Grade your team's draft 2023

Remove this Banner Ad

Just for those who want to revisit in 5 years time: Review - Winners and losers of the draft (2018 edition)

And for reference this was the draft..

1. Sam Walsh (Geelong Falcons) – Carlton
2. Jack Lukosius (Woodville-West Torrens) – Gold Coast
3. Izak Rankine (West Adelaide) – Gold Coast
4. Max King (Sandringham Dragons) – St Kilda
5. Conor Rozee (North Adelaide) – Port Adelaide
6. Ben King (Sandringham Dragons) – Gold Coast
7. Bailey Smith (Sandringham Dragons) – Western Bulldogs
8. Tarryn Thomas (North Launceston) – North Melbourne (next generation)
9. Chayce Jones (Launceston) – Adelaide
10. Nick Blakey (UNSW-ES) – Sydney (academy)
11. Jye Caldwell (Bendigo Pioneers) – GWS
12. Zak Butters (Western Jets) – Port Adelaide
13. Isaac Quaynor (Oakleigh Chargers) – Collingwood (next generation)
14. Jackson Hately (Central District) – GWS
15. Jordan Clark (Claremont) – Geelong
16. Ned McHenry (Geelong Falcons) – Adelaide
17. Sam Sturt (Dandenong Stingrays) – Fremantle
18. Xavier Duursma (Gippsland Power) – Port Adelaide
19. Liam Stocker (Sandringham Dragons) – Carlton
20. Riley Collier-Dawkins (Oakleigh Chargers) – Richmond
21. Ely Smith (Murray Bushrangers) – Brisbane Lions
22. Xavier O’Halloran (Western Jets) – GWS
23. Jez McLennan (Central District) – Gold Coast
24. Ian Hill (Perth) – GWS
25. James Rowbottom (Oakleigh Chargers) – Sydney
26. Rhylee West (Calder Cannons) – Western Bulldogs (father-son)
27. Tom Sparrow (South Adelaide) – Melbourne
28. Xavier O’Neill (Oakleigh Chargers) – West Coast
29. Will Kelly (Oakleigh Chargers) – Collingwood (father-son)
30. William Hamill (Dandenong Stingrays) – Adelaide
31. Luke Foley (Subiaco) – West Coast
32. Luke Valente (Norwood) – Fremantle
33. James Jordon (Oakleigh Chargers) – Melbourne
34. Kieren Briggs (Pennant Hills) – GWS (academy)
35. Bailey Williams (Dandenong Stingrays) – West Coast
36. Thomas Berry (GWV Rebels) – Brisbane Lions
37. Laitham Vandermeer (Murray Bushrangers) – Western Bulldogs
38. Irving Mosquito (Gippsland Power) – Essendon
39. Jarrod Cameron (Swan Districts) – West Coast (next generation)
40. Thomas Joyce (East Fremantle) – Brisbane Lions
41. Jack Bytel (Calder Cannons) – St Kilda
42. Connor McFadyen (Wilston Grange) – Brisbane Lions (academy)
43. Jack Ross (Oakleigh Chargers) – Richmond
44. Justin McInerney (Northern Knights) – Sydney
45. Ben Cavarra (Williamstown) – Western Bulldogs
46. Curtis Taylor (Calder Cannons) – North Melbourne
47. Matthew Parker (South Fremantle) – St Kilda
48. Ben Jarvis (Norwood) – Geelong
49. Bailey Scott (Geelong Falcons) – North Melbourne (father-son)
50. Jacob Kennerley (Norwood) – Geelong
51. Zac Foot (Dandenong Stingrays) – Sydney
52. Jacob Koschitzke (Murray Bushrangers) – Hawthorn
53. Aaron Nietschke (Central District) – Melbourne
54. Nick Hind (Essendon VFL) – St Kilda
55. Noah Answerth (Oakleigh Chargers) – Brisbane Lions
56. Marty Hore (Collingwood VFL) – Melbourne
57. Lachlan Schulz (Williamstown) - Fremantle
58. Fraser Turner (Clarence) - Richmond
59. Brett Bewley (Williamstown) - Fremantle
60. Noah Gown (Gippsland Power) - Essendon
61. Connor Idun (Geelong Falcons) - GWS
62. Luke English (Perth) - Richmond
63. Matthew Walker (GWS Academy) - Hawthorn
64. Lachlan Sholl (Calder Cannons) - Adelaide
65. Darcy Fort (Central District) - Geelong
66. Finbar O'Dwyer (Yarrawonga) - Carlton
67. Robert Young (North Adelaide) - St Kilda
68. Jake Tarca (South Adelaide) - Geelong
69. Joel Crocker (Sandringham Dragons) - North Melbourne (father-son)
70. Ben Silvagni (Oakleigh Chargers) - Carlton (father-son)
71. Caleb Graham (Gold Coast academy) - Gold Coast
72. Brayden Ham (Geelong Falcons) - Essendon
73. Riley Grundy (Sturt) - Port Adelaide
74. Oscar Brownless (Geelong Falcons) - Geelong (father-son)
75. Toby Bedford (Dandenong Stingrays) - Melbourne (next generation)
76. Boyd Woodcock (North Adelaide) - Port Adelaide
77. Atu Bosenavulagi (Oakleigh Chargers) - Collingwood (next generation
78. Will Hayes (Footscray VFL) - Western Bulldogs
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Warwick said:
Just for those who want to revisit in 5 years time: Review - Winners and losers of the draft (2018 edition)

And for reference this was the draft..

1. Sam Walsh (Geelong Falcons) – Carlton
2. Jack Lukosius (Woodville-West Torrens) – Gold Coast
3. Izak Rankine (West Adelaide) – Gold Coast
4. Max King (Sandringham Dragons) – St Kilda
5. Conor Rozee (North Adelaide) – Port Adelaide
6. Ben King (Sandringham Dragons) – Gold Coast
7. Bailey Smith (Sandringham Dragons) – Western Bulldogs
8. Tarryn Thomas (North Launceston) – North Melbourne (next generation)
9. Chayce Jones (Launceston) – Adelaide
10. Nick Blakey (UNSW-ES) – Sydney (academy)
11. Jye Caldwell (Bendigo Pioneers) – GWS
12. Zak Butters (Western Jets) – Port Adelaide
13. Isaac Quaynor (Oakleigh Chargers) – Collingwood (next generation)
14. Jackson Hately (Central District) – GWS
15. Jordan Clark (Claremont) – Geelong
16. Ned McHenry (Geelong Falcons) – Adelaide
17. Sam Sturt (Dandenong Stingrays) – Fremantle
18. Xavier Duursma (Gippsland Power) – Port Adelaide
19. Liam Stocker (Sandringham Dragons) – Carlton
20. Riley Collier-Dawkins (Oakleigh Chargers) – Richmond
21. Ely Smith (Murray Bushrangