Worst afl player you've seen (and why)

[Stan_Darsh72]

Nathan J Brown, has been exceptionally poor for the Saints so far this season.

He has actually been pretty good for us so far.

Josh Bruce

Serious?

 

[Baird]

How many 21 year old ruckmen have you seen dominate? You are biased by his contract.

Go to the who is over paid thread. Then you might have a point.

He's a spud mate. Slow and clueless. And the only reason he's playing in the ruck is because he's a useless forward.

 

[hoianbulldog]

He's a spud mate. Slow and clueless. And the only reason he's playing in the ruck is because he's a useless forward.

Wow......me and bevo thought it was for team balance.

Calling him a spud because he isnt playing the position you think he should be playing shows how little you know about the game.

Forget the price tag and look at where he has been playing.

He is a.kid.....a big kid and they take time. Always has been and always will be.

 

[flylikeaneagle]

Serious?

he sucks, big time

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

he sucks, big time

 

[ioppolo]

People taking stabs at young key forwards with no mention of Paddy McCartin?

 

[Brad Goodman]

Mark Orchard and James Wasley weren't very good from what I can remember.

 

[Sydneyfan]

David Clarke Jnr and Ricky Mott (Carlton)

Shit isn't a crude enough adjective to describe how rubbish those two camels were.

Yeah, poor old Ricky Mott sure was a lemon. I remember back around 2002 at ANZ when he was with the Swans he missed a 30 metre shot right in front on/just before the siren which lost the match for the Swans.

Walking out of the stadium after the match I look behind to see him along with a couple of other players including Luff walking in the same general direction with a group of Swans supporters giving it to their own player, Mott, admirably Luffy was sticking up for his teammate but in his heart of hearts must have realised he was fighting a losing cause.

Luffy himself had his fair share of detractors over the past years but carved out a handy career in the end.

 

[marty36]

Aaron Keating and won a GF medal, its almost criminal, he owns this thread

 

[Son_of_Gero]

He's a spud mate. Slow and clueless. And the only reason he's playing in the ruck is because he's a useless forward.

He's 21.
Do you expect Darcy Moore to be a gun by seasons end?

 

[gangsta deluxe]

Tom Boyd, apart from the 2016 Grand Final he has been absolutely useless.

In the bests vs. Richmond and without him we wouldnt have won the game (of course, he was playing in the ruck against a first gamer in Soldo, but still)

 

[SterlingArcher]

In the bests vs. Richmond and without him we wouldnt have won the game (of course, he was playing in the ruck against a first gamer in Soldo, but still)

But Soldo had a big influence in the first quarter when Bevo was going without a ruck. Of course Boyd should beat him but it still counts considering Soldos influence early.

 

[Russian Demon]

he sucks, big time

You sure you're not confused with Mav Weller?

 

[ApplecrossWC]

Tom Boyd

 

[gollygeewiz]

Trent Knobel, 75 games and averaged 5.8 disposals per game.

 

[drazah]

Currently playing, you'd have to say David Mackay and Curtley Hampton are two of the worst players going around. Very stark contrast between them and a star like Sloane.

 

[god_of_the_universe]

Trent Knobel, 75 games and averaged 5.8 disposals per game.

At least he wasn't sacked mid-season like another former saints ruckman Matthew Capuano

 

[stevie26]

Sorry if this guy has already been mentioned but this thread definitely needs

 

[Kram]

 

[Whatname]

Israel Folau.

Just look up his stats.

 

[Simon_Says]

Another one to be added to Cale's highlight reel

I wonder what Neeld says to him? "Chin up. Better luck next time"?

Anyone deciphered what Neeld was saying? Someone Lip read that surely?

 

[JoondalupJ]

I'll keep my vote to current players who have played at least one game this season.

Tom Boyd, apart from the 2016 Grand Final he has been absolutely useless.

Jake Batchelor, no explanation needed.

Nathan J Brown, has been exceptionally poor for the Saints so far this season.

Taylor Hunt, defies logic that he's on an AFL list.

Ty Vickery, Ty Vickery.

I've supported Ty this year but really he hasn't shown up, and Clarko looks like he may make him wait even longer, who knows.
But he has got the skills it just seems he has no application, I don't know enough about him to really comment on that, but if he could get consistent form, he would be a huge lift for us!

 

[The Joker]

Still "developing" just ask every freo supporter. He has my vote.

A 'please like my post' post if ever ive seen one. FYI champ, only his mother likes it when Nic gets a game!

 

[a_fighting_fury]

I'd hope that everyone who has posted a name excels in their chosen field...

Let's make it an even playing field and add a quarter million dollar salary to that chosen field, huh?

And I think you'll find that these AFL footballers are in a league of their own .


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Testekill]

Jamaes Mulligan or Mark Austin from Bulldogs

Thank you. Austin was only ever a battler who wasn't athletic enough to make up a lack of skill. Mulligan however is the worst I've ever seen and somehow was on our list from 2008 to his retirement in 2012. Purest case of being an athlete instead of a footballer and the old 'built like Tarzan, plays like Jane' thing.