Votes V Melbourne

[Plugga]

I'm too disgruntled to write anything else, so I'll kick it off...

5 Pav
4 Solly
3 Palmer (though quiet 2nd half - who wasn't, besides those above him)
2 Crowley
1 Sandilands

 

[Freo Big Fella]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Palmer
2. Crowley
1. Ibbo

 

[Lach72]

5 Solomon
4 Pavlich
3 Ibbotson
2 Palmer
1 Crowley

 

[beautime]

What about Sandilands, I thought he was alright.

 

[toenail11]

5 pav
4 solly
3 crowley
2 palmer
1 ibbo

 

[Freeeoo]

1. Pav
2. Solly
3. Palmer
2. Ibbo
1. Crowley

 

[ImperialPurple]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Palmer
2. Ibbo
1. Crowley

 

[Latro]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Crowley
2. Ibbotson
1. Sandi

 

[Ripper]

5 Solomon
4 Pavlich
3 Ibbotson
2 Palmer
1 Crowley

Same here

 

[Freo Shark]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Sandi
2. Ibbo
1. Palmer

 

[Shaymuhz]

5. Pav
4. Crowley (i think his job on jones was outstanding)
3. Solly
2. Sandilands
1. Farmer

 

[estibador]

5. Pav - that goal from the centre square was one of the best the big fella has ever kicked. His 5 min burst to stop Melbourne's momentum dead in it's tracks was inspirational stuff - he deserves better from his teammates.

4. Solly
3. Crowley - awesome job. Looks twice the player when he's focused on a task. I think we've seen the last of M.Carr.
2. Palmer
1. Ibbo

 

[Cameron_K]

5 Solomon
4 Pavlich
3 Ibbotson
2 Palmer
1 Crowley

Same for me

 

[Kenny_01]

5- Solomon
4- Pavlich
3- Palmer
2- Ibbotson
1- Crowley

 

[hoss]

5 Solly
4 Pav
3 Crowley
2 Ibbo
1 Palmer

 

[dockers_bengals]

5.Pav
4.sandi
3.palmer
2.Bell
1.crowley

 

[freocuz]

5 Solly
4 Pav
3 Crowley
2 Ibbo
1 Palmer

I echo these sentiments.

 

[The Night Shift]

5. Pavlich
4. Palmer
3. Solomon
2. Ibbotson
1. Sandilands

 

[Avid_Avenger]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Palmer
2. Sandi
1. Ibbo

Unlucky: Crowley.

 

[Nodgey]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Bell
2. Palmer
1. Tarrant

 

[Belnakor]

5. Pav
4. Solly
3. Palmer
2. Ibbo
1. Sandi

 

[PapaJ]

5. Pav - hard to decide between Pav and ...
4. Solomon - along with Pav, was the closest too looking like a true AFL 4 quarter player
3. Palmer - tried hard all day, in and out a bit, but did well again.
2. Crowley - great tagging role again.
1. Farmer - almost left him out of my top 5 but was struggling to see who could take his spot. If he had have kicked 4-2 instead of 2-4 then would have been even higher. In any case, was energetic worked fairly hard and certainly not one of our worst.

Unlucky:
- Sandi was solid, though Melbourne negated him fairly well I thought.
- Ibbo, great first half and good user of the ball.

 

[ImperialPurple]

Anyone else? We've had 24 hours to digest the result - anyone else want to add in anything?

I'll be adding these up later today.

 

[big blue boy]

5 Pav
4 Sandi
3 Ibbo
2 Palmer
1 Farmer

 

[bfff]

It hurts to vote.

5 - Ibbotson
4 - Pav
3 - Solomon
2 - Palmer
1 - Farmer