Trade hypotheticals

[LukeParkerno1]

There's other options available. Lowden? Giles? Leuwenberg? Griffin?

Giles and Lowden are the obvious two. Leuy and Griffin would cost too much, Leuy coming off a major injury

 

[V23]

Pick 4 + Leuenburger for Beams and Collingwood's second round pick?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Pick 4 + Leuenburger for Beams and Collingwood's second round pick?

Why is Leunenberger who is so injury prone worth it- he is 28 they have Grundy, what's the point! Pies will take pick 4 + pick 25 (give and take, Brisbane's 2nd and be done with it). Moore plus Durdin or Wright is a decent outcome.

 

[V23]

Why is Leunenberger who is so injury prone worth it- he is 28 they have Grundy, what's the point! Pies will take pick 4 + pick 25 (give and take, Brisbane's 2nd and be done with it). Moore plus Durdin or Wright is a decent outcome.

He's 26 and can be their primary ruck until Grundy fully develops.

 

[Defacto]

Giles and Lowden are the obvious two. Leuy and Griffin would cost too much, Leuy coming off a major injury

i reckon giles is your man. would fit right in quick and i reckon he'd be prepared to go to a premiership side

 

[blueiris]

Why is Leunenberger who is so injury prone worth it- he is 28 they have Grundy, what's the point! Pies will take pick 4 + pick 25 (give and take, Brisbane's 2nd and be done with it). Moore plus Durdin or Wright is a decent outcome.

We hold the Aces though only wants to go to Brisbane
pick 4 and Merrett to GWS. WHE to Collingwood. BEAMS to Brisbane

 

[iGNITER]

He's 26 and can be their primary ruck until Grundy fully develops.

No thanks.

Witts and Grundy need game time together.
Definitely not interested in Leuenberger.

 

[danielnajdek]

Why is Leunenberger who is so injury prone worth it- he is 28 they have Grundy, what's the point! Pies will take pick 4 + pick 25 (give and take, Brisbane's 2nd and be done with it). Moore plus Durdin or Wright is a decent outcome.

Witts is our number one ruck atm.

 

[Defacto]

jones (WB) for z clarke (Freo) would be a win/win

 

[bloke_]

jones (WB) for z clarke (Freo) would be a win/win

Not really

 

[eaglespremiers]

We hold the Aces though only wants to go to Brisbane
pick 4 and Merrett to GWS. WHE to Collingwood. BEAMS to Brisbane

Would Collingwood be happy with effectively a straight trade Beams for Hoskin-Elliott?

 

[blueiris]

Would Collingwood be happy with effectively a straight trade Beams for Hoskin-Elliott?

I don't know but Hosky is great young player would love him at Brisbane

 

[LukeParkerno1]

We hold the Aces though only wants to go to Brisbane
pick 4 and Merrett to GWS. WHE to Collingwood. BEAMS to Brisbane

WHE is untradeable!

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Witts is our number one ruck atm.

Close enough but the point stands a ruck is the last thing Collingwood need

 

[danielnajdek]

Close enough but the point stands a ruck is the last thing Collingwood need

Agree totally.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Agree totally.

Especially one at 26 who gets injured every month

 

[blueiris]

WHE is untradeable!

It doesn't have to be Hoskin-Elliott any of the GWS young players willing to go to Collingwood would do

 

[daniel23]

I don't know but Hosky is great young player would love him at Brisbane

Hes a great young player exactly why would gws want to get rid of him to bring in another young player

 

[blueiris]

Hes a great young player exactly why would gws want to get rid of him to bring in another young player

I don't think he will leave just Brought up a name that I thought would make Collingwood happy to trade for.

 

[Sydswans0512]

i reckon giles is your man. would fit right in quick and i reckon he'd be prepared to go to a premiership side

I reckon your right mate, wouldn't cost much and he's at the right age

 

[LukeParkerno1]

It doesn't have to be Hoskin-Elliott any of the GWS young players willing to go to Collingwood would do

Summner might be a chance I guess but WHE is worth a top 2 pick

 

[SnowRoo]

How about:

Beams to Bris
Pick 4, Aaron Mullett + Pick 53(North 3rd) to Pies
Pick 24(Bris 2nd) + 45 (Pies 3rd) to North

?

 

[blueiris]

How about:

Beams to Bris
Pick 4, Aaron Mullett + Pick 53(North 3rd) to Pies
Pick 24(Bris 2nd) + 45 (Pies 3rd) to North

?

Lol Collingwood are not going to want Mullet not to mention that's a ridiculous trade for Brisbane

 

[SnowRoo]

Lol Collingwood are not going to want Mullet

Ummm Pies are the team apparently chasing him according to afl.com.au

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Ummm Pies are the team apparently chasing him according to afl.com.au

But not for pick 24! That is just Crazy Vossy style trading! Would be for a 4th rounder or a late upgrade