75
4. Blackbird RGB - Hell's Feather Busters - 6.46
5. Stripple - the Thundercats - 6.72
6. BACCS - The Sloanedawgs - 7.14
7. Roo2macca - The Maccaroos - 6.60
8. Buzzasto - The Lismore Lions - 6.49
9. Crows are the best - Kenworth Trucks - 7.70
10. Hendo888 - The Foo Fighters - 7.32
11. Freddy Bassett - Club 119-138-165 - 7.81
12. Hdecure - The Crippled Crows - 6.25
13. Kristof - The Stringer Bellends - 7.89
14. ringo200 - The Ringo Starrs - 6.23
15. Lawrst - The Memes - 7.37
16. Faith - Faith FC - 7.61
17. Adelaide Fan 14 - The A Team - 5.81
18. Bacon8 - Total Bacon Domination - 6.77


So in ladder position by my rankings (but also showing yours)

Ladd Position-Team-Coach-SJ Score-Kristof Score
1 The Stringer Bellends Kristof 7.89 8.1
2 Club 119-138-165 Freddy Bassett 7.81 7.3
3 Team Kenworth Trucks crowsarethebest 7.70 7.5
4 Faith Football Club Faith 7.61 8.05
5 The Gophers Carl Spackler 7.49 8.05
6 The Memes Lawrst 7.37 6.9
7 Foo Fighters hendo8888 7.32 7.55
8 The Sloanedawgs BACCS 7.14 7
9 Total Bacon Domination Bacon8 6.77 6.7
10 Sando's Spikes Mad Fan of AFL 6.75 6.75
11 The ThunderCats stripple 6.72 6.9
12 The MaccaRoos roo2macca 6.60 6.75
13 The Anti-Crows FootyPie32 6.51 7.05
14 The Lismore Lions Buzzasto DaSilva 6.49 7.05
15 Hell's Feather Buster Football Club blackbird_RGB 6.46 6.8
16 The Crippled Crows hdecure 6.25 6.85
17 Ringo All Starr ringo200 6.23 6.2
18 The A-Team AdelaideFan14 5.81 5.9

 

[FAITH]

And what excellent criteria they were!

Can we do finals Kristof, i reckon i can get you in the prelim

 

[ringo200]

I had r2m first followed by carl then kritof. Cant remember the rest i think catb was next. Cant imagine i scored too many points on structure, i had 4 guys who play in the ruck in my 21.

 

[Hank93]

Clearly my Forward line destroyed my chance of winning. Understandable, especially my tall forwards.

Will post my full rankings of teams later, but CATB was my top team. Kristof, BACCS, Freddy, R2M, Stripple and Faith were the others that faired well from me.

 

[Bacon8]

Another 2nd placing!! Kristof, this a conspiracy!! RECOUNT!!

Blackbird didn't have you second... That's the order of the picks, not the positioning.

 

[Bacon8]

Equal top with Faith & Hendo.

I had myself bottom 6, so to come 9th, I'm happy with