Trade hypotheticals

[bloke_]

Beams and Lumumba for Kennedy and Pick 7

come on

If I was the Eagles I'd do it. Maybe Darling instead of Kennedy

 

[apuchar]

I think Hannath will either be traded or delisted at seasons end for that reason. He isn't a required player really. A 3rd rounder would be good compensation

Read somewhere that Griffen is being looked at by the Adelaide clubs. Might change the situation with Hannath.

 

[markm106]

If we lose Frawley I'm pretty sure Roos will be putting a top 5 pick on the table for a couple of big/tall mids. Or one if they are worth it. Thinking O'Rourke but we would need more than just him.

 

[Unknown Identity]

If we lose Frawley I'm pretty sure Roos will be putting a top 5 pick on the table for a couple of big/tall mids. Or one if they are worth it. Thinking O'Rourke but we would need more than just him.

if you stay where you are on the ladder, you are going to most likely get Christian Petracca. 186cm and 92kg. Ready to go. Absolute Beast.

With 5 you can take Brayshaw or Durdin.

I'd be holding pick 5 unless the perfect deal came along.

 

[markm106]

if you stay where you are on the ladder, you are going to most likely get Christian Petracca. 186cm and 92kg. Ready to go. Absolute Beast.

With 5 you can take Brayshaw or Durdin.

I'd be holding pick 5 unless the perfect deal came along.

Yeah I was thinking Petracca or Brayshaw would be on our radar. Still think Roos might look at another deal like we did last year to land Tyson and Salem.

 

[bloke_]

Read somewhere that Griffen is being looked at by the Adelaide clubs. Might change the situation with Hannath.

What do you think he'd go for?

 

[Unknown Identity]

Yeah I was thinking Petracca or Brayshaw would be on our radar. Still think Roos might look at another deal like we did last year to land Tyson and Salem.

Yeah fair call.

I honestly think you would be mad not to select Petracca. He is now coming into pick 1 or 2 calculations, which means Wright or McCartin may fall to pick 3.

His game on the weekend was extraordinary, 32 touches 10 marks 5 goals.

 

[markm106]

Yeah fair call.

I honestly think you would be mad not to select Petracca. He is now coming into pick 1 or 2 calculations, which means Wright or McCartin may fall to pick 3.

His game on the weekend was extraordinary, 32 touches 10 marks 5 goals.

Yeah saw those stats. He would walk straight in next year.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Yeah saw those stats. He would walk straight in next year.

Even last year as an under-ager he was impressive. Picking up 22-25 touches a game with a couple of goals, but his improvement has been phenomenal. I'd be licking my lips as a Dee's supporter.

You'd be effectively bringing in to your team next year..

Petracca
Pick 5
Jesse Hogan

Exciting times.

 

[apuchar]

What do you think he'd go for?

I have no idea, but if both Adelaide clubs want him that should increase the trade value. He was approached by Port a couple of years ago and chose to stay with Freo, not sure if he feels any differently now.
I will be curious to see what they do with Moller assuming that he cannot remain on the rookie list. Upgrade or delist/re-rookie or delist?

 

[Two Planks]

Petracca and McCartin are virtually locks for 1 and 2. Peter Wright is going to fall into that "is he a ruckman or is he a forward" type discussion. I can see Melbourne slipping to bottom 2 and ending up with picks 2 and 3.

 

[ArdentEagle]

Beams and Lumumba for Kennedy and Pick 7

come on

I'd actually do that deal.

 

[ArdentEagle]

What would you give for Ben Howlett ? Not the A-Grader but he'd give better support for Priddis

That's a tricky one...As a direct swap, I think all the players I could offer you of equivalent value, Essendon have no need for.
Our 3rd round pick is under and our 2nd is required.

 

[ArdentEagle]

We'd be after pick 7, problem is we can't really offer mids, only talls which you don't need. Conca's the only one because there is the sweetener of going home. Would Conca and our second rounder get pick 7?

Conca really is a cherry on top of the cake but not what we really need.
I'd have to say no to this offer.

 

[bloke_]

I have no idea, but if both Adelaide clubs want him that should increase the trade value. He was approached by Port a couple of years ago and chose to stay with Freo, not sure if he feels any differently now.
I will be curious to see what they do with Moller assuming that he cannot remain on the rookie list. Upgrade or delist/re-rookie or delist?

I think we will re-rookie. Not good enough for the senior list but needs time to bulk up

 

[apuchar]

I think we will re-rookie. Not good enough for the senior list but needs time to bulk up

Seems the most likely scenario. Just have to see if anyone picks him up before our rookie pick. From what I have seen and heard about Moller this year I doubt clubs will stop us from picking him up again if he wants to stay at Freo. He does show potential at times though.

 

[apuchar]

What do you think he'd go for?

Seems to be a pretty speculative article in hindsight, not to mention factually inaccurate through most of it. Can happen when you read something at midnight
http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/af...lian-jon-griffin/story-fniv64vs-1226987447234

 

[bloke_]

Seems to be a pretty speculative article in hindsight, not to mention factually inaccurate through most of it. Can happen when you read something at midnight
http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/af...lian-jon-griffin/story-fniv64vs-1226987447234

Cheers for the article. I actually meant what would it take to trade him from a Freo perspective

 

[eth-dog]

That's a tricky one...As a direct swap, I think all the players I could offer you of equivalent value, Essendon have no need for.
Our 3rd round pick is under and our 2nd is required.

Would Howlett + 19 for Darling suffice? He's the bloke we really need from you. It's an awkward deal for both sides due to lack of picks on our part

 

[blueiris]

Petracca and McCartin are virtually locks for 1 and 2. Peter Wright is going to fall into that "is he a ruckman or is he a forward" type discussion. I can see Melbourne slipping to bottom 2 and ending up with picks 2 and 3.

Don't think so Brisbane will have pick 2

 

[bumsonseats]

Interested in peoples thoughts on David Hale. Has been overtaken by Ceglar and McEvoy and we have Lowden in the wings.

Hale has recently turned 30 and hasn't had the greatest of years after a pretty good finals series last year. There are definitely a few clubs looking for a ruckman that might be interested.

Was thinking that as a standalone trade we would be lucky to get anything more than an early 4th rounder. What are people's thoughts about his value from a pick upgrade perspective. Is there any potential for a 2nd round pick upgrade or is that a bit ambitious.

 

[Snake Charmer]

What wou

Would Howlett + 19 for Darling suffice? He's the bloke we really need from you. It's an awkward deal for both sides due to lack of picks on our part

As much as I'd love to see this happen. It would no way be enough for Darling. He is worth a top 10 pick.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Interested in peoples thoughts on David Hale. Has been overtaken by Ceglar and McEvoy and we have Lowden in the wings.

Actually would be interested as he would allow us to use Ryder in a full time ruck role, however would be just an upgrade sort of deal. Wouldn't want to give the bank.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Interested in peoples thoughts on David Hale. Has been overtaken by Ceglar and McEvoy and we have Lowden in the wings.

Hale has recently turned 30 and hasn't had the greatest of years after a pretty good finals series last year. There are definitely a few clubs looking for a ruckman that might be interested.

Was thinking that as a standalone trade we would be lucky to get anything more than an early 4th rounder. What are people's thoughts about his value from a pick upgrade perspective. Is there any potential for a 2nd round pick upgrade or is that a bit ambitious.

Would be worthwhile purely for the novelty of having the highest hairline in sporting history on your list.

 

[bone2468]

Would Howlett + 19 for Darling suffice? He's the bloke we really need from you. It's an awkward deal for both sides due to lack of picks on our part

How bout Hannath and 3rd rounder for Ben Howlett?