Mega Thread The Former Player Thread: Part 2

[RobbieK]

Do you know Brown ?

Not personally, no, I've just been witness to enough footage of him punching people to have made a call on good character without a formal introduction.

 

[bedford]

Not personally, no, I've just been witness to enough footage of him punching people to have made a call on good character without a formal introduction.

You must live a perfect life. I'd rather get it from AJ thanks.

 

[MC Bad Genius]

You must live a perfect life. I'd rather get it from AJ thanks.

To be fair, there's a long spectrum from perfection to some of the acts Campbell Brown dished on the field...

 

[DobmusEdge]

You must live a perfect life. I'd rather get it from AJ thanks.

Gold Coast sacks Campbell Brown after assault on teammate Steven May

Gold Coast parts ways with veteran after he assaulted teammate

www.afl.com.au

 

[bedford]

To be fair, there's a long spectrum from perfection to some of the acts Campbell Brown dished on the field...

And then we all liked thugs like Plugger and BBBH playing for us.

 

[bedford]

Gold Coast sacks Campbell Brown after assault on teammate Steven May

Gold Coast parts ways with veteran after he assaulted teammate

www.afl.com.au

And who's to say May is an angel ! might have deserved it .

 

[RobbieK]

And then we all liked thugs like Plugger and BBBH playing for us.

And they weren't good blokes either. So what's your point?

 

[bedford]

And they weren't good blokes either. So what's your point?

So what's yours , we all have times that are not good , are you perfect ?

 

[RobbieK]

So what's yours , we all have times that are not good , are you perfect ?

Yes, I am perfect.

My point is that maybe we need to stop calling guys who have a long and sadly repetitive history of extreme and unprovoked violence "good blokes"?

 

[Kummerspeck]

You must live a perfect life. I'd rather get it from AJ thanks.

I've never punched people on multiple occasions when they weren't looking so I say it on good authority that Brown is a stain.

 

[MC Bad Genius]

So what's yours , we all have times that are not good , are you perfect ?

I reckon we can have a higher bar for calling someone a good bloke. I'm not saying I'm perfect, but I've never drunkenly broken someone's jaw and lost my job for it. That's not a good bloke. That's a shit bloke.

 

[bedford]

I've never punched people on multiple occasions when they weren't looking so I say it on good authority that Brown is a stain.

Here they come the K's you 2 must live in a perfect world . By the way champ , I don't punch people , I detest that shit.

 

[RobbieK]

Here they come the K's you 2 must live in a perfect world . By the way champ , I don't punch people , I detest that shit.

And yet you are arguing with us for saying that Campbell Brown, who has done that many times, is not a good bloke...

 

[bedford]

I've never punched people on multiple occasions when they weren't looking so I say it on good authority that Brown is a stain.

People make mistakes , he hasn't killed anyone and as a fact BBBH played up big time early days in Sydney and it was hushed up , if it happened in Melbourne he was cooked

 

[Kummerspeck]

Here they come the K's you 2 must live in a perfect world . By the way champ , I don't punch people , I detest that shit.

Ah grow up bedders. You idolise a bloke who has repeatedly behaved in a shit way, others disagree. Try to support your belief in some way rather than having a tantrum.

People make mistakes , he hasn't killed anyone and as a fact BBBH played up big time early days in Sydney and it was hushed up , if it happened in Melbourne he was cooked

And Hall is a shit bloke, what's your point?

 

[bedford]

And yet you are arguing with us for saying that Campbell Brown, who has done that many times, is not a good bloke...

How many times do you know about ?

 

[bedford]

Ah grow up bedders. You idolise a bloke who has repeatedly behaved in a shit way, others disagree. Try to support your belief in some way rather than having a tantrum.


And Hall is a shit bloke, what's your point?

Bedford thanks , you don't qualify to call me bedders ! where do I idolise Brown ? , I just said AJ likes him and you and your other K mate can't handle normal life.

 

[RobbieK]

How many times do you know about ?

He was suspended six times for striking, once more on top of that for unnecessary contact to an opponents face, arrested in Thailand for fighting and stripped of his leadership role at the Suns, then the punch on May that got him sacked...

You detest violence but think this guy is a good bloke? Think this is normal?

 

[bedford]

He was suspended six times for striking, once more on top of that for unnecessary contact to an opponents face, arrested in Thailand for fighting and stripped of his leadership role at the Suns, then the punch on May that got him sacked...

You detest violence but think this guy is a good bloke? Think this is normal?

I said AJ said , go to OPSM

 

[RobbieK]

Calling me a commie is an insult you ? I hate violence . So don't lecture me .

You hate violence but think violent thugs are good blokes?

 

[RobbieK]

they seem like they can do no wrong

Just like Campbell Brown.

 

[bedford]

Just like Campbell Brown.

What don't you understand , I was saying what was coming from AJ , unbelievable from your perfectness.

 

[RobbieK]

What don't you understand , I was saying what was coming from AJ , unbelievable from your perfectness.

I disagreed with his assessment and gave my reasons. You then repeatedly pushed back against me for saying that the lengthy history of violent behaviour by Brown both on and off the field means that he is not a good bloke. Why?

Stop hiding behind AJ. Stop defending this violent thug.

 

[sataris]

The best thing about the last 2 pages of inane drivel, are that they're all based on the opinions of a bloke about another a bloke that nobody here knows.

 

[bedford]

I disagreed with his assessment and gave my reasons. You then repeatedly pushed back against me for saying that the lengthy history of violent behaviour by Brown both on and off the field means that he is not a good bloke. Why?

Stop hiding behind AJ. Stop defending this violent thug.

Did he deck you at some stage . If he's that bad he'd be in jail and listen im not hiding behind a Swans champ who is a very decent person , not like some others.