Tippet above Gibbs, Riewoldt and others? Tippet is ridiculously overrated. No way the 7th best player in the draft.
1. Joel Selwood - I hate this campaigner but no doubt one of the best players in the league.
2. Travis Boak - Respect this campaigner and again an easy lock for 2nd.
3. Josh Kennedy - Shown more in his career to slightly edge out Gray.
4. Robbie Gray - Shot up the ranks through one season. I'd back him in to repeat it in 2015.
5. Eric Mackenzie - Has played defence in both good and bad WCE teams and has performed to an elite standard in both. Has performed A Grade longer than Gibbs to just edge him out.
6. Bryce Gibbs - Has always been a consistent player in a s**t and mediocre team. Has only just turned 25 (bottom ager) and is hitting his straps.
7. Tom Hawkins - Don't rate the fat s**t as much as others. Has played both main and 2nd forward in arguably the best AFL team in the modern era. Wouldn't have the hardest job in football.
8. Jack Riewoldt - Whinging gay campaigner but quality forward.
9. Todd Goldstein - One of the games premium rucks. But you wouldn't take him ahead of any of the previous 8.
10. James Frawley - Would walk away with a quality FB at pick 10 anyday. Should look 10 fold better at Hawthorn next year then the AFL graveyard Melshit.
Not including the F/S selections the top 10 would be as follows...
1. Carlton - Joel Selwood
2. Essendon* - Travis Boak
3. Kangaroos - Robbie Gray
4. Brisbane Lions - Eric Mackenzie
5. Port Adelaide - Bryce Gibbs
6. Hawthorn - Jack Riewoldt
7. Geelong - Todd Goldstein
8. Collingwood - James Frawley
9. St Kilda - Kurt Tippett
10. Collingwood - Justin Westoff
No way Boak is above JPK.