Would This Get Us Judd....

[Macedonian Magpie]

Just throwing it out there for discussion....Chris Egan, Nathan Brown and our 1st Round pick.

Egan still have some value and an up-side and can add some skills in the Eagles forward line as well as working his way into the middle. Nathan Brown can play with his brother and slot in at CHB and we can work on having John Anthony as a key defender.

Nathan Brown - 194cm
John Anthony - 192cm

Judd, Pendelbury, Thomas and Didak in the midfield....let's only hope.

 

[OneEyedPie7]

I would be prepared to give them our first rounder plus egan and rusling. I would not be prepared to trade Nath Brown at this stage. Look at the age of our key defenders he is going to be extremely important in a few years.

 

[smiddaz123]

Just throwing it out there for discussion....Chris Egan, Nathan Brown and our 1st Round pick.

Egan still have some value and an up-side and can add some skills in the Eagles forward line as well as working his way into the middle. Nathan Brown can play with his brother and slot in at CHB and we can work on having John Anthony as a key defender.

Nathan Brown - 194cm
John Anthony - 192cm

Judd, Pendelbury, Thomas and Didak in the midfield....let's only hope.

Brown has more talent than Anthony. I'm pretty confident of that.

I really don't want to trade Reid or Brown.

 

[spEKTre]

Just throwing it out there for discussion....Chris Egan, Nathan Brown and our 1st Round pick.

Egan still have some value and an up-side and can add some skills in the Eagles forward line as well as working his way into the middle. Nathan Brown can play with his brother and slot in at CHB and we can work on having John Anthony as a key defender.

Nathan Brown - 194cm
John Anthony - 192cm

Judd, Pendelbury, Thomas and Didak in the midfield....let's only hope.

Those 2 won how many Brownlows ? Jeez I wish people would start to realise that Judd isn't going to go for a packet of Potato Chips ffs.

 

[smiddaz123]

Those 2 won how many Brownlows ? Jeez I wish people would start to realise that Judd isn't going to go for a packet of Potato Chips ffs.

The thing is beggers can't be choosers. Judd WILL be going. West Coast don't have much power to bargain with that fact.

I'm pretty sure the deal you end up with wont be very fair.

 

[Brahma Bull]

Just throwing it out there for discussion....Chris Egan, Nathan Brown and our 1st Round pick.

Egan still have some value and an up-side and can add some skills in the Eagles forward line as well as working his way into the middle. Nathan Brown can play with his brother and slot in at CHB and we can work on having John Anthony as a key defender.

Nathan Brown - 194cm
John Anthony - 192cm

Judd, Pendelbury, Thomas and Didak in the midfield....let's only hope.

I doubt that trade will happen, we would need to give 2 first round picks and more for Judd.

Is Egan from WA?

 

[shawthing09]

IMO Egan holds 0 trade value and hence that deal would not be good enough unless Judd picked us and would not budge and the WCE where desperate to get something rather then PSD

 

[Barwick17]

Why do people try and add our duds to trades to "bump up' the value? West Coast want to recover from losing judd, why would they accept Egan on list? I think they also want to clear our their duds as well so they would only add quality players eg didak, rusling. Lets stop mentioning Lonie, Egan, Davies. Thay are worth nothing in a trade! One pick and player only.

By the way, Judd says he will nominate his club. If he says Collingwood, then we just have to come to terms with WCE. They can either accept or lose him for nothing in PSD. So as long as our deal doesnt include, lonie, egan, Licuria, holland etc and pick 56, they will have to accept it.

Please get some perspective people

 

[eliasd82]

Just throwing it out there for discussion....Chris Egan, Nathan Brown and our 1st Round pick.

Egan still have some value and an up-side and can add some skills in the Eagles forward line as well as working his way into the middle. Nathan Brown can play with his brother and slot in at CHB and we can work on having John Anthony as a key defender.

Nathan Brown - 194cm
John Anthony - 192cm

Judd, Pendelbury, Thomas and Didak in the midfield....let's only hope.

Dont think so... if collingwood have any chance they need to deal with another club to get a higher pick to pass it onto the coast...


i know you guys love didak but something like...

pick 3 to pies

didak to collingwood

pick 3 and 15 to WC for judd

something like this... unless you wanna give em travis cloke, wc would love that...

 

[Barwick17]

Dont think so... if collingwood have any chance they need to deal with another club to get a higher pick to pass it onto the coast...


i know you guys love didak but something like...

pick 3 to pies

didak to collingwood

pick 3 and 15 to WC for judd

something like this... unless you wanna give em travis cloke, wc would love that...

Isn't he at collingwood?? And to trade for pick 3 means didak to carlton? Dream on clown.
Oh, and pick 15 means we lose the grand final. At least we'd beat Geelong on saturday!

 

[Blueboy43]

Just throwing it out there for discussion....Chris Egan, Nathan Brown and our 1st Round pick.

Egan still have some value and an up-side and can add some skills in the Eagles forward line as well as working his way into the middle. Nathan Brown can play with his brother and slot in at CHB and we can work on having John Anthony as a key defender.

Nathan Brown - 194cm
John Anthony - 192c

No Chance.

Chris Egan - No Good
Nathan Brown - Yet to play a game.

