List Mgmt. The 24 Out Of Contract Club

[SnowRoo]

Aiden Bonar - keep 1 year deal
Bailey Scott - priority keep 3 years
Ben Brown - trade
Ben Jacobs (RFA) - delist
Curtis Taylor - priority keep 3 year deal
Ed Vickers-Willis - keep 2 years
Jamie MacMillan (UFA) - pray for FA or delist
Jasper Pittard - keep 1 year
Jed Anderson - priority keep 3 years
Joel Crocker - 1 year
Josh Walker - 2 years
Kayne Turner. - 1 year
Kyron Hayden - 2 years
Lachie Hosie - rookie/1 year
Majak Daw (UFA) - 1 year
Marley Williams - delist
Mason Wood (RFA) - delist
Matthew MacGuinness - delist
Paul Ahern - 1 year
Sam Durdin - 1 year
Taylor Garner (RFA) - delist
Tom Murphy - 1 year
Tristan Xerri - 2 years
Will Walker - 2 years


Payout/delist - Hall, Tyson, Campbell

 

[chairo]

My big concern is that, if match day selections are anything to go by, some of the delisting/relisting are going to defy logic.

 

[Bigeasy]

These are my thoughts based on the most popular viewed list sizes for 2021, 38 primary list and 2 rookies. We currently have a total of 45 players on our list therefore I will reduce to 36 to allow for 3 draftees and a trade.

Aiden Bonar
Bailey Scott
Ben Brown
Ben Jacobs (RFA)
Curtis Taylor
Ed Vickers-Willis
Jamie MacMillan (UFA)
Jasper Pittard
Jed Anderson
Joel Crocker - Rookie
Josh Walker
Kayne Turner
Kyron Hayden
Lachie Hosie
Majak Daw (UFA)
Marley Williams
Mason Wood (RFA)
Matthew MacGuinness - Rookie
Paul Ahern
Sam Durdin
Taylor Garner (RFA)
Tom Murphy
Tristan Xerri
Will Walker

 

[Snake_Baker]

These are my thoughts based on the most popular viewed list sizes for 2021, 38 primary list and 2 rookies. We currently have a total of 45 players on our list therefore I will reduce to 36 to allow for 3 draftees and a trade.

Aiden Bonar
Bailey Scott
Ben Brown
Ben Jacobs (RFA)
Curtis Taylor
Ed Vickers-Willis
Jamie MacMillan (UFA)
Jasper Pittard
Jed Anderson
Joel Crocker - Rookie
Josh Walker
Kayne Turner
Kyron Hayden
Lachie Hosie
Majak Daw (UFA)
Marley Williams
Mason Wood (RFA)
Matthew MacGuinness - Rookie
Paul Ahern
Sam Durdin
Taylor Garner (RFA)
Tom Murphy
Tristan Xerri
Will Walker

THats pretty good.

The only thing that jumps off the page is Ahern & Murphy.

 

[Bigeasy]

THats pretty good.

The only thing that jumps off the page is Ahern & Murphy.

Yeah I toyed with cutting them but they are good by foot and that is what Shaw is looking for. I would give them one year only.

 

[Moti]

These are my thoughts based on the most popular viewed list sizes for 2021, 38 primary list and 2 rookies. We currently have a total of 45 players on our list therefore I will reduce to 36 to allow for 3 draftees and a trade.

Aiden Bonar
Bailey Scott
Ben Brown
Ben Jacobs (RFA)
Curtis Taylor
Ed Vickers-Willis
Jamie MacMillan (UFA)
Jasper Pittard
Jed Anderson
Joel Crocker - Rookie
Josh Walker
Kayne Turner
Kyron Hayden
Lachie Hosie
Majak Daw (UFA)
Marley Williams
Mason Wood (RFA)
Matthew MacGuinness - Rookie
Paul Ahern
Sam Durdin
Taylor Garner (RFA)
Tom Murphy
Tristan Xerri
Will Walker

Hosie, Wood and Garner are all HF, Maj another marking option. I would keep Maj and drop Ahern or Murphy.

 

[Horace]

If pushed I would drop Marley. That's it.

Jasper was basically the greatest steak knives since Wayne Carey up until 7-8 rounds ago. His detractors must have been hiding in foxholes all this time.

Absolutely agree. Jasper's season was undone the moment he was sent forward. As a defender, although prone to the odd error, my view is that he was a very good addition to the squad.

Not part of this discussion I know, but I think that Polec's season was brought undone when he was asked to operate as one of the four in at centre bounces. He is not that type of player. He is first and foremost a wingman or in today's language, an outside midfielder. The problem for him this is that our best extractor, BennyC has been unavailable to get it out to him (and others).

 

[Bigeasy]

Hosie, Wood and Garner are all HF, Maj another marking option. I would keep Maj and drop Ahern or Murphy.

