List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

[eagles rule]

He would not want to coach EP. Why leave a winning environment to go to a club that has no sole focus on winning. I hear what you are saying but it would be full time assistant to Simpson or stay at Subi.

Depends on how committed to joining the Afl circus he was as I don't think he has expressed a desire to coach at a higher level . I think Schofield would be a better choice than Jamie GRaham or Adam Selwood in the development roles .

 

[ArdentEagle]

does any one rate matt guelfi.

I watched a handful of wa's u/18's this year and was super impressed by fisher. size seems to be his concern but he is only a cm shorter than neale and plays a similair sort of game.

Monocle - This guy was on my list...What do you know about him mate?

 

[avishka5]

This brings a tear to my eyes

 

[swannies]

I rate Guelfi, yes, avishka5 uncertain about Fisher, because he's come from nowhere, so haven't seen a lot of him.
Guelfi, Banfield and Goddard tore Swans a new one in the colts finals last year.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

View attachment 287547

Head up Corey, do you really want to play with those clowns from Thursday night?

Bigger and better things.

 

[new breed]

does any one rate matt guelfi.

I watched a handful of wa's u/18's this year and was super impressed by fisher. size seems to be his concern but he is only a cm shorter than neale and plays a similair sort of game.

Guelfi has played half a dozen league games and would fit what we need at a lower pick ....tenacious hard running player . Positive Leader with a bit of attitude .

Havent seem him play enough but just seems to fit our need at a low pick too .
Doubt we will get him though , lower picks probably used on tall or KPP .

 

[the harry]

View attachment 287547
This brings a tear to my eyes

What was the ongoing cost of keeping him really? We've kept worse players around longer.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

What was the ongoing cost of keeping him really? We've kept worse players around longer.

Yeah, like Brophy on the exact same Rookie deal.

 

[swannies]

View attachment 287547
This brings a tear to my eyes

Why avishka? I don't mean to be rude to all those that seem to adore him on here but he was never going to make it, I didn't think.
Before anyone gets the shits, yes, it was worth the punt.

 

[Cerpin Taxt]

View attachment 287547
This brings a tear to my eyes

Wow, harsh.

i thought he was tracking along more or less exactly as what may have been expected.

 

[sey666]

This guy (b 1981), if he can shed some weight (well a lot) and have a decent preseason, would be a better ruck option than Petrie (b 1982) for next year.

 

[eagles rule]

I rate Guelfi, yes, avishka5 uncertain about Fisher, because he's come from nowhere, so haven't seen a lot of him.
Guelfi, Banfield and Goddard tore Swans a new one in the colts finals last year.

How do you rate Griffin Logue ?
I wouldn't be unhappy if we took him with our 1st pick .

 

[Carbine Chaos]

How do you rate Griffin Logue ?
I wouldn't be unhappy if we took him with our 1st pick .

Massive reach there.

 

[wraglesweb]

Shai Bolton profile on AFL Draft Central. - If he's as good as the profile, he'd be worth our 1st. (Bruce is excited)
https://afl*******************/player/shai-bolton/

It's definitely a possibility.

 

[avishka5]

Why avishka? I don't mean to be rude to all those that seem to adore him on here but he was never going to make it, I didn't think.
Before anyone gets the shits, yes, it was worth the punt.

i find it a bit harsh concidering we have kept useless players such as college and mcginnity on our list. The fact that ginna got 9 seasons on our list is a blight on our list management. But the tears i was reffering to is his instagram post. Its kinda sad seeing stuff like this from players.

 

[avishka5]

h

Guelfi has played half a dozen league games and would fit what we need at a lower pick ....tenacious hard running player . Positive Leader with a bit of attitude .

Havent seem him play enough but just seems to fit our need at a low pick too .
Doubt we will get him though , lower picks probably used on tall or KPP .

hows his contested game. Hard running is fine but the lack of contested mids really hurt us.

 

[avishka5]

This guy (b 1981), if he can shed some weight (well a lot) and have a decent preseason, would be a better ruck option than Petrie (b 1982) for next year.

View attachment 287553

Thats would be awesome. Its would take me back to my childhood when a retired wrestler returns from no where.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

If Natanui was not injured I think he would be gone, but they will hang on to him now.

Yea thats what i think as well.

 

[CM9000]

So, I think these players have a chance of being on our list next year:
* Wells
* Swallow/Coniglio
* Rotham
* SPP
* Logue
* Guefli
* Lobb
* A/J Waterman
* Shai/Jye Bolton
* Tim English

 

[new breed]

h

hows his contested game. Hard running is fine but the lack of contested mids really hurt us.

Guelfi is hard at it with a bit of mongrel at under age level i dont where he will go in the draft ....so many more high profile draftees , Guelfi seems to go under the radar .

Pretty good third or fourth round pick but might be a player that could or should go earlier . Just goes under the radar .

 

[eagles rule]

Massive reach there.

A reach yes but another player that sits in a awkward gone before 2nd pick scenario.

 

[sey666]

Thats would be awesome. Its would take me back to my childhood when a retired wrestler returns from no where.

First Eagle to play 300 games?

 

[WCErevival]

So, I think these players have a chance of being on our list next year:
* Wells
* Swallow/Coniglio
* Rotham
* SPP
* Logue
* Guefli
* Lobb
* A/J Waterman
* Shai/Jye Bolton
* Tim English

Coniglio? Don't think there is much chance at all

 

[eagles rule]

So, I think these players have a chance of being on our list next year:

* Rotham
* SPP
* Logue
* Guefli
* Lobb
* A/J Waterman
* Shai/Jye Bolton

Edited for accuracy .

 

[WCEswift]

Delistings.

Bennell
Colledge
Adamson
Lucas
Mcginnity
Waterman