one reason. you had most of your core on your list mate.Your premise is somewhat flawed.
Both coaches took over clubs rebuilding. you finished 3rd last in 09 and we finished 5th last. So the fact that we achieved two 9th place finishes in 2010 and 11, punching above our weight should not be held against us.
2012 and 13 we were a middle of the road side, no doubt.
2014 we finished 6th, a couple of wins of 4th place.
2015, all we had to do was field a decent side in round 23 and we would have beaten you, finishing 5th. With you finishing 6th as it turned out.
No doubt both of us need to improve and become more consistent throughout the year or top 4, and a real chance at a flag are just not realistic.
The one thing we have over you is that we do not have a massive monkey on our back come September.
ironically your best year (6th) was when we had our worst and won 9 in a row for finals. its like we are changing places lol