List Mgmt. Who don't you miss?

[Shaq attack]

There is always so much discussion about all the players we have lost over the journey. Sure Docherty, Yeo and Polec would add to our side but who are the player who have left that you don't miss at all?

For me Billy Longer, James Aish and Jack Redden are three players I am happy to see wearing different colours.

 

[scott_the_man]

Redden for sure. He was an established and important player for us who consistently racked up 25 touches and a ton of tackles. Ever since he left his career has done a backflip and he's been stinking it up ever since. Glad he's not performing like that on our list

 

[snooplions]

Redden for sure. He was an established and important player for us who consistently racked up 25 touches and a ton of tackles. Ever since he left his career has done a backflip and he's been stinking it up ever since. Glad he's not performing like that on our list

Redden was stinking it up for a few years before he left as well.

 

[fanackapan]

Jason Roe.

 

[Dom PC]

Sam Sheldon - never rated the guy.

Patrick Karnesis - just seems like a really ordinary bloke all round.

James Aish - disappointed he left at the time. He didn't even give us a chance. Now looks like we dodged a bullet with him being pretty average with Collingwood.

Probably a few others. But they are ones that come straight to mind.

 

[The Bear]

We basically gave Aish away considering the pick swap that went with the deal.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/news/af...e/news-story/0f16d7a2f7f53c226a03d9057956a584

 

[M Malice]

Albert Proud and Llane Spaanderman. Ordinary human beings as well.

 

[Checkered]

We basically gave Aish away considering the pick swap that went with the deal.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/news/af...e/news-story/0f16d7a2f7f53c226a03d9057956a584

Lol no we didn't.

 

[Dalions]

We basically gave Aish away considering the pick swap that went with the deal.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/news/af...e/news-story/0f16d7a2f7f53c226a03d9057956a584

I think we did ok.

 

[Cockliff38]

We basically gave Aish away considering the pick swap that went with the deal.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/news/af...e/news-story/0f16d7a2f7f53c226a03d9057956a584

Mathieson, Keays (and Bastinac) are pretty good nothings.

Note - the 2016 third round pick was part of the trade to land McCluggage and Berry too, albeit not the centerpiece

 

[The Bear]

Mathieson, Keays (and Bastinac) are pretty good nothings.

What did we get for our pick 17 then?

 

[dlanod]

What did we get for our pick 17 then?

If you convert all the picks to "draft value" given that's what we used them for, it works out to Aish for Bastinac and pick 27.

If you look at just the Aish trade, Collingwood's ins and outs give an approximate value on what we actually got for Aish:

IN: James Aish and picks 34, 53
OUT: Picks 26, 28, 47 and 2016 second-round selection (St Kilda’s - pick 33)

I've cancelled out the roughly equal items.

17, 26 and 28 effectively got us 33 (2016), 38, 40, 50 (2016) and Bastinac. Funnily enough, using draft value again it works out that we effectively gave up pick 27 for Bastinac (which I'd argue was an overpayment).

 

[Fatcat08]

What did we get for our pick 17 then?

Lets not start this whole argument again. If you'd like to know the answer you can look through the many many posts on this subject that have continually round and round in circles.

Maybe start with a search for the term "pick 17" on this board and go from there. Enjoy

 

[Elixuh]

Albert Proud and Llane Spaanderman. Ordinary human beings as well.

Spaanderman would have to go down as one of our biggest recruiting blunders.

 

[The Bear]

If you convert all the picks to "draft value" given that's what we used them for, it works out to Aish for Bastinac and pick 27.

If you look at just the Aish trade, Collingwood's ins and outs give an approximate value on what we actually got for Aish:

IN: James Aish and picks 34, 53
OUT: Picks 26, 28, 47 and 2016 second-round selection (St Kilda’s - pick 33)

I've cancelled out the roughly equal items.

17, 26 and 28 effectively got us 33 (2016), 38, 40, 50 (2016) and Bastinac. Funnily enough, using draft value again it works out that we effectively gave up pick 27 for Bastinac (which I'd argue was an overpayment).

Nice work. Pretty even then. I stand corrected.

 

[Back2Back2Back]

Aish for sure. Played pretty average for us, and has done hardly anything he was supposed to aspire to since going to Collingwood. Crisp is a bigger loss than he was.

 

[Soren Lorenson]

Aish for sure. Played pretty average for us, and has done hardly anything he was supposed to aspire to since going to Collingwood. Crisp is a bigger loss than he was.

The James Aish thread on the Collingwood board is good for a chuckle or two if you have some time to waste.

 

[CarloLion]

If we're talking Eagles then before Jack Redden there was Bradd Dalziell!

 

[3KZ is Football]

Sam Sheldon - never rated the guy.

For some strange reason Vossie rated him. That and the Fevola signing are Exhibit A and Exhibit B in the case against Voss as a coach. Then there was the way he treated Daniel Bradshaw, Luke Power and James Hawksley. Come to think of it, I don't miss Coach Vossie.

 

[Back2Back2Back]

The James Aish thread on the Collingwood board is good for a chuckle or two if you have some time to waste.

That is quite the giggle

 

[pulpdriver]

Billy Longer. If he hadn't requested a trade it's likely we would have put games into him instead of Stef when Leuie went down which means it's possible we'd never experience Stef's elite form and we instead would have wasted time investing games into someone who isn't that good. Easy in hindsight but never should have used pick 8 on him, particularly when we got him due to seeing potential to have an impact up forward, strength of character and leadership all of which he's ended up showing none.

 

[Skoob]

Jayden Post.

 

[Dalions]

Jared Polec.
I know he has turned into a decent footballer. But it was obvious to me that he never wanted to be here and he just seemed like a snotty nose rich kid.

 

[kylegee28]

Sherminator. Racist prick.

 

[Milk Steak]

Cheynee Stiller. I'm sure I'll cop it,but he used to frustrate the shit out of me. Bit of a soft,nothing player that would kick little dinky balloon passes on top of guys heads. Mitch Golby was the other one I couldn't cop. Had an encouraging first year before getting injured,then just became very below average. Had no discernible skills that I could think of.