We still would have Taylor, Thomas, Zurhaar, Turner, Zeibell, Scott, Mahoney and W Walker to play HF.

 

[Twinkletoes]

Absolutely agree. Jasper's season was undone the moment he was sent forward. As a defender, although prone to the odd error, my view is that he was a very good addition to the squad.

Not part of this discussion I know, but I think that Polec's season was brought undone when he was asked to operate as one of the four in at centre bounces. He is not that type of player. He is first and foremost a wingman or in today's language, an outside midfielder. The problem for him this is that our best extractor, BennyC has been unavailable to get it out to him (and others).

Agree mate.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Cuts
1. Brown (trade)
2. Polec (trade)
3. Campbell (payout rookie contract)
4. Macmillan
5. Pittard
6. Murphy
7. Jacobs
8. Wood
9. Will Walker
10. EVW

id keep durdin who imo has always been decent when playing but he could be added to the above due to pecking order

 

[year of the roo]

Cuts
1. Brown (trade)
2. Polec (trade)
3. Campbell (payout rookie contract)
4. Macmillan
5. Pittard
6. Murphy
7. Jacobs
8. Wood
9. Will Walker
10. EVW

id keep durdin who imo has always been decent when playing but he could be added to the above due to pecking order

Cutting Brown, Polec, Will Walker and EVW but keeping Garner and Durdin? How embarassing for you.

 

[The acurate one]

The acurate one also has suggested that size mate.

I was told a player believes 36, but I highly doubt that would be the case. From memory we have a total of 45 currently. That would mean at least a dozen of the list.
Extrapolate that across the league and that's a mass culling. I did see this is costing the league 400,000,000 or some such. Maybe the players salaries need to reflect this change in times?

I cannot believe players can earn so much, but a lower league aka VFL isn't affordable. makes no sense at all.

 

[archerboy]

For what it's worth here's my list:

Aiden Bonar - Keep
Bailey Scott - Keep
Ben Brown - Trade only if a good deal
Ben Jacobs (RFA) - Delist/Trade
Curtis Taylor - Keep
Ed Vickers-Willis - Keep
Jamie MacMillan (UFA) - Let him walk, it's either him or Atley for mine and Atley is contracted.
Jasper Pittard - Delist/Trade
Jed Anderson - Keep
Joel Crocker - Delist. Deserves a chance but i would look around for a better option, otherwise rookie him.
Josh Walker - Keep
Kayne Turner - Delist/Trade. Love his pressure but others have past him by.
Kyron Hayden - Keep
Lachie Hosie - Delist/Trade. Deserves a chance but 4 or 5 others ahead of him
Majak Daw (UFA) - Keep
Marley Williams - Delist/Trade
Mason Wood (RFA) - Delist/Trade
Matthew MacGuinness - Deserves a chance but i would look around for a better option, otherwise rookie him
Paul Ahern - Delist/Trade
Sam Durdin - Delist/Trade
Taylor Garner (RFA) - Delist/Trade
Tom Murphy - Keep unless better options come about as delisted free agents
Tristan Xerri - Keep
Will Walker - Keep

That is 12 gone at least from me and i would love to add Hall & Dyson to that list. Gives us great flexibility to add through free agency, the draft and load up on rookie selections.

 

[the flying ham]

Cuts
1. Brown (trade)
2. Polec (trade)
3. Campbell (payout rookie contract)
4. Macmillan
5. Pittard
6. Murphy
7. Jacobs
8. Wood
9. Will Walker
10. EVW

id keep durdin who imo has always been decent when playing but he could be added to the above due to pecking order

Haha you've had a mare here

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ferball]

Matt McGuiness is a first year Cat B rookie isn't he? Doesn't that mean he doesn't even take up a rookie spot on the list? Given we need a KPD in his age group and he has had good reports he would be kept on wouldn't he?

Apart from Hayden, who may be injury prone, how many lock down small defenders do we have?

Why are we trading out Brown when our forward line is shambles?

Etc etc.

 

[ferball]

Aiden Bonar
Bailey Scott
Ben Brown
Ben Jacobs (RFA)
Curtis Taylor
Ed Vickers-Willis
Jamie MacMillan (UFA)
Jasper Pittard
Jed Anderson
Joel Crocker
Josh Walker
Kayne Turner
Kyron Hayden
Lachie Hosie
Majak Daw (UFA)
Marley Williams
Mason Wood (RFA)
Matthew MacGuinness
Paul Ahern
Sam Durdin
Taylor Garner (RFA)
Tom Murphy
Tristan Xerri
Will Walker

Bolds are gone. The five in italics seem to be competing for two spots and EVW will get one of them if he stays fit. LMac and Atley are both contracted. Add them to the other five and that is seven players for three or four spots.

Tyson and Campbell are the other obvious choices in contract.

