Votes v St Kilda round 16

[NTRabbit]

POTY
5. Ben Rutten - Only Crow who won his position all day
4. Simon Goodwin
3. Brodie Martin - Played like his future depended on it, never gave up and got most of what he did right
2. Andy Otten
1. Scott Thompson - Owned the first quarter, but faded as the game went on

BTM
3. Ben Rutten - All 3 of these for being the only players on the field who showed the rest how to stand up and keep trying
2. Scott Stevens
1. Brodie Martin

ROTY
3. Brodie Martin (Assuming he is eligible?)
2. Andy Otten
1. -

 

[Alex99]

POTY
5. Ben Rutten
4. Simon Goodwin
3. Brodie Martin
2. Andy Otten
1. Scott Thompson

You serious? were you watching the same match. He had little to no impact at all - how the fudge did he get second best?

 

[Riggy1]

poty
5. Thompson
4. Martin
3. Rutten
2. Otten
1. Goodwin
roty
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. Sellar

 

[NTRabbit]

He had little to no impact at all

In a game where precisely zero Crows had an impact. Not one.

 

[Alex99]

In a game where precisely zero Crows had an impact. Not one.

You clearly disagree – leave it at that.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

POTY
5. Scott Thompson
4. Ben Rutten
3. Brodie Martin
2. Michael Doughty
1. Andy Otten

BTM
3. Ben Rutten
2. Scott Stevens
1. Brodie Martin

ROTY
3. Brodie Martin
2. Andy Otten
1. Patrick Dangerfield

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

POTY:
5. Rutten
4. Thompson
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. Doughty

BTM:
3. Rutten
2. Martin
1. Stevens

ROTY:
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. Dangerfield

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

5. Scott Thompson
4. Ben Rutten
3. Brodie Martin
2. Andy Otten
1. Simon Goodwin

BTM
3. Ben Rutten
2. Brodie Martin
1. Scott Stevens

ROTY
3. Brodie Martin
2. Andy Otten

 

[relapse]

5, Thompson
4. Martin
Daylight
More daylight
3. Truck
2. Goody (though most of his possessions were across ground)
1. Otten

 

[jackster83]

POTY
5. Rutten - Pantsed that dirty, buck toothed, overrated, bean pole Koshitski.
4. Thompson - Great first quarter, tried so hard but had little help.
3. Martin - Great debut today. Nice skills and some run and carry, not to mention a lovely goal.
2. Doughty - Another who toiled hard and didn't make too many calamitous errors. 7 tackles
1. Reilly - Was decent in picking up 24 touches and 5 tackles.

BTM
3. Rutten
2. Stevens
1. Otten
Can we give Maric and Sellar minus BTM votes for forcing Tippett into the ruck?
If so then -2 Sellar and -1 Maric

ROTY
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. one of the Auskick kids

 

[macca23]

POTY

5. Thompson - had a real crack and always in the rough and tumble. Never intimated and always gives it 100%

4. Rutten - one of the very few Crow players that won his position. Kept a cooler head than most.

3. Martin - what a breath of fresh air this lad was. Has a ton of pace and wasn't intimitated by the guns of St kilda eg when he took Reiwoldt on bouncing the ball. Looks to have a great future.

2. Otten - made a few errors but he did have a real crack as well and tried to get some run and dash going - one of the few that did.

1. Doughty - Another who had a genuine crack and never looked intimidated. Has developed incredible hardness for a guy once considered soft. .


Best Team Man

3. Rutten - see above

2. Otten - see above

1.Dangerfield - only 11 possessions due to being left for far too long up forward, but still led the way in contested possessions. Tough.


Rookie

3. Martin - great effort playing so well against the best in a match in which we were thrashed. Liked what I saw.

2. Otten - see above

1. Dangerfield - see above

 

[Paladin]

POTY:
5. Rutten
4. Martin
3. Thompson
2. Goodwin
1. Otten

BTM:
3. Rutten
2. Goodwin
1. Otten

ROTY:
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. Dangerfield

 

[Vader]

Mostly stolen/copied from Macca's voting, with a couple of changes.

POTY

5. Thompson - had a real crack and always in the rough and tumble. Never intimated and always gives it 100%

4. Rutten - one of the very few Crow players that won his position. Kept a cooler head than most.

3. Otten - made a few errors but he did have a real crack as well and tried to get some run and dash going - one of the few that did.

2. Martin - what a breath of fresh air this lad was. Has a ton of pace and wasn't intimitated by the guns of St kilda eg when he took Reiwoldt on bouncing the ball. Looks to have a great future.

1. Doughty - Another who had a genuine crack and never looked intimidated. Has developed incredible hardness for a guy once considered soft. .


Best Team Man

3. Rutten - see above

2. Otten - see above

1.Dangerfield - only 11 possessions due to being left for far too long up forward, but still led the way in contested possessions. Tough.

ROTY

3. Otten - Is 26 disposals his PB for the season? I know Martin had a great debut, but seriously, Otten was the better player.

