Who Would u rather?

[Roughies Boys]

Joel Selwood or Jack Riewoldt?

 

[Murraj1966]

Midfielders are so common these days, a good Key Forward is worth it's weight in gold.

 

[Dylz48]

the option where you stop posting crap threads on the main board

 

[holybishop]

Midfielders are so common these days, a good Key Forward is worth it's weight in gold.

^This. Joel is good but he's no where near unique.

 

[Andrew Mc]

the option where you stop posting crap threads on the main board

Seconded - there's a Polls board for this crap.

 

[beez]

I'm on the Mitch Thorp bandwagon too.

 

[Silvagnis]

^This. Joel is good but he's no where near unique.

Is Jack Riewoldt unique?

There's only one Franklin.

 

[Rob]

It's actually a damn good question (except for that Mitch Thorp bullshit).

I don't really know. Probably Selwood, but here is a bit of risk there that he's a bit like Daniel Kerr - great when others are taking all the attention but throw him into a side as the top mid and he's going to struggle.

With Reiwoldt you can't say that he's been riding the coat tails of a good side.

 

[Simmonds2Hislop]

Going forward i'd take Jack just because our forwardline would look shithouse without him.

Selwood's been better so far though.

 

[CrimsonRaven]

Seconded - there's a Polls board for this crap.

Thirded

 

[Peck]

To be perfectly honest I wouldn't want Joel Selwood full stop.

 

[WCE_phil]

Riewoldt. Proven he can be a star in a shithouse team. Selwood has only proven he can be a top 10 player in an exceptional team. There will be a question mark for as long as he's playing in a dominant team and has great support and backup.

 

[Johnny619]

Selwood for Essendon.

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Is Jack Riewoldt unique?

There's only one Franklin.

lol, what's this got to do with anything??

There is only one Mitch Thorp too.

 

[Hopping Mad]

I'd take Riewoldt at North any day. We've already got a few inside mids, and we're in desperate need for a good key forward. Riewoldt at FF with Petrie at HF would be insane.

 

[dthack]

riewoldt. Proven he can be a star in a shithouse team. Selwood has only proven he can be a top 10 player in an exceptional team. There will be a question mark for as long as he's playing in a dominant team and has great support and backup.

+ 1

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

I'd take Riewoldt at North any day. We've already got a few inside mids, and we're in desperate need for a good key forward. Riewoldt at FF with Petrie at HF would be insane.

That Hansen bloke is turning into a very nice player

 

[Silvagnis]

lol, what's this got to do with anything??

There is only one Mitch Thorp too.

Riewoldt isn't a unique talent like a Franklin.

There are plenty of young marking forwards around.

Tippett was the flavour of the month and the next deadset superstar after he kicked 55 goals in 2009.

Selwood is a better footballer than Riewoldt.

Period.

Anyone who picks Riewoldt is fickle.

Footy fans are more reactionary than the AFL.

The irony of Richmond fans querying the selection of a superstar midfielder over a KPF.

 

[ballanFYNE]

Riewoldt. Gun forwards > Gun Midfielders. @ a young age.

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Riewoldt isn't a unique talent like a Franklin.

There are plenty of young marking forwards around.

Tippett was the flavour of the month and the next deadset superstar after he kicked 55 goals in 2009.

Selwood is a better footballer than Riewoldt.

Period.

Anyone who picks Riewoldt is fickle.

Footy fans are more reactionary than the AFL.

The irony of Richmond fans querying the selection of a superstar midfielder over a KPF.

Just like all of Carlton's awesome marking forwards?

Did I or any Richmond supporter say anything about Buddy or Riewoldt?

The poster asking the question is a Hawthorn supporter.

FYI - I rate Buddy very highly, but I'm very happy with Riewoldt.

 

[tugga]

Riewoldt isn't a unique talent like a Franklin.

There are plenty of young marking forwards around.

Tippett was the flavour of the month and the next deadset superstar after he kicked 55 goals in 2009.

Selwood is a better footballer than Riewoldt.

Period.

Anyone who picks Riewoldt is fickle.

Footy fans are more reactionary than the AFL.

The irony of Richmond fans querying the selection of a superstar midfielder over a KPF.

Gee it's strange how you'r pretty much on your own with this one isn't it?
I'd go Thorp personally.

 

[Greggy]

I'm starting to think Carlton supporters don't have the same love for my club as me.

Riewoldt, he's bloody entertaining and only getting better as a player.

 

[coke_zero]

Riewoldt isn't a unique talent like a Franklin.

There are plenty of young marking forwards around.

Tippett was the flavour of the month and the next deadset superstar after he kicked 55 goals in 2009.

Selwood is a better footballer than Riewoldt.

Period.

Anyone who picks Riewoldt is fickle.

Footy fans are more reactionary than the AFL.

The irony of Richmond fans querying the selection of a superstar midfielder over a KPF.

haha you think this will be jacks only ever good year? Jack will be top 5 coleman for the next 7-8 years.

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

haha you think this will be jacks only ever good year? Jack will be top 5 coleman for the next 7-8 years.

Let's not count our eggs before they've hatched coke_zero, but he does look like an awesome 10+ year player, doesn't he?

 

[zomg!wtf]

haha you think this will be jacks only ever good year? Jack will be top 5 coleman for the next 7-8 years.

sigh.

might as well pencil it in hey?