What 4 Fev?

[astro_toby]

if this talk of fev being linked to richmond is true, what is he worth? pick 8 is on the table, what other desserts would you take to let him go (realistically)

 

[deluxeman]

Nothing, I want him at Carlton and Lance gone.

Theoretically if it came to a stage where we had to trade him, 2 first round draft picks, either one in the top 5 or 2 in the top 10. Keep in mind that Fev > Ottens and Ottens got Picks 12 and 16.

 

[astro_toby]

Nothing, I want him at Carlton and Lance gone.

Theoretically if it came to a stage where we had to trade him, 2 first round draft picks, either one in the top 5 or 2 in the top 10. Keep in mind that Fev > Ottens and Ottens got Picks 12 and 16.

but it has became quite obvious that Geelong got screwed in the ottens deal, and that they paid above reason. also despite ottens being average - (they didnt realise this @ the time) he can play 2-3 positions effectively in FF, CHF or ruck. Fevola is a one spot shot. its FF or bust (DONT U DARE SAY HE CAN PLAY FB TOO!! LOL)

 

[CarltonRulz]

Bulldogs = B.Fevola and Pick 36
Carlton = A.Cooney and J.Rawlings

Thats if we have to trade fev, which we shouldnt

 

[deluxeman]

but it has became quite obvious that Geelong got screwed in the ottens deal, and that they paid above reason. also despite ottens being average - (they didnt realise this @ the time) he can play 2-3 positions effectively in FF, CHF or ruck. Fevola is a one spot shot. its FF or bust (DONT U DARE SAY HE CAN PLAY FB TOO!! LOL)

Ottens never had the potential of being an 100+ goal kicker. Also Fevola could be quite dangerous on the CHf, lets not forget that he has a deadly kick outside 50.

 

[RoK]

Nothing, I want him at Carlton and Lance gone.

Theoretically if it came to a stage where we had to trade him, 2 first round draft picks, either one in the top 5 or 2 in the top 10. Keep in mind that Fev > Ottens and Ottens got Picks 12 and 16.

yeap spot on,he is twice the player Ottens is and far less of a risk.The only risk with fev is his on feild problems.

 

[OZBomb]

Richmond - Pick 8 and Jay Schulz
Western Bulldogs - Pick 11 and Farren Ray
St.Kilda - Pick 17 and Brendan Goddard (Pick 36 to St Kilda)
Hawthorn - Pick 6 and Matthew Ball

 

[Silvagnis]

Hawthorn - Pick 6 and Matthew Ball

Matthew Ball?

Try trading Fev to Richmond for pick 8, Pattison & Schulz with Carlton giving them 20.

 

[astro_toby]

Richmond - Pick 8 and Jay Schulz
Western Bulldogs - Pick 11 and Farren Ray
St.Kilda - Pick 17 and Brendan Goddard (Pick 36 to St Kilda)
Hawthorn - Pick 6 and Matthew Ball

good job there dude, thats the best, most realistic trades for fev ive read

 

[astro_toby]

Matthew Ball?

Try trading Fev to Richmond for pick 8, Pattison & Schulz with Carlton giving them 20.

richmond cant and wouldnt trade patto, is only starting his 2nd year, so cant be traded

 

[Silvagnis]

richmond cant and wouldnt trade patto, is only starting his 2nd year, so cant be traded

I think he can be traded but not delisted.

 

[OZBomb]

I think Ball could be okay and when you're getting pick 6... well it's a bit of a difference from even pick 8 and 11.

We're talking about being in the running for players the calibre of Clarke, Dowler, Birchall, Kennedy and Hurn.

 

[Silvagnis]

Ball is 23 and played 1 game this year for a total of 14, so Denis would want more than a speculative pick and the dud Ball for Fevola.

 

[The Dice Man]

God you gusy seriously over-rate the shag.. Pick 8 and Schulz??? U have to be ********ing kidding me!

Pick 8 and a fringe player or 3-4th round pick at best.

You forgettting the baggage that comes with him? Including both the over-salaried part, and the brain fades... These are the reasons Carlton are shopping him arounbd.

And I highly, highly doubt we will trade for a tall and give up a tall.

You might get lucky and we throw Chaffey or Tivendale into the deal.

If your LUCKY!

 

[gandaal]

Bulldogs = B.Fevola and Pick 36
Carlton = A.Cooney and J.Rawlings

Thats if we have to trade fev, which we shouldnt

Don't be ridiculous. The dogs will never willingly trade Cooney.