You will need to give 2 quality players as you dont have any low picks. IMO as good as Judd is, Collingwood should not and will not give up 2 young guns. Your list is good enough

 

[Blueboy43]

i know you guys love didak but something like...

pick 3 to pies

didak to collingwood

pick 3 and 15 to WC for judd

something like this... unless you wanna give em travis cloke, wc would love that...

Explain how and why Carlton will give pick 3 to Collingwood so they can obtain Judd

 

[eddies army]

Those 2 won how many Brownlows ? Jeez I wish people would start to realise that Judd isn't going to go for a packet of Potato Chips ffs.

Egan was a pick ten only two years ago, brown ten in the super draft and our first round pick this season, all vic clubs have stated theyd love to have judd in their side, but are not willing to stuff up team balance so havin said all this you need to ask yourself, how much do you think your really gonna get????

 

[Murray]

Dont think so... if collingwood have any chance they need to deal with another club to get a higher pick to pass it onto the coast...


i know you guys love didak but something like...

pick 3 to pies

didak to collingwood

pick 3 and 15 to WC for judd

something like this... unless you wanna give em travis cloke, wc would love that...

Wow, I wouldn't mind picking up that Didak dude, I hear he is pretty good

 

[Invigoration]

Explain how and why Carlton will give pick 3 to Collingwood so they can obtain Judd

He did actually read he's post didn't you? Re-read it and try putting emphasis where he says 'a trade LIKE rah rah rah'.

Not every scenario needs a full blown explanation as to the ins and outs of the trade, it is simply a scenario.
It is a discussion board you realise?

 

[Invigoration]

Wow, I wouldn't mind picking up that Didak dude, I hear he is pretty good

Supposedly has off-field issues, not worth it...

 

[JBMKII]

Those 2 won how many Brownlows ? Jeez I wish people would start to realise that Judd isn't going to go for a packet of Potato Chips ffs.

you will be lucky to get a top 10 pick and a player, Judd has stated he will not set his new club back 2-3 years. He owes you nothing. And he does not play for west coast anymore, he is "out of contract".

 

[astro_toby]

i can't believe you guys would get rid of didak - the bloke was a star last week and you guys are trying to flog him off for someone else

your everyones best friend until somebody better comes along

good luck on friday fella's - hopefully the players haven't gotten too offended that you are trying to sell them all off to get hold of another player - despite the fact they have gotten you to a prelim final

 

[Darkdayz]

look why does everyone assume judd is the be all end all.

NOW listen here
didak will not be traded unless he ask to leave, otherwise we pay his contract out with next years salary cap.

whoever started this thread you've just given away potentially 2 200game + highly rated young defenders. for one man. get it in your heads please a kpp will always be more valuable then a flashy midfielder, there always like 5 of them in every draft.

why does every1 amplify judds value? hes 1 man in a team. woosha has sucked every1 into thinking lets go sky high, when he said pick 3 fev not good enough. you'll be lucky to even get that, carlton are crazy but not that bloody crazy.

if and when hes specifies he wants to come to us and us alone then we can strangle the toaster, which i cant see happening. look toaster get use to it your not gonna come out of this happy. pies will offer rusling 1st pick maybe second pick. get us to it your only going to get something of that mold. you can mark my words that about all your going to get, your not dealing with freo here, and your man wants to leave. if it proves i am wrong in 4 weeks time i will retract this statement and appologize. but i cant see you getting anything close to what you all seem to expect.

 

[JBMKII]

i can't believe you guys would get rid of didak - the bloke was a star last week and you guys are trying to flog him off for someone else

your everyones best friend until somebody better comes along

good luck on friday fella's - hopefully the players haven't gotten too offended that you are trying to sell them all off to get hold of another player - despite the fact they have gotten you to a prelim final

Mate we would never trade didak, ever unless he wants to leave, only the moron piemen are offering didak, the club wont be

 

[Blueboy43]

He did actually read he's post didn't you? Re-read it and try putting emphasis where he says 'a trade LIKE rah rah rah'.

Not every scenario needs a full blown explanation as to the ins and outs of the trade, it is simply a scenario.
It is a discussion board you realise?

I understand that what we are talking about is all here say. But there was no mention of what Carlton will receive for giving up pick 3. That was my point.

 

[1eye]

Wow, I wouldn't mind picking up that Didak dude, I hear he is pretty good

Yeah and for pick 3- feels like DejaVu

 

[Invigoration]

I understand that what we are talking about is all here say. But there was no mention of what Carlton will receive for giving up pick 3. That was my point.

Point well made

 

[Murray]

Supposedly has off-field issues, not worth it...

I think I recall hearing something about that.
It was all kept pretty quiet though

 

[eddies army]

i can't believe you guys would get rid of didak - the bloke was a star last week and you guys are trying to flog him off for someone else

your everyones best friend until somebody better comes along

good luck on friday fella's - hopefully the players haven't gotten too offended that you are trying to sell them all off to get hold of another player - despite the fact they have gotten you to a prelim final

didak aint goin no where!!! all aust last year, didnt have a pre season and was stuffed for most of the year, came out like a gun had off field drama and was flat, the weekend proved he has got it and could be runnin into red hot form. It would be completely stupid to even think of a trade unless he wanted out...doubt it!!!