Votes

[omit]

I was down in Melbourne on the weekend and was at the game and I was very disapointed with Brock's efforts. Sure he had 29 touches, but I thought in crucial times he tried to do too much, got tackled and pinged, his disposal was not the best, made several bad decisions and he always seemed to be the last away from a stoppage, even when Sewell was the first away. One moment that sticks out in my mind was on the outer wing when bate took the mark, handed it to brock who had Johnston a 20m short kick away. Brock propt, got into trouble, turned back, noticed bate was under pressure, tried to bust a tackle and lost the ball. When Hawthorn took the ball away, he eventually got up turned to Johnston and barated him for not shepherding. He was the bloke that ____ed up and he blamed a bloke 20m away for his error.

I was really pleased with the effort Melbourne put in and disapointed they ended up losing (even when I thought they wouldn't get close to Hawthorn). I was suprised to read in the Hun that they had Brock in the best and even more suprised that he is getting votes here too! COME ON people getting kicks doesn't necessarily mean you are doing well.

3 Bate
3 Garland
2 Weonamearri
2 Davey
2 Green

his 17 effective kicks and 5 inside 50's beg to differ. there wasn't a single melbourne player there that wasn't without fault...maybe robba and dutch can be excused as they were injured early in the game

 

[MinerBoy]

Not sure if you want opposition votes. If not, please disregard - just offering an opinion. Appears you allocate a total of 12 votes, so here goes:-

4 - M Bate (Always liked the looks of him and thought he was terrific)
3 - B McLean (Great start but faded later. Knows how to be where the ball is).
3 - A Davey (Always dangerous)
1 - B Green (Body on the line marks were great)
1 - A Whatshisname (Can't spell it, but glad I had him in my SC team before the Freo game)

 

[saj_21]

I was down in Melbourne on the weekend and was at the game and I was very disapointed with Brock's efforts. Sure he had 29 touches, but I thought in crucial times he tried to do too much, got tackled and pinged, his disposal was not the best, made several bad decisions and he always seemed to be the last away from a stoppage, even when Sewell was the first away. One moment that sticks out in my mind was on the outer wing when bate took the mark, handed it to brock who had Johnston a 20m short kick away. Brock propt, got into trouble, turned back, noticed bate was under pressure, tried to bust a tackle and lost the ball. When Hawthorn took the ball away, he eventually got up turned to Johnston and barated him for not shepherding. He was the bloke that ____ed up and he blamed a bloke 20m away for his error.

I was really pleased with the effort Melbourne put in and disapointed they ended up losing (even when I thought they wouldn't get close to Hawthorn). I was suprised to read in the Hun that they had Brock in the best and even more suprised that he is getting votes here too! COME ON people getting kicks doesn't necessarily mean you are doing well.

3 Bate
3 Garland
2 Weonamearri
2 Davey
2 Green

Your a snuff!!!

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

Your being over-run with us ferals!

3 - Bate (forgot him completely in Bollox's TotW)
3 - McLean (short on players we didn't tag him in the 1st - showed what he can do)
2 - Wonaemarri (torched us early - no respect)
2 - Green (a rock for you up back - Buddy/Smooth needed to run through him but never got there)
1 - Davey (sparkling early - just too quick for Ladson, Ossy shut him down somewhat)
1 - Garland (though he had plenty of help - reduced Franklin's impact by 50%)

Bruce played? I didn't notice him at all!

 

[Bakes]

Your a snuff!!!

please elaborate.

 

[Bakes]

his 17 effective kicks and 5 inside 50's beg to differ. there wasn't a single melbourne player there that wasn't without fault...maybe robba and dutch can be excused as they were injured early in the game

So would people be voting for him if it was only shown he had 17 touches? What do you think about his attitude in the instance I spoke about?

 

[Lazza1981]

3 Colin Garland stuck to his task all day
2 Mathew Bate
1 Ausiie

 

[RandB]

3 - Green
2 - Mclean
2 - Bate
1 - Buckley
1 - Garland
1 - Davey
1 - Moloney
1 - Wonaeamirri

That's pretty good. Not sure about Buckley though. A few others ahead of him who were more useful.