What would be our toughest side?

[Top_4_Tiger]

Seen a few Round 1 (or even Round 7 ) threads on who the starting 22 will be, so I thought this might be more interesting.

If we were to field a team that was to play in the toughest AFL match of all-time, who would you pick?


B: Connors Schulz Tuck
HB: JON Mcguane Rance

C: Hislop Coughlan Polo

HF Jackson Reiwoldt White
F Deledio Vickery Foley

R Graham King Thomson

Res: Raines Cotchin Johnson and Richardson (throws his body in)


Ideas?

 

[cormick]

FB: Nicholls Gaspar Newman

HB: King Holland Kellaway

C: Fleming Kellaway Fletcher

HF: Hudson Richo Dragacevic

FF: Knights Stafford Merenda

Foll: Simmonds Rogers Broderick

Inter: Cameron Harrison McGuane Morrison

 

[coke_zero]

what do you mean by toughest? strongest, most aggresive, taking a bumb-tackle-knock.

 

[getthefooty]

Hows this for an all tough 18:

FB Rod Grinter, Neil Kerley, Max Oppy
HB Jim O'Dea, Ted Whitten, Ronnie Andrews
C Marx Kretschmer, Jack Dyer (c), Roger Merritt
HF Robbie Muir, Mal Brown, Wayne Johnston
FF Greg Williams, Cowboy Neale, Neil Balme

FOLL John Nicholls, Leigh Matthews (vc), Michael Voss

 

[cormick]

Not too good, GTF.
Surely Fiora would have to get in there?

 

[JSFish]

Good effort GTF. That must've taken all of 53 minutes.

 

[The Cotch]

Well by toughest, I take that as wanting to inflict pain on the opposition. So maybe we should go out like this Round 1.

FB: Newman Thursfield McGuane

HB: Hislop Rance Moore

C: Cotchin Foley Coughlan

HF: Riewoldt Richardson Jackson

FF: White Schulz Connors

R: Simmonds Deledio Tuck

INT: Raines Polo Thomson Pattison

 

[St Francis]

Hows this for an all tough 18:

FB Rod Grinter, Neil Kerley, Max Oppy
HB Jim O'Dea, Ted Whitten, Ronnie Andrews
C Marx Kretschmer, Jack Dyer (c), Roger Merritt
HF Robbie Muir, Mal Brown, Wayne Johnston
FF Greg Williams, Cowboy Neale, Neil Balme

FOLL John Nicholls, Leigh Matthews (vc), Michael Voss

Shit the bed!!
there's some hard boys in that team, they would win a flag just on intimidation!
I played on Robbie Muir in the MPNFL back in the late 90's, he knocked 2 of our lads out cold before half time, one of them still cant breathe through his nose.. no one on our team was game to man up to him, he was just completely nuts! In the end he started to chase the umpire around the field so his coach dragged him (guttsy move)..
That was one crazy upset n...a!

 

[mitch richmond]

Hows this for an all tough 18:

FB Rod Grinter, Neil Kerley, Max Oppy
HB Jim O'Dea, Ted Whitten, Ronnie Andrews
C Marx Kretschmer, Jack Dyer (c), Roger Merritt
HF Robbie Muir, Mal Brown, Wayne Johnston
FF Greg Williams, Cowboy Neale, Neil Balme

FOLL John Nicholls, Leigh Matthews (vc), Michael Voss

Greg Williams was a sniper (a gun but a sniper) Roger Merrett was a cheap shot with knees/elbows, Mal Brown wasn't tough and neither was Rod Grinter.
Tough players are Michael Voss, Paul Kelly, Duncan Kellaway, Bob Skilton and Francis Bourke

 

[cormick]

Greg Williams was a sniper (a gun but a sniper) Roger Merrett was a cheap shot with knees/elbows, Mal Brown wasn't tough and neither was Rod Grinter.
Tough players are Michael Voss, Paul Kelly, Duncan Kellaway, Bob Skilton and Francis Bourke

Same as Mad Dog.
He's a nut.

 

[jko'neal]

Hows this for an all tough 18:

FB Rod Grinter, Neil Kerley, Max Oppy
HB Jim O'Dea, Ted Whitten, Ronnie Andrews
C Marx Kretschmer, Jack Dyer (c), Roger Merritt
HF Robbie Muir, Mal Brown, Wayne Johnston
FF Greg Williams, Cowboy Neale, Neil Balme

FOLL John Nicholls, Leigh Matthews (vc), Michael Voss

No Plugger Lockett! If I was going to war on a football field Lockett would be second only to Matthews on my team.

 

[CoggaRules]

Scotty Turner & Andy Goodwin are a walk up starts in any toughest team.