Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 3 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Braybrook Son]

How about you don't come onto a trade discussion board in the middle of trade week and suggest we don't talk about possible trades.

Are you Sam Power? No, ok, so you don’t have the authority to trade x player to x club for xx picks do you?

 

[Virgin Dog]

Should have seen the Saints board. Many are practically begging for someone to take Newnes off them. Has quite a lot of Clangers. Wingers need to be one of the cleanest users of the ball. Something we are needing, along with a bit of pace, in the wing position. We already struggle for clean delivery inside 50 to our forwards.

Newnes has (statistically) one of the best conversion rates from his inside 50 entries in the competition. Considering how poor Saints are in this area, it's quite surprising that Newnes would be ranked so high in that area. If we had more list spots available, I'd have been happy to try target the likes of Newnes, Bonar, Gray, etc. but as it stands, we will be drafting the minimum number of players, and don't even have space for any more than Bruce and Keath at this rate

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Newnes has (statistically) one of the best conversion rates from his inside 50 entries in the competition. Considering how poor Saints are in this area, it's quite surprising that Newnes would be ranked so high in that area. If we had more list spots available, I'd have been happy to try target the likes of Newnes, Bonar, Gray, etc. but as it stands, we will be drafting the minimum number of players, and don't even have space for any more than Bruce and Keath at this rate

Does that include or exclude Dickson? I believe you are expecting Dickson to be retained for 2020 when you concluded your post, is that right?

For the record, I'd prefer to have Dickson in 2020 than Newnes.

 

[Sentinel]

Are you Sam Power? No, ok, so you don’t have the authority to trade x player to x club for xx picks do you?

Might as well shut down BigFooty then if discussion isn't allowed.

What's your job at the Dogs by the way?

 

[Virgin Dog]

Does that include or exclude Dickson? I believe you are expecting Dickson to be retained for 2020 when you concluded your post, is that right?

For the record, I'd prefer to have Dickson in 2020 than Newnes.

I'm assuming Roberts is 100% gone, then it's up in the air whether Webb/Dickson play on (they would be 2nd and 3rd spots). So if Dickson plays on while Webb is delisted, then there would be no space for any other trade ins, unless I'm forgetting someone.

Would prefer Dickson over Newnes. Don't hate the idea of taking a punt on Bonar, but only if he costs us no more than Pick 53 on a 2 year deal. Pretty risky addition but could pay off big time

 

[Tommycash]

Gosh trade week absolutely sucks.

 

[TiAn_]

Been told a trade involving the Dees is about to drop.

 

[Dogsman16]

Been told a trade involving the Dees is about to drop.

Who else are the dees targeting? No one springs to mind.

 

[Virgin Dog]

Who else are the dees targeting? No one springs to mind.

Gawn about to be traded to the Dogs

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Senior list:
34 players contracted for 2020 beyond
(2020: Wood, Trengove, Schache, Jong, Lynch, Crozier, Lloyd, Duryea, B.Smith, Vandermeer, Greene, Porter, Suckling, Cavarra, Hayes)
(2021: Richards, Cordy, Wallis, Bontempelli, Lipinski, Liberatore, Le.Young, Williams)
(2022: Macrae, Johannisen, McLean, Daniel, Dunkley, English, West, Dale)
(2024: Hunter, Naughton)

6 senior list positions yet to be confirmed, likely to be filled by:
Bruce
Keath
Dickson/Webb/Roberts/or a surprise DFA
Pick 13
Late pick
Late pick (Rookie upgrade)

Rookie list:
R.Smith
Sweet
Khamis
La.Young
Gardner (mid-season rookie position)

I would think Dickson gets offered a 2020 contract ahead of Webb/Roberts, but he could be delisted if we are after another trade target or perhaps a DFA.

I would like La.Young to be upgraded but suspect R.Smith may be our choice.

 

[ivan rassmussen]

Dees apparently trading 2020 first and some later picks for North's #8 this year (Dees board and Jon Ralph so make of that what you will...)

 

[Doggy]

Senior list:
34 players contracted for 2020 beyond
(2020: Wood, Trengove, Schache, Jong, Lynch, Crozier, Lloyd, Duryea, B.Smith, Vandermeer, Greene, Porter, Suckling, Cavarra, Hayes)
(2021: Richards, Cordy, Wallis, Bontempelli, Lipinski, Liberatore, Le.Young, Williams)
(2022: Macrae, Johannisen, McLean, Daniel, Dunkley, English, West, Dale)
(2024: Hunter, Naughton)

6 senior list positions yet to be confirmed, likely to be filled by:
Bruce
Keath
Dickson/Webb/Roberts/or a surprise DFA
Pick 13
Late pick
Late pick (Rookie upgrade)

Rookie list:
R.Smith
Sweet
Khamis
La.Young
Gardner (mid-season rookie position)

I would think Dickson gets offered a 2020 contract ahead of Webb/Roberts, but he could be delisted if we are after another trade target or perhaps a DFA.

I would like La.Young to be upgraded but suspect R.Smith may be our choice.

Our late/ rookie pick likely to be CCP

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Patton to Hawthorn for a bag of chips (future 4th tied to Melbourne) has dropped.

 

[TiAn_]

Dees apparently trading 2020 first and some later picks for North's #8 this year (Dees board and Jon Ralph so make of that what you will...)

It’s a ballsy move from the Dees.

 

[ivan rassmussen]

Patton to Hawthorn for a bag of chips (future 4th tied to Melbourne) has dropped.

His knees are worth more than anything between his ears, and they're both cactus.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Gawn about to be traded to the Dogs

English > Gawn

 

[Boyd oh Boyd]

If Jack Steven is about to go to Geelong for pick 58 then surely we can get Bruce for 32?

 

[ivan rassmussen]

It’s a ballsy move from the Dees.

Gives them 3 and 8 this year - unless they trade one of them for a surprise in the next 30 hours!

 

[Northernsoul74]

If Jack Steven is about to go to Geelong for pick 58 then surely we can get Bruce for 32?

Yes as expected they need us for the Jones trade.

 

[Dogsman16]

How do Hawthorn continue to get players for bags of chips. Glad McCartney is not our list manager anymore. That deal sucks.

Yes it’s a salary dump but other melb clubs are crying out for a key forward.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Our late/ rookie pick likely to be CCP

Is Cat B rookie an option?

 

[Doggy]

Is Cat B rookie an option?

Don't think he lasts that long

 

[_M_16_]

Gives them 3 and 8 this year - unless they trade one of them for a surprise in the next 30 hours!

If their interest in Weightman is true, then probably allows them to NAB him at 8, instead of 3 which is high for him. And allows them to target someone else at 3. This draft must appeal to their needs hence the move.

 

[dergert]

Gowers to the dees please

 

[Northernsoul74]

If their interest in Weightman is true, then probably allows them to NAB him at 8, instead of 3 which is high for him. And allows them to target someone else at 3. This draft must appeal to their needs hence the move.

Wow that seems early for Weightman.