Who would currently be winning the Brownlow?

[wizardcupfinalblues]

Taking into account Kerr's suspension who would currently be winning the Brownlow. I would say Judd or Chad Cornes. What are your thoughts??

 

[B-Rock]

Judd, Chris.

 

[Burzum]

Judd, Cornes, Bartel.

 

[Bomber32]

Chad Cornes.

 

[wizardcupfinalblues]

And a new thing, who is your roughie, mine would be Tarkyn Lockyer

 

[Mancey]

Cornes and Bartel historically do not poll well. Both have been good this year but i just can't see them winning it.

Judd is the obvious favourite. Scott West will be there abouts once again. Simon Black has been fantastic. Sorry to be boring, but it'll be one of the usual suspects IMO.

Smokey? I'll go with Cross

 

[Souup]

Jimmy Bartel

Smokey - Brent Harvey

 

[jerry springer]

And a new thing, who is your roughie, mine would be Tarkyn Lockyer

ssshhh keep it on the low he is still paying $101

 

[tin can sam]

Cornes and Bartel historically do not poll well. Both have been good this year but i just can't see them winning it.

Judd is the obvious favourite. Scott West will be there abouts once again. Simon Black has been fantastic. Sorry to be boring, but it'll be one of the usual suspects IMO.

Smokey? I'll go with Cross

Bartel polled 13 votes in 10 rounds in 2004.

Cornes cam 2nd the same year I believe.

 

[lookkg386]

Judd
Black
Cornes

same old....

 

[Quinz]

Judd will be leading.

 

[David_Brent]

Kerr and Judd will be leading.

Cornes doenst poll well. Will be interesting to see how he goes.

 

[Mancey]

Bartel polled 13 votes in 10 rounds in 2004.

Cornes cam 2nd the same year I believe.

I must admit i only took into account the last 2 years as i thought they would hold the most relevance.

2005 Bartel 9 votes, Cornes 0 votes
2006 Bartel 2 votes, Cornes 4 votes

Bartel especially has been fantastic this year, problem is he's just one of those guys that quietly goes about his work without being noticed.

Goodwin has the same problem

 

[CoastBhoy]

Judd
G.Ablett
Lucas
Bartel
C.Cornes

 

[Alphanumeric]

Judd will be in front I would think.

 

[dtrainium]

Judd and Black.

Best smokey would be Wojcinski.

 

[Upgrayedd]

FRANKLIN
but seriously, kerr would be leading, throw in bartel/cornes/judd at second

 

[Bernie L]

er..... McLeod!

 

[Mancey]

Good point

 

[Inferno]

Judd or Bartel.

Smokey - Tarkyn Lockyer

 

[walkers a legend]

i would be putting my money on s.black

 

[mudgeathon]

Chris Judd

This year he has been amazing and it would not suprise me if he had polled in 6 of the 9 games

2 votes against Sydney [27 possies - 2 goals]
2 votes against Collingwood [29 possies - 2 goals]
1 or 2 votes against Freo [25 possies - 1 goal]
3 votes against Carlton [35 possies]
2/3 votes against the doggies [34 possies - 2 goals - 6 tackles]
2/3 votes against Melbourne [31 possies - 3 goals]

 

[Tizza]

Judd easily..he polls votes even when we lose sometimes.....

Judd will win it by a street this year

 

[wizardcupfinalblues]

Judd easily..he polls votes even when we lose sometimes.....

Judd will win it by a street this year

Probably, i think Peter Burgoyne is having a good year as well

 

[harmesy 37]

Lance Whitnall or Wiggins.