InstinctivelyAlert
Senior List
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2025
- Posts
- 181
- Reaction score
- 294
- AFL Club
- Essendon
How exciting! I ordered a roast chicken for lunch - who do I call about writing a book on these bones?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Shocker - who saw that comingAnimal bones
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
What?! You’re telling me circumstantial evidence isn’t concrete?! But he lived so close to the beach?!LOL, I’d say there’s far more evidence for Harry Phipps NOT being involved!
After all the allegations poor old Harry Phipps has had to endure, I’d say he’s turning in his grave by now… but I doubt that he’s buried on the Castalloy site or with those poor Beaumont kids!What?! You’re telling me circumstantial evidence isn’t concrete?! But he lived so close to the beach?!
Chant with me now;After all the allegations poor old Harry Phipps has had to endure, I’d say he’s turning in his grave by now… but I doubt that he’s buried on the Castalloy site or with those poor Beaumont kids!
It’s a deal. Do you have a shovel? I’ll bring the camera.Chant with me now;
One! More! Dig!
Good to go!It’s a deal. Do you have a shovel? I’ll bring the camera.
The 'authors' I use that term loosely will never rule Phipps out they've nailed themselves to it.How many failed digs does it take before a theory is reconsidered?
Can you provide any further information about this? Didn’t see anything about it in the news.Cossie has visited the Stansbury location. I guess to meet the occupants. Think it was Tuesday
Can you provide any further information about this? Didn’t see anything about it in the news.
good thing Cosi didn't make a media statement about it!Think they want to keep the news and media out of it.
Wait you’re telling me Cosi didn’t get in front of a camera ?!good thing Cosi didn't make a media statement about it!
Wait you’re telling me Cosi didn’t get in front of a camera ?!
He isn't a suspectThe 'authors' I use that term loosely will never rule Phipps out they've nailed themselves to it.
I guess SAPOL could come out and say it's an exhausted avenue and strike him off as a suspect.
Interesting, to see if he still goes ahead with the dig after speaking to the Land Owners.Can you provide any further information about this? Didn’t see anything about it in the news.
Between him and ex detective Hayes, they need a firm talking to. Potentially a reminder that circumstantial evidence is absolutely not proof.Would have loved to speak to Frank Pangallo, and point out the irregularities with the Phipps theory... Thats before the dig!
Many people have been convicted on circumstantial evidence, but in this case, it just didn't add up.Between him and ex detective Hayes, they need a firm talking to. Potentially a reminder that circumstantial evidence is absolutely not proof.
I believe the landholders have agreed to the dig.Interesting, to see if he still goes ahead with the dig after speaking to the Land Owners.
Personally, I want to see it go ahead, then we can finally end this Circus
Agreed. I should have been more concise and clearer.Many people have been convicted on circumstantial evidence, but in this case, it just didn't add up.