2. Martin - Outstanding debut game.

1. Dangermouse - Did enough to justify 1 vote, but nothing more.

 

[marvin]

BOG:

5: Thompson It was boys and one man versus men. Thanks to the one man.

4: Doughty Boxed on well, went in hard, and was far from our worst.

3: Otten A few mistakes, but took them on and kept his head up.

2: Stevens Battled hard.

1: Martin Spark plug

BTM:

3: Doughty One of the few to lay some tackles that stuck.

2: Martin As above

1: Otten As above

ROTY:

3 Otten
2 Martin
1 -

 

[cammo84]

POTY
5- Thompson
4- Rutten
3- Martin
2- Otten
1- Doughty

BTM
3- Rutten
2- Stevens
1- Martin

ROTY
3- Martin
2- Otten
1- Danger

(Pretty happy that Martin is pretty much a certainty to get a few votes in his first game. Top effort)

 

[toddflanders]

POTY
5. Rutten - Pantsed that dirty, buck toothed, overrated, bean pole Koshitski.
4. Thompson - Great first quarter, tried so hard but had little help.
3. Martin - Great debut today. Nice skills and some run and carry, not to mention a lovely goal.
2. Doughty - Another who toiled hard and didn't make too many calamitous errors. 7 tackles
1. Reilly - Was decent in picking up 24 touches and 5 tackles.

BTM
3. Rutten
2. Stevens
1. Otten
Can we give Maric and Sellar minus BTM votes for forcing Tippett into the ruck?
If so then -2 Sellar and -1 Maric

ROTY
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. one of the Auskick kids

when he was ruckin wasnt sellar up forward and ivan on the bench... u can hardly blame maric there

 

[musha_13]

POTY

5 Rutten - thought he beat Kosi and tried to set up a bit
4 Martin - the only excitment after quarter time, loved his run and bounces right in front of me on the wing, even had saints supporters applauding
3 Thompson - battled away all day
2 Otten - looked composed and not over-oared, did his job I thought
1 Symes - scraping the barrel but I thought symes did some good things and was alright

BTM
3 Stevens - once again was the ultimate swing man, Riewoldt stopped a little once Stevo dropped back in front of him
2 Rutten
1 Martin - loved the mark in the first quarter in defensive goal square after only 20 seconds earlier having a touch in our 50

ROTY
3 Martin
2 Otten
1 ........

 

[Damp Squarie]

POTY
5. Thompson
4. Martin
3. Rutten
2. Otten
1. Doughty


BTM
3. Rutten
2. Otten
1. Bock


ROTY
3. Martin
2. Otten
1. Dangerfield

 

[johnnypanther]

POTY:
5 Thompson
4 Rutten
3 Martin
2 Otten
1 Doughty

 

[Coopers]

2. Andy Otten

ROTY
3. Brodie Martin
2. Andy Otten

Just a bit confused at how this works?
How can otten be below Martin in your rankings, if Otten was in the top 5 and martin was not?

 

[Coopers]

5. Thommo: Gun
4. Goodwin: Tried to lift the team, had a lot of it. To no avail!
3. Otten
2. Rutten
1. Symtes: In and under!

BTM
3. Stevo
2. Dogga
1. Danger

ROTY
3. Otten
2. Martin
1. Ooooh, sellar or Danger. Well, Danger, you kicked a goal. So Danger.

 

[rooboy]

Poty
5 rutten
4 thommo
3 martin
2 doughty
1 otten


btm

3 rutten
2 thommo
3 doughty

roty

3 martin
2 otten

 

[WALL-e]

POTY
5. Thompson - Burrowed in packs as usual.
4. Martin - A spark of energy in a flat footed zombie field
3. Rutten - At least he beat his man
2. Otten - Tried to run and carry from the back when we were down, struggled with no running help
1. Stevens - Did well, works hard, not athletically gifted, but tries very hard.

BTM
3. Rutten - Hard day, got it done
2. Otten - tried to spark us
1. Dogga- team player


ROTY
3. Martin - very nice
2. Otten - tried
1. Dangerfield - not enough middle time. Would have been happy with a run in the HB line as well.

 

[Jars458]

Struggling to give more than Martin votes this week but here goes

5 Martin - livewire, broke the lines and wasn't intimidate dispite palyers like McLeod and Goodwin palying as if they were.

4 Thompson - immense first quarter but poor after that, at least he idd part of his job

3 - Otten - tried very hard and did some nice things

2 - Doughty - showing how vital solid palyers in their late 20's are

1 - Rutten - tried hard under immense pressure

Team Man

3 Dangerfield - so brave and hard

2 Symes - ditto

1 Thompsion

Rooke

3 Martin
2 Otten
1 - NA

 

[srv23]

POTY
5 - Thompson
4 - Rutten
3 - Martin
2 - Stevens
1 - Otten

BTM
3 - Rutten
2 - Stevens
1 - Otten

ROTY
3 - Martin
2 - Otten
1 - Dangerfield