Votes v Sydney Rnd 12

[Freo Big Fella]

Another week, Another Loss. Give Murphy some decent gametime Connolly!


5. Schammer
4. Cook
3. Gilmore
2. Bell
1. Farmer

 

[BB gun]

5 Cook
4 Schammer
3 Longmuir
2 Gilmore
1 Farmer

 

[ImperialPurple]

5. Cook
4. Farmer
3. Gilmore
2. Schammer
1. Bell
1. Johnson - he gets a vote too, because despite being beaten, stuck to his task, tried his guts out all day and didn't drop his head. That shows some courage.

Tried: Pav, Mundy, Parker, Smith

Needed more from: Hase, JLo

Schofield: W.O.S. (Waste of Space).
Carr & Black: MIA

Bloody lucky there's no-one left to replace them: Webster, Thornton

 

[hoss]

5. Cook
4. Farmer
3. Gilmore
2. Schammer
1. Bell
1. Johnson - he gets a vote too, because despite being beaten, stuck to his task, tried his guts out all day and didn't drop his head. That shows some courage.

Tried: Mundy, Parker, Smith

Needed more from: Hase, JLo

Schofield: W.O.S. (Waste of Space).
Carr & Black: MIA

Bloody lucky there's no-one left to replace them: Webster, Thornton

IP, I like the look of your votes. Can I be lazy and just say..."ditto" ?


(disagree on JLo though. I thought he was pretty good)

 

[FreoDocker]

5. Cook
4. Schammer
3. Farmer
2. Longmuir
1. Gilmore

 

[dugrene]

5. cook
4. farmer
3 happy
2 schammer
1 bell
1 jlo ... kept us in it in the 1st half.

Messed that up. I wont change it.

 

[BB gun]

Tried: Pav,
Needed more from: JLo

Black: MIA

How many goals has pav kicked this year. I wonder how his stats compare with 2003 and 2004.
Jlo played well, its was when sandi went into the ruck in the third quarter that the swans kicked three quick goals.
Black played in the back pocket

 

[auste1234]

5. Schammer
4. Cook
3. Mundy
2. Gilmore
1. Farmer/Pavlich

Not a great game from the leadership group, although there isnt many left at the moment. Bell played ok but got alot of cheap kicks.

Black and schoey where hopeless today. At the end of the day i never thought we would win, but i was hoping for a closer margain

 

[ImperialPurple]

How many goals has pav kicked this year. I wonder how his stats compare with 2003 and 2004.
Jlo played well, its was when sandi went into the ruck in the third quarter that the swans kicked three quick goals.
Black played in the back pocket

Pav was being man-handled all day with no frees awarded. At one stage on the wing, he was against 5 of them, stayed in the contest but in the end numbers won out. Where were his team-mates? Then seconds later the ball came back towards our end and took possession and pumped it inside 50. Agree, though, he should be kicking more goals, but there's not a lot else wrong with what he is doing. Perhaps could go a bit harder in second efforts when he is beaten to the ball... but is putting in week in and week out. Unlike many of his team-mates.

I didn't say J-Lo didn't play well, I agree he did play well... but he has become such a vital player that if he is even a little bit down, then the rest of the team is down as Sandi is not up to it yet (will he ever be??). Very, very harsh, but unfortunately true.

I know where Black was, and he had something like 2 possessions to three-quarter time. Like I said MIA. Not good enough for a team leader to have 2 possessions in three quarters of footy wherever he is played - unless he's injured and on the bench.

 

[Plugga]

5 Schammer
4 Cook
3 Gilmore
2 Mundy
1 Pavlich


5HITHOUSE FOOTBALLER OF THE YEAR AWARD;

5 Medhurst
4 Josh Carr
3 Heath Black
2 Webster
1 Schofield

 

[Scham]

5. Schammer
4. Mundy
3. Farmer
2. Cook
1. Bell

Gilmore was pathetic in the first half came back well in the second but couldn't put him above these guys plus Sandi and Jonno.

C'mon Plugga, do you seriosly think Medhust was worse than Webster?? Your joking aren't you?? Webster should never have played today, and if he is a better option than Woods I'll go hee!!! Put a line through his name never to play again - he's hopeless!

 

[Ripper]

5: Cookie
4: Gilmore (played on Goodes all day and broke even after a scrathie start.)
3: Bellie
2: Scham
1: M.J. Played on BBBH, Never dropped his head and actually got better as the day went on. Will have learnt heaps today.

 

[Moo]

5. Cook
4. Farmer
3. Schammer
2. Gilmore
1. J Lo

Moo Hoo

 

[pinkus maximus]

5 schammer
4 cook
3 farmer
2 mundy
1 gilmore

 

[whizzbert]

5. Bell
4. Cookie
3. Mundy
2. Scham
1. JLo

 

[voodoo_86]

5. cook
4. scham
3. gilmore
2. mundy
1. m.johnson

 

[milo]

5. Cookie
4. Schammer
3. Bell
2. Mundy
1. Johnson

 

[masai]

5. Cook
4. Farmer
3. Schammmer
2. Johnson (stuck to his guns and was prepared to back himself)
1. Mundy (has he played a bad game?)


Not happy with Webster (injury?), Schofield, Black and Meddie was so so.

Pav was r*ped (ala Modra) but got on with it.

 

[ImperialPurple]

Results Rd 12:
7. Cookie
6. Schammer
5. Farmer
4. Gilmore
3. Mundy
2. Bellie
1. JLo


Leaderboard:

1. Pav (59)
2. Cookie (37)
3. The Wiz (34)
4. McPharlap (23)
5. Blackie (22)
6. JCarr (21)
7. MCarr (20)
=8. JLo & Parker (18)
10. Bellie (15)
=11. Mundy, Hase, DJ & Medders (9)
15. Sandi (8)
16. Schammer (6)
=17. Gilmore, Grover,Siegert & Thornton (4)
=21. Polly & OMDodd (3)
=22. Murphy & Webster (1)