Who's our no.1 midfielder?

[rgauci]

It's between Hasleby, Bell and J.Carr. But i can't decide. Thoughts?

I think M.Carr is clearly no. 4 though we haven't seen a fit and firing Schammer this season. Heath Black is pretty good too. Headland seems to have fallen from grace. Though most of our players seem to bounce back from a run in the WAFL.

Heath Black and M.Carr (before injury) have performed well all season. Headland and Schammer have been the disappointments. Hopefully they fire up after being dropped to the WAFL. If all 7 of those midfielders are firing we are pretty unstoppable. We haven't seen it once this year. I'm looking forward to a strong finish this year.

 

[PAFC2004]

Josh Carr.

 

[Undertaker]

I believe it is between Hasleby & J Carr, both on a par when it comes to center clearances, J. Carr has a better disposal than Hasleby, but Hasleby is better overhead. I agree with rgauci when we get them all on the field together and inform they will be a very formidable combination.
Very good balance of the following midfielders
Receivers / Attacking = Headland, Black & Schofield.
Defensive / Tagging = Walker, M. Carr, Cook & Dodd.
In and Under = Hasleby, J. Carr, Bell, Schammer.

 

[Reveler]

Bell.. This season so far J.Carr

 

[dugrene]

I believe it is between Hasleby & J Carr, both on a par when it comes to center clearances, J. Carr has a better disposal than Hasleby, but Hasleby is better overhead. I agree with rgauci when we get them all on the field together and inform they will be a very formidable combination.
Very good balance of the following midfielders
Receivers / Attacking = Headland, Black & Schofield.
Defensive / Tagging = Walker, M. Carr, Cook & Dodd.
In and Under = Hasleby, J. Carr, Bell, Schammer.

i'd swap cook and Bell in your post. Otherwise Ok.

 

[coasting]

Easily Hasleby, he just isn't playing like it at the moment. I suspect he is carrying an injury.

 

[pav_is_god]

Black and J. Carr have been the outstanding midfielders so far this season.

 

[pinkus maximus]

Easily Hasleby, he just isn't playing like it at the moment. I suspect he is carrying an injury.

no doubt about it

on both points

 

[big buddy38]

I reckon Hasleby is the most damaging with his creative use of the ball - generally, when he's going well so are Fremantle. I rate Schammer - had an interrupted year but he's going to be very good.

 

[Farrand]

Schofield.

 

[wehavethepassion]

Black and J. Carr have been the outstanding midfielders so far this season.

Josh was very good early but has faded some what whereas Blacky has been very consistent. Big Carr also has been consistent.

Watch Belly in the run home starting to get fully fit missed the real preseason.

 

[dugrene]

Watch Belly in the run home starting to get fully fit missed the real preseason.

CC said on 9 tonight Belly missed the pre season.

100 times dugrene...

I must pay more attention
I must pay more attention
I must pay more attention
I must pay more attention
I must pay more attention
I must pay more attention

 

[Ripper]

Fortunately it is not as clear cut as it used to be.

In form Hase would still be the most damaging .

 

[PAFC2004]

Schofield.

Having seen a lot more of both Schoe and Carr, I would have to say carr. They are different types of midfielders though. Schoe receives the ball from the in and under midfielders.

 

[wehavethepassion]

From a PP suporter can Schofield kick the ball more than 20m? or does he just chip the ball around?