Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Competitions TOP 20 DRAFT - 2015

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cringle
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Include Academy Selections?

  • Total voters
    20

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Cringle

Cringle

Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran Carlton Board Tipping Champion
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Posts
9,058
Reaction score
15,228
AFL Club
Carlton
Hey

HARKER started this little competition last year (maybe earlier)...
link http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/top-20-draft-2014.1081430/


Points will be allocated accordingly:

1. 5 Points for every player selected correctly by the team with the appropriate selection.
i.e. Carlton with pick #1.....Weitering, receives maximum points.
n.b. Essendon's consecutive picks #4 and #5 must be in order to receive maximum points.


2. 3 Points for every player selected in the top 20
i.e. As long as the name is selected in the top twenty in the draft, 3 points will be allocated on top of having that player in the correct order.


3. Bonus points for Correct Carlton selections: #1 = 5Pts... #8 = 7Pts... #19 = 10Pts... #59 = 12Pts. #60 = 12Pts. *
*If F/S is taken with both #59 and #60 you need to make this clear and you will receive the 24 full points.


Feel free to edit your posts as much as you like up until the draft.

ACADEMY SELECTIONS:
Might be best to just exclude Academy selections all together. Just makes the order complex and ruins the marking allocation. Or perhaps create a separate selection where you state (similar to the Carlton selections) where academy picks will be picked if the top 20. I.e. #3 (Assumed Bid) Callum Mills... etc.

The draft order is below to copy and paste.

Draft Order
1. Blues.........
2. Lions.........
3. Melb.........
4. * .............
5. * .............
6. GC............
7. Melb.........
8. Blues........
9. Adel.........
10. Blues......
11. Rich........
12. Adel........
13. Saints.....
14. Hawks.....
15. GC..........
16. North......
17. Hawks.....
18. Blues......
19. WB.........
20. WB.........

Carlton Selections
1.
8.
11.
19.
59.
60.


 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues......... Weitering
2. Lions......... Schache
3. Melb......... Oliver
4. * ............. Parish
5. * ............. Francis
6. GC............ Ah Chee
7. Melb......... Weideman
8. Blues........ H.McKay
9. Adel......... Milera
10. Blues...... Curnow
11. Rich........ Gresham
12. Adel........ Burton
13. Saints..... Mathieson
14. Hawks..... Collins
15. GC.......... Hibberd
16. North...... Clarke
17. Hawks..... Cole
18. Blues...... Tucker
19. WB......... Balic
20. WB......... B.McKay

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. H.McKay
11. Curnow
19. Cuningham
59. Silvagni
60. Silvagni
 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues.........Weitering
2. Lions.........Schache
3. Melb.........Parish
4. * .............Curnow
5. * .............Francis
6. GC............Milera
7. Melb.........McKay
8. Blues........Weidemann
9. Adel.........Burton
10. Blues......Oliver
11. Rich........Ah Chee
12. Adel........Balic
13. Saints.....Tucker
14. Hawks.....Bonner
15. GC..........Hibberd
16. North......Mathieson
17. Hawks.....Collins
18. Blues......Cunningham
19. WB.........Cole
20. WB.........McKay

Carlton Selections
1.Weitering
8.Weidemann
11.Oliver
19. Cunningham
 
Draft Order
1. Blues......... Jacob Weitering
2. Lions......... Joshua Schache
3. Sydney..... Callum Mills (Academy bid by Melbourne)
4. Melb......... Darcy Parish
5. GWS....... Jacob Hopper (Academy bid by *FC)
6. GWS..... Matthew Kennedy (Academy bid by *FC)
7. * ........... Sam Weideman
8. * ............. Aaron Francis
9. GC............ Charlie Curnow
10. BRI........ Eric Hipwood (Academy bid by Melbourne)
10. Melb......... Harry McKay
11. Blues........ Clayton Oliver
12. Adel......... Terry Milera
13. Blues...... Rhys Mathieson
14. BRI..... Ben Keays (Academy bid by Richmond)
15. Rich........ Harley Balic
16. Adel........ Ryan Burton
17. Saints..... Darcy Tucker
18. Hawks..... Callum Ah Chee
19. GC.......... Mitchell Hibberd
20. North...... Kieran Collins
21. Hawks..... Jade Gresham
22. St. Kilda.... Bailey Rice (Father-Son bid by Carlton)
23. Blues...... Riley Bonner
24. WB......... Ryan Clarke
25. WB......... Mitch Brown

