News Update: Charles Cameron traded to Brisbane for Pick 12

[Elite Crow]

What about this.. Charlie Cameron and pick 10 for Brisbanes pick 1 and 2018 first?

Why has it taken so long for a sensible suggestion?

 

[glengowan]

I don't want Cameron to play for the Crows next year now. Take Pick 18 OR a bonus if we can get Pick 12 or a huge bonus if we package up for future 1st round.

Give Cameron's spot to Milera and/or Galluci. It might improve us.

 

[arrowman]

I am no list manager either and I wouldn’t do the trade for pick 12, especially if there is no best 22 player coming our way.

JR rightly said pick 12 doesn’t have 70 games of AFL experience, won’t play 20-25 games for us next year, nor will pick 12 help us go one better next year.

We are in the window. We should be improving the 22 for next year and not worry about maximizing the value for a draft pick that will be 3 years away from being best 22 player at best.

Fair call but surely 12+ a player (from Bris or elsewhere) is unachievable. Maybe 18+? I dunno. Something's got to be cooking. I hope.

 

[70lethal]

Who wins this
Cameron to Brisbane
Schache to Bulldogs
Stringer to Essendon
Francis + pick 24 to Adelaide
Gibbs to Adelaide for 16+24 swap our 2nd for there 2nd next year
Kennedy to Carlton for pick 24

who needs steak knives

 

[Samcro24]

I see some of our posters are still coming to terms with breaking away from the David Noble "School of accepting the first shitty offer so you can move on to other deals".

 

[AusTerran]

I know, stupid idea, but...
CC + Pick 10 for 2018 1st Pick? (Guessing between Pick 3 to 7) or Pick 1 this year.

 

[Squiba]

Who wins this
Cameron to Brisbane
Schache to Bulldogs
Stringer to Essendon
Francis + pick 24 to Adelaide
Gibbs to Adelaide for 16+24 swap our 2nd for there 2nd next year
Kennedy to Carlton for pick 24

who needs steak knives

We win it

 

[AusTerran]

Who wins this
Cameron to Brisbane
Schache to Bulldogs
Stringer to Essendon
Francis + pick 24 to Adelaide
Gibbs to Adelaide for 16+24 swap our 2nd for there 2nd next year
Kennedy to Carlton for pick 24

who needs steak knives

CC + Pick 24 is overs for Francis IMHO

 

[Redline]

I get the comment we want a player who can play 22 games but Cameron really didn't have a good year besides the Prelim. I think he can be replaced without to much trouble.

The loss of Smith and Lever is more concerning.

I'd trade for pick 18 (I doubt 12 is even in the conversation)

 

[Kenny Dee]

Surely we're at a stage where we try improve our list for the now. Really hoping for something in the next few days...

 

[Pea Nut]

Surely we're at a stage where we try improve our list for the now. Really hoping for something in the next few days...

Everything Reid has said, especially today, reinforces this.

 

[Kenny Dee]

Everything Reid has said, especially today, reinforces this.

Any idea who we are trying to get from Brisbane?

 

[Samcro24]

CC + Pick 24 is overs for Francis IMHO

Shades of the Menzel deal.

 

[Pea Nut]

CC + Pick 24 is overs for Francis IMHO

It's CC for Francis and 24. Then forward 24 along with our 16 to Carlton for Gibbs.

 

[70lethal]

CC + Pick 24 is overs for Francis IMHO

Essendon pick 24

Shades of the Menzel deal.

Its not our 24 its Essendons

 

[Pea Nut]

Any idea who we are trying to get from Brisbane?

Unfortunately not. Wish I did.

 

[pirate bob]

We're not trading cc and we're not getting Gibbs and the last week of my life for 2-4 hours every day reading BF was all a waste of time because we're not gonna get squat

Do you need a hug?

 

[pirate bob]

Why has it taken so long for a sensible suggestion?

sensible quote from penis blister?

 

[70lethal]

Schache, Motlop, Watts, Weller, Rockliff, Cameron, Stringer, Smith, Kennedy, Lever
Talk about a soft bunch without much leadership between them

 

[BACCS]

Players I would target from Brisbane; Berry, Witherden, Zorko, Cox, McCluggage. Pay something extra if needed.

On HTC_PN071 using BigFooty.com mobile app

Would take Harris Andrews before everyone there but Zorko.

 

[Pea Nut]

Would take Harris Andrews before everyone there but Zorko.

Andrews would also be more 'untouchable' than Zorko.

 

[Crowhorse]

Who wins this
Cameron to Brisbane
Schache to Bulldogs
Stringer to Essendon
Francis + pick 24 to Adelaide
Gibbs to Adelaide for 16+24 swap our 2nd for there 2nd next year
Kennedy to Carlton for pick 24

who needs steak knives

Assuming the Gibbs trade is combined and not separate. We won't be unloading CC without him. This is incredibly achievable I would have thought, but Bulldogs and Carlton seem indecisive on what they want and will be hardest to please with their respective lists of basketcases.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Any idea who we are trying to get from Brisbane?

Cameron

 

[AusTerran]

It's CC for Francis and 24. Then forward 24 along with our 16 to Carlton for Gibbs.

My mistake!
That is a better deal, wouldn't touch Francis myself (as Samcro24 said, Menzel type player/Deal)
16 +24 Over playing for Gibbs even if you add their 2nd round pick for next year.

 

[mistylake]

Why do you believe that?

Why wouldn't have Charlie just said "no I'm gonna play crap and don't want to be here so you better get a deal done"?

I don’t recon he’d have the balls to say that to the coach and if he did were ****ed.