Worst Captain

[Hodgepodge]

It takes a lot to overtake Maxwell as the worst captain.

Judd has finally done it - overseeing two drunken incidents this summer that have seen Fev traded and a shipload of Carlton players drunk and disorderly. 3 of those will be slapped with a wet lettuce leaf, one ended up in lock up, two banned from the Crown.

 

[The Night Shift]

How the **** is Chris Newman not winning this?

Because Judd is much worse gopower... and thats taking in Newman's rating... damning, isn't it.

It takes a lot to overtake Maxwell as the worst captain.

Judd has finally done it - overseeing two drunken incidents this summer that have seen Fev traded and a shipload of Carlton players drunk and disorderly. 3 of those will be slapped with a wet lettuce leaf, one ended up in lock up, two banned from the Crown.

This is true.......

 

[Lawnchair]

Did people even read the thread? I mean, sure Judd is a shit captain, but he should still be getting games at AFL level.

Maxwell gets my vote. Absolute dud.

 

[Military_man]

You kinda knew that Judd would poll the most votes. Its like starting a poll on who is the most hated club in the afl. Carlton are going to get that award too. Why dont the OP'S for all these type of threads just start threads that are constructive instead of trying to gain points against Carlton. Everyone hates carlton its a old point. We at Carton know we aint liked.Try something new for a change. Get over it

 

[Northworth]

You kinda knew that Judd would poll the most votes. Its like starting a poll on who is the most hated club in the afl. Carlton are going to get that award too. Why dont the OP'S for all these type of threads just start threads that are constructive instead of trying to gain points against Carlton. Everyone hates carlton its a old point. We at Carton know we aint liked.Try something new for a change. Get over it

this wasn't a troll poll

to be honest - I honestly thought McDonald and Newman would dominate but wanted to see what others thought

that Judd is the worst captain seems to be the will of the bay

I dont see too many attempts by blues fans to defend his captaincy

 

[Lawnchair]

this wasn't a troll poll

to be honest - I honestly thought McDonald and Newman would dominate but wanted to see what others thought

that Judd is the worst captain seems to be the will of the bay

I dont see too many attempts by blues fans to defend his captaincy

I've never pretended he is a good captain, I just believe there are far worse out there

 

[Kipz]

I've never pretended he is a good captain, I just believe there are far worse out there

There very well could be... But not in the AFL.

 

[Bosk]

Nice one Lunchlady Doris being the only person foolish enough to select Jonathan Brown.

Really showing your true colours there mate.