-- Without Academy Selections -- (no changes)
1. Carlton: Jacob Weitering
2. Brisbane: Joshua Schache
3. Melbourne: Darcy Parish
4. Essendon: Sam Weideman
5. Essendon: Aaron Francis
6. Gold Coast: Charlie Curnow
7. Melbourne: Harry McKay
8. Carlton: Clayton Oliver
9. Adelaide: Terry Milera
10. Carlton: Rhys Mathieson
11. Richmond: Harley Balic
12. Adelaide: Ryan Burton
13. St. Kilda: Darcy Tucker
14. Hawthorn: Callum Ah Chee
15. Gold Coast: Mitchell Hibberd
16. North: Kieran Collins
17. Hawthorn: Jade Gresham
18. Carlton: Riley Bonner
19. Bulldogs: Ryan Clark
20. Bulldogs: Mitch Brown

Carlton Selections:

1. Jacob Weitering
2. Clayton Oliver
3. Rhys Mathieson
4. Riley Bonner

Would prefer if we didn't draft Mathieson but just a gut feeling.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Draft Order
1. Blues......... Weitering
2. Lions......... Schache
3. Melb......... Oliver
4. * ............. Parish
5. * ............. Weideman
6. GC............ Ah Chee
7. Melb......... H.McKay
8. Blues........ Francis
9. Adel......... Milera
10. Blues...... Curnow
11. Rich........ Rioli
12. Adel........ Burton
13. Saints..... Balic
14. Hawks..... Collins
15. GC.......... Mathieson
16. North...... Hibberd
17. Hawks..... Bonner
18. Blues...... Cuningham
19. WB......... Fiorini
20. WB......... B.McKay

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. Francis
11. Curnow
19. Cuningham
59. Silvagni
60. Hardwick or Phillips
 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues......... Weitering
2. Lions.........
3. Melb.........
4. * .............
5. * .............
6. GC............
7. Melb.........
8. Blues........ Collins
9. Adel.........
10. Blues...... Curnow
11. Rich........
12. Adel........
13. Saints.....
14. Hawks.....
15. GC..........
16. North......
17. Hawks.....
18. Blues...... Gresham
19. WB.........
20. WB.........

Carlton Selections
1.
8.
11.
19.
 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues.........J.Weitering
2. Lions.........J.Schache
3. Melb.........C.Curnow
4. * .............D.Parish
5. * .............S.Weideman
6. GC............H.McKay
7. Melb.........W.Milera
8. Blues........A.Francis
9. Adel.........R.Burton
10. Blues......C.Oliver
11. Rich........B.Ah Chee
12. Adel........H.Balic
13. Saints..... R.Bonner
14. Hawks.... K.Collins
15. GC..........B.McKay
16. North...... J.Gresham
17. Hawks.....M.Hibberd
18. Blues......R.Clarke
19. WB.........R.Mathieson
20. WB.........T.Cole
 
Draft Order
1. Blues......... Jacob Weitering
2. Lions......... Josh Schache
3. Melb......... Clayton Oliver
4. * ............. Aaron Francis
5. * ............. Darcy Parish
6. GC............ Callum Ah Chee
7. Melb......... Sam Weideman
8. Blues........ Harry McKay
9. Adel......... Wayne Milera
10. Blues...... Charlie Curnow
11. Rich........ Jade Gresham
12. Adel........ Ryan Burton
13. Saints..... Kieran Collins
14. Hawks..... Mitchell Hibberd
15. GC.......... Harley Balic
16. North...... Daniel Rioli
17. Hawks..... Ben McKay
18. Blues...... Darcy Tucker
19. WB......... Riley Bonner
20. WB......... Brayden Fiorini

Carlton Selections
1. Jacob Weitering
8. Harry McKay
11. Charlie Curnow
19. Darcy Tucker
59. David Cuningham
60. Jack Silvagni

Academy Selections
3. Callum Mills
5. Jacob Hopper
7. Matthew Kennedy
14. Eric Hipwood
17. Ben Keays
21. Harry Himmelberg
25. Josh Dunkley
 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues..........Weitering
2.Lions...........Schache
3.Demons.......Weideman
4.*.................Parish
5.*.................Francis
6.GC..............Curnow
7.Demons.......Oliver
8.Blues...........H.Mckay
9.Crows..........Milera
10.Blues.........Clarke
11.Rich...........Mathieson
12.Crows........Burton
13.Saints........Hibberd
14.Hawks.......Collins
15.GC............Balic
16.North........Ah Chee
17.Hawks.......Dunkley
18.Blues.........Gresham
19.Dogs.........B.McKay
20.Dogs.........Bonner
 
Draft Order
1. Blues......... Weitering
2. Lions......... Schache
3. Melb.......... Parish
4. * ............. Curnow
5. * ............. Weidemann
6. GC............ Milera
7. Melb......... H. McKay
8. Blues........ Francis
9. Adel......... Burton
10. Blues...... Oliver
11. Rich........ Balic
12. Adel........ Bonner
13. Saints..... Mathieson
14. Hawks..... Collins
15. GC.......... Ah Chee
16. North...... Clarke
17. Hawks..... Rioli
18. Blues...... B. McKay
19. WB......... Tucker
20. WB......... Hibberd

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. Francis
11. Oliver
19. B. McKay
 
Draft Order
1. Blues.........Weitering
2. Lions.........Schache
3. Melb.........Oliver
4. * .............Francis
5. * .............Parish
6. GC............AhChee
7. Melb.........Weideman
8. Blues........H.McKay
9. Adel.........Milera
10. Blues......Curnow
11. Rich........Burton
12. Adel........Balic
13. Saints.....Tucker
14. Hawks.....Collins
15. GC..........Hibberd
16. North......Gresham
17. Hawks.....Cole
18. Blues......Cunningham
19. WB.........Bonner
20. WB.........Redman

Carlton Selections
1.Weitering
8.H.McKay
10.Curnow
18. Tucker
59&60 Silvagni

Academy Selections

3.Mills by Melbourne
5.Hopper by *
12.Kennedy by Richmond
13.Hipwood by Adelaide
17.Keays by Hawthorn

 
Last edited:
Alright, game on lads...

Draft Order
1. Blues.........Weitering
2. Lions.........Schache
3. Melb.........Oliver
4. * .............Parish
5. * .............
6. GC............Ah Chee
7. Melb.........Weideman
8. Blues........Curnow
9. Adel.........Milera
10. Blues......H. McKay
11. Rich........Rioli
12. Adel........Burton
13. Saints.....Mathieson
14. Hawks.....Bonner
15. GC..........Gresham
16. North......Balic
17. Hawks.....Collins
18. Blues......Tucker
19. WB.........Hibberd
20. WB.........B. McKay

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. Curnow
10. H. McKay
18. Tucker

Academy Selections

3. Mills - Sydney, bid by Melbourne
4. Hopper - GWS, bid by *
7. Kennedy - GWS, bid by Melbourne
11. Hipwood - Brisbane, bid by Carlton
13. Keays - Brisbane, bid by St Kilda
 
Last edited:
Draft Order

.................Original 16.11..............24.11

1. Blues.........Weitering..............Weitering
2. Lions.........Schcahe.................Schcahe
3. Melb..........Parish....................Parish
4. E'don .......Weideman..............Francis
5. E'don .......Oliver......................Oliver
6. GC.............Francis...................Curnow
7. Melb.........Curnow...................Weideman
8. Blues........H. McKay................H. McKay
9. Adel..........Milera.....................Milera
10. Blues......Tucker....................Tucker
11. Rich........Ah Chee..................Ah Chee
12. Adel........Burton....................Burton
13. Saints.....Mathieson..............Mathieson
14. Hawks.....Collins...................Collins
15. GC...........Hibberd..................Gresham
16. North......Gresham................Clarke
17. Hawks.....Bonner..................Rioli
18. Blues......Clarke.....................Cunningham
19. WB..........B. McKay................Balic
20. WB..........Rioli........................Adams

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. H.McKay
11. Tucker
19. Cunningham
59. SOS
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

1.Carlton ... Weitering
2.Brisbane ... Schache
3.Melbourne ... Parish
4.* ... Francis
5.* ... Milera
6.GC ... Curnow
7.Melbourne ... H.McKay
8.Carlton ... Weideman
9.Adelaide ... Burton
10.Carlton ... Oliver
11.Richmond ... Collins
12.Adelaide ... Balic
13.St.Kilda ... Mathieson
14.Hawthorn ... Tucker
15.GC ... Hibberd
16.NM ... Ah Chee
17.Hawthorn ... Bonner
18.Carlton ... Gresham
19.Footscray ... B.McKay
20.Footscray ... Cunningham

Carlton Selections :
1.Weitering
8.Weideman
10.Oliver
18.Gresham
59.Silvagni
 
Academy Selections
#3 GWS - Jacob Hopper
#5 Sydney - Callum Mills
#7 GWS - Matthew Kennedy
#11 Brisbane - Ben Keays
#15 Brisbane - Eric Hipwood
#21 GWS - Harry Himmelberg
#28 St Kilda - Rice

