The Doig.

[beetz]

At least it was only 1 other player and 1 Freo staff member who carried him as opposed to 21 players who usually carry him through a game.

On the right track, Col.

 

[more_of_bito]

Just reading the Sylvia incident. Surely there were some BF witnesses that were there to shed some light? Seems very odd that a bloke can get plastered and not make it to 9.30pm at a major club event? Was he messy when he turned up ala Fev at the Brownlow?? Anyone?

 

[MadDocker]

Would rather no one shine any more light on it personally. What happens at the Doig, stays at the Doig.

 

[JunglistPosse]

Just reading the Sylvia incident. Surely there were some BF witnesses that were there to shed some light? Seems very odd that a bloke can get plastered and not make it to 9.30pm at a major club event? Was he messy when he turned up ala Fev at the Brownlow?? Anyone?

Saw him at about 730 and he looked fine..definitely wasn't inebriated

 

[Righteo]

Maybe he lost a few quick rounds of Slap Cup or beer pong?

 

[MadDocker]

Slap cup hey? Google research coming right up.

 

[JunglistPosse]

Is that like soggy Sao?

 

[Righteo]

It's kiiiinda like flip cup only with cup slapping and not flipping and a faster pace.

 

[rgauci]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-11-18/delayed-start-for-Sylvia

There is a reference to the incident at the bottom. Apparently gastro according to twitter.

 

[Schauermann]

It is strange that Lachie and Gu didn't finish top 10, but i would imagine they would have been sitting in 11th and 12th as mentioned above.

I think this voting system is perfect as it grades every player on their performance and doesn't just favour the top players for the day like the Brownlow or AFLCA award does.

I would love to know the decision making on giving votes though and the criteria they are assessed on from all coaches.


If this is how the voting was judged was all season, you can see how a crap game from a player can affect their total.

What isn't really covered is how and when the votes are given. Is it straight after the game or once they have done their analysis or looked through stats.

Every coach wouldn't get a good look at all 22 players out there.

Well, I am still confused with the voting system. Really dislike that not all votes are published in a table. When you consider like top 3:

Fyfe 283 votes / 20 games / 5 coaches = on average 2,83 votes from each coach
Sandi 251 votes / 23 games / 5 coaches = 2,18
Hill 238 votes / 20 games / 5 coaches = 2,38

That is pretty low when every player gets 1-5 votes where I would expect an average performance being 3 votes.

So I still think only the top 5 players in each match are given 1,2,3,4,5 votes. Their was proof of that in other votings in years before as well.

 

[gungho]

So what is so bad about the voting system?
Apart from the fact that you are unhappy with the result?

Going to redo the votes to how the freo board want them. (And how they should be.)
1 Nat Fyfe
2 Aaron Sandilands
3 Stephen Hill
4 Hayden Ballantyne.
5. Michael Barlow.
6. David Mundy.
7 Tendai Mzungu
8 Lockie Neal.
9 Matthew Pavlich
10. Cam Sutcliffe
11 Michael Johnson
12 Paul Duffield
13 Lee Spurr.
14 Ryan Crowley
15 Chris Mayne.
16. Danyle Pearce
17 Zac Dawson
18 Luke Mcpharlin
19 Nick Suban
20 Zac Clarke
21 Matt Tabener
22 Matt De Beor
23 Hayden Crozier
24 Garrick Ibbotson
25 Alex Silvani
26 Michael Walters
27 Anthony Morabito
28 Tom Sheridan
29 Clancee Pearce
30 Max Duffy
31 Michael Apeness
32 Jack Hannath
33 Josh Simpson

34 Meritorious award for showing up.......Colin Sylvia.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

Going to redo the votes to how the freo board want them. (And how they should be.)
1 Nat Fyfe
2 Aaron Sandilands
3 Stephen Hill
4 Hayden Ballantyne.
5. Michael Barlow.
6. David Mundy.
7 Tendai Mzungu
8 Lockie Neal.
9 Matthew Pavlich
10. Cam Sutcliffe
11 Michael Johnson
12 Paul Duffield
13 Lee Spurr.
14 Ryan Crowley
15 Chris Mayne.
16. Danyle Pearce
17 Zac Dawson
18 Luke Mcpharlin
19 Nick Suban
20 Zac Clarke
21 Matt Tabener
22 Matt De Beor
23 Hayden Crozier
24 Garrick Ibbotson
25 Alex Silvani
26 Michael Walters
27 Anthony Morabito
28 Tom Sheridan
29 Clancee Pearce
30 Max Duffy
31 Michael Apeness
32 Jack Hannath
33 Josh Simpson

34 Meritorious award for showing up.......Colin Sylvia.

FCS, how much do you know about Col Sylvia or are you just jumping on the wagon of rabid attack dogs.
Also, that isn't how you spell Lachie.

 

[Latro]

Going to redo the votes to how the freo board want them. (And how they should be.)
1 Nat Fyfe
2 Aaron Sandilands
3 Stephen Hill
4 Hayden Ballantyne.
5. Michael Barlow.
6. David Mundy.
7 Tendai Mzungu
8 Lockie Neal.
9 Matthew Pavlich
10. Cam Sutcliffe
11 Michael Johnson
12 Paul Duffield
13 Lee Spurr.
14 Ryan Crowley
15 Chris Mayne.
16. Danyle Pearce
17 Zac Dawson
18 Luke Mcpharlin
19 Nick Suban
20 Zac Clarke
21 Matt Tabener
22 Matt De Beor
23 Hayden Crozier
24 Garrick Ibbotson
25 Alex Silvani
26 Michael Walters
27 Anthony Morabito
28 Tom Sheridan
29 Clancee Pearce
30 Max Duffy
31 Michael Apeness
32 Jack Hannath
33 Josh Simpson

34 Meritorious award for showing up.......Colin Sylvia.

Slyvia should only get a partial credit.

 

[gungho]

FCS, how much do you know about Col Sylvia or are you just jumping on the wagon of rabid attack dogs.
Also, that isn't how you spell Lachie.

Fred, quite a few of the names are spelt wrong.....I just spelt them the way I wanted to spell them.
The bit about Col was meant as a little light hearted banter.
Lighten up cobba.