People seem to think Marley is gone. He'd be in with Will Walker, Bonar, Xerri, Hayden, Turner and Daw as the next group likely to be out the door. At least for mine. McGuiness could be in that group too, I guess it depends on Cat B Rookie status after the virus. IMO this group has low likelihood of being delisted.

 

[Swallow_Wood]

Recontract:
Aiden Bonar - 1 year with triggers for 1-2 more
Tristan Xerri - 1 year
Will Walker - 1 year with triggers for 2 more
Bailey Scott - 3 years
Curtis Taylor - 3 years
Ed Vickers-Willis - 1 year with triggers for 2 more
Kyron Hayden - 2 years
Jed Anderson - 2 years
Josh Walker - 1 year
Kayne Turner - 1 year


Re-contract or Trade:
Ben Brown - 3 years or trade for early picks
Jamie MacMillan (UFA) - 1 year/Trade
Jasper Pittard - 1 year/ Trade


Trade or Delist:
Sam Durdin - Delist/Trade
Mason Wood (RFA) - Delist/Trade


Delist/Retire:
Ben Jacobs (RFA) - Delist/Retire
Joel Crocker - Rookie - Delist
Lachie Hosie - Delist
Majak Daw (UFA) - Delist/Retire
Marley Williams - Delist
Matthew MacGuinness - Rookie - Delist
Paul Ahern - Delist
Taylor Garner (RFA) - Delist/Retire
Tom Murphy - Delist

 

[DuckYeah]

Garner, Campbell (dgaf if he has a year to go, trade him or pay him out), Hall (trade/pay him out), williams, wood, BJ and MacMillan .. thats a start.. the rest keep for 2021 then another cull

 

[sruss]

Recontract:
Aiden Bonar - 1 year with triggers for 1-2 more
Tristan Xerri - 1 year
Will Walker - 1 year with triggers for 2 more
Bailey Scott - 3 years
Curtis Taylor - 3 years
Ed Vickers-Willis - 1 year with triggers for 2 more
Kyron Hayden - 2 years
Jed Anderson - 2 years
Josh Walker - 1 year
Kayne Turner - 1 year


Re-contract or Trade:
Ben Brown - 3 years or trade for early picks
Jamie MacMillan (UFA) - 1 year/Trade
Jasper Pittard - 1 year/ Trade


Trade or Delist:
Sam Durdin - Delist/Trade
Mason Wood (RFA) - Delist/Trade


Delist/Retire:
Ben Jacobs (RFA) - Delist/Retire
Joel Crocker - Rookie - Delist
Lachie Hosie - Delist
Majak Daw (UFA) - Delist/Retire
Marley Williams - Delist
Matthew MacGuinness - Rookie - Delist
Paul Ahern - Delist
Taylor Garner (RFA) - Delist/Retire
Tom Murphy - Delist

Wholeheartedly agree with all of this BUT reckon there’s a hole in the third tall forward type if both Hosie and Wood depart - would prefer to keep one for depth

 

[Swallow_Wood]

Wholeheartedly agree with all of this BUT reckon there’s a hole in the third tall forward type if both Hosie and Wood depart - would prefer to keep one for depth

I reckon we could cover it with a combination of Ziebell, Taylor and Thomas. All those guys have a strong marking game.

 

[Shinboner1]

I reckon we could cover it with a combination of Ziebell, Taylor and Thomas. All those guys have a strong marking game.

Unfortunately I think zeibel is on his last legs.

 

[big_e]

Depart - 5

Jacobs
Garner
Ahern
Wood
McGuinness


Maybe -6

Daw
Williams
Bonar
Durdin
Crocker
Hosie

Keep - 13

Anderson
Scott
Pittard
Walker J
Walker W
Turner
Taylor
Vickers-Willis
Macmillan
Hayden
Xerri
Murphy
Brown

The maybes are dependent on what we could pick up in free agency and trades - ie give one year deals if we can't find an adequate replacement.

 

[the flying ham]

Depart - 5

Jacobs
Garner
Ahern
Wood
McGuinness


Maybe -6

Daw
Williams
Bonar
Durdin
Crocker
Hosie

Keep - 13

Anderson
Scott
Pittard
Walker J
Walker W
Turner
Taylor
Vickers-Willis
Macmillan
Hayden
Xerri
Murphy
Brown

The maybes are dependent on what we could pick up in free agency and trades - ie give one year deals if we can't find an adequate replacement.

I agree with that list although get the feeling Jaspers papers might be stamped?

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[hellas_johnny]

I agree with that list although get the feeling Jaspers papers might be stamped?

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

agreed, more chance or marley staying on atm then pittard i reckon

 

[youdontmesswiththez]

Delisting hosie would be a mistake has shown great promise in a lost team . Has goals in him and can play around the ground . Set up one of our only four goals on the weekend with great vision .