Draft Order
1. Blues........Weitering (Best)
2. Lions........Schache (KPF who wants to go to Brisbane)
3. Melb.........Parish (Best mid available)
4. * .............Francis (strengthen back 6 as third tall/Bargain)
5. * .............Oliver (Leader, Strong mid, rolls forward and kicks Goals)
6. GC............Weideman (replace Dixon at KPF)
7. Melb.........H. McKay (complement Hogan/Ruck)
8. Blues........Curnow (KPF who runs all day to fit BB game plan ala Tomlinson)
9. Adel.........Burton (Best Forward of 2014/local KPF)
10. Blues......Collins (KPD - best still available)
11. Rich........Ah Chee (small forward silky skills)
12. Adel........Milera (Classy local bargain)
13. Saints.....Tucker (Outside Run Halfback/Mid)
14. Hawks.....B. McKay (ruck/KP versatility to replace Hale/Lake)
15. GC..........Mathieson (Highly rated Inside Mid)
16. North......Balic (mid with class to give more run and immediate impact, can play forward)
17. Hawks.....Hibberd (Classy Tasmanian Halfback)
18. Blues......Gresham (classy small mid we need to help Marc in the guts)
19. WB.........Clarke (midfield run)
20. WB.........Sam Skinner (key back)

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. Curnow
10. Collins
18. Gresham
59. SOSOS
60. Hardwick

 
Last edited:
1.Carlton ... Weitering
2.Brisbane ... Schache
3.Melbourne ... Curnow
4.* ... Parish
5.* ... Oliver
6.GC ... Milera
7.Melbourne ... Francis
8.Carlton ...Weideman
9.Adelaide ... H McKay
10.Carlton ... Burton
11.Richmond ... Gresham
12.Adelaide ... Collins
13.St.Kilda ... Mathieson
14.Hawthorn ... Hibberd
15.GC ... Tucker
16.NM ... Ah Chee
17.Hawthorn ... Balic
18.Carlton ... Cunningham
19.Footscray ... B.McKay
20.Footscray ... Rioli

Carlton Selections :
1.Weitering
8. H McKay
10.Collins
18.Gresham
59 60.Silvagni
 
1. Carlton - Weitering
2. Brisbane - Schache
3. Sydney - Mills
4. GWS - Hopper
5. Melbourne - Curnow
6. GWS - Kennedy
7. Essendon - Oliver
8. Essendon - Parish
9. Gold Coast - Milera
10. Melbourne - Francis
11. Brisbane - Hipwood
12. Carlton - Weideman
13. Adelaide - Mathieson
14. Carlton - H McKay
15. Richmond - Ah Chee
16. Adelaide - Balic
17. Brisbane - Keays
18. St Kilda - Gresham
19. Hawthorn - Collins
20. Gold Coast - Clarke

Carlton - Weitering, Weideman, McKay, Dunkley, Silvagni
 
1. Carlton - Weitering
2. Brisbane - Schache
3. Sydney - Mills
4. GWS - Hopper
5. Melbourne - Weidemann
6. GWS - Kennedy
7. Essendon - Francis
8. Essendon - Parish
9. Gold Coast - Curnow
10. Melbourne - Oliver
11. Brisbane - Hipwood
12. Carlton - H.McKay
13. Adelaide - Milera
14. Carlton - Collins
15. Richmond - Ah Chee
16. Adelaide - Balic
17. Brisbane - Keays
18. St Kilda - Tucker
19. Hawthorn - B. McKay
20. Gold Coast - Mathieson

Carlton: Weitering, H. McKay, Collins, Burton (or Gresham if Burton is not available), Silvagni.

EDIT: Anything is possible now that Curnow has been arrested.
I am thinking that we a) won't take 3 talls and b) will take Cunningham with what was originally our pick 19.
Burton and Gresham are looking unlikely for us now.

I have changed my mind on the mids that might be available at our pics since Melbourne have made it clear that they want Weidemann. McKay is too good to pass up at our second pick and I like Balic but I think that Collins is also too good to pass up at our 3rd pick.
He has had a good combination with Weitering and with Jamison and Rowe being ordinary last season, then I think it would be crazy to let him slip even though most will say that it is too early to pick him.
We are in a long rebuild and we need to take quality KPP's as soon as they are available.
Silvagni and Bolton are keen on Burton and will take him if he is available to us, so it could be an all tall draft with mids coming from the trade period, rookie and pre-season drafts.
I think we will go for Menegola as well but probably as a rookie.
 
Last edited:
1. Carlton - Weitering
2. Brisbane - Schache
3. Sydney - Mills
4. GWS - Hopper
5. Melbourne - Weidemann
6. GWS - Kennedy
7. Essendon - Francis
8. Essendon - Curnow
9. Gold Coast - Milera
10. Melbourne - Oliver
11. Brisbane - Hipwood
12. Carlton - Parish
13. Adelaide -H.McKay
14. Carlton - Collins
15. Richmond - Ah Chee
16. Adelaide - Balic
17. Brisbane - Keays
18. St Kilda - Tucker
19. Hawthorn - B. McKay
20. Gold Coast - Clark

1. Weitering
12. Parish* (Dream scenario....since its rumoured his interviewed poorly)
14. Collins
21. Burton* (Mathieson or Gresham if Burton is not available)
59. Silvagni
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Draft Order
1. Blues........Weitering
2. Lions........Schache
3. Melb.........Oliver
4. * .............Francis
5. * .............Parish
6. GC............Milera
7. Melb.........Weideman
8. Blues........H McKay
9. Adel.........Burton
10. Blues......Curnow
11. Rich........Ah Chee
12. Adel........Balic
13. Saints.....Mathieson
14. Hawks.....Collins
15. GC..........Gresham
16. North......Rioli
17. Hawks.....Hibberd
18. Blues......Cuningham
19. WB.........Tucker
20. WB.........B. McKay

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. McKay
10. Curnow
18. Cuningham
59. Silvagni
60. Schoenfield
 
Last edited:
ok, I'll give this a go...

Draft Order
1. Blues.........Weitering
2. Lions.........Schache
3. Melb.........Oliver
4. * .............Parish
5. * .............Weideman
6. GC............Ah Chee
7. Melb.........Curnow
8. Blues........Francis
9. Adel.........Burton
10. Blues......H. McKay
11. Rich........Milera
12. Adel........Rioli
13. Saints.....Tucker
14. Hawks.....Hibberd
15. GC..........Gresham
16. North......Balic
17. Hawks.....Collins
18. Blues......Cunningham
19. WB.........B. McKay
20. WB.........Bonner
Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. Francis
10. H. Mckay
18. Cunningham
 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues.........Weitering
2. Lions.........Schache
3. Melb.........Parish
4. * .............Francis
5. * .............Weideman
6. GC............Ah Chee
7. Melb.........H. McKay
8. Blues........Curnow
9. Adel.........Milera
10. Blues......Collins
11. Rich........Oliver
12. Adel........Burton
13. Saints.....Tucker
14. Hawks.....Bonner
15. GC..........Balic
16. North......Gresham
17. Hawks.....B McKay
18. Blues......Clarke
19. WB.........Hibberd
20. WB.........Mathieson

Carlton Selections
1. Weitering
8. H. McKay
11. Balic
19. Cuningham
59. SOS
60. SOS

Academy/FS
3. Melb - Mills
4. Ess - Kennedy
5. Ess - Hopper
6. GC - Keays
7. Melb - Hipwood
19. Carl - Rice
 
Last edited:
Draft Order
1. Blues......... J.Weitering
2. Lions......... J.Schache
3. Syd........... C.Mills (Academy Pick Melb Bid)
4. Melb......... C.OLiver
5. Gws.......... J.Hopper (Academy Pick * Bid)
6. *.............. D.Parish
7. *.............. C.Curnow
8. Gws.......... M.Kennedy (Academy Pick G.C Bid)
9. G.C........... A.Francis
10. Bris........ E.Hipwood (Academy Pick Melb Bid)
11. Melb........ S.Weideman
12. Blues....... H.McKay
13. Adel........ W.Milera
14. Blues...... J.Gresham
15. Rich........ C.Ah Chee
16. Adel........ R.Burton
17. Bris........ B.Keays (Academy Pick St.K Bid)
18. St.K........ D.Tucker
19. Haw........ K.Collins
20. G.C......... R.Bonner
21. N.M........ H.Balic
22. Haw........ M.Hibberd
23. Blues...... B.McKay
24. W.B......... B.Fiorini
25. W.B......... R.Mathieson

Carlton Selections
1. J.Weitering
8. H.McKay
11. J.Gresham
19. B.McKay
59. SOSOS
60. SOSOS
 
Last edited:
  1. Weitering - Carlton
  2. Schache - Brisbane
  3. Curnow - Melbourne
  4. Parish - Essendon
  5. Weideman - Essendon
  6. Francis - Gold Coast
  7. Oliver - Melbourne
  8. H.McKay - Carlton
  9. Milera - Adelaide
  10. Burton - Carlton
  11. Ah Chee - Richmond
  12. Bonner - Adelaide
  13. Balic - St Kilda
  14. Collins - Hawthorn
  15. Tucker - Gold Coast
  16. Gresham - North Melbourne
  17. Mathieson - Hawthorn
  18. Clarke - Carlton
  19. B.McKay - Western
  20. Hibberd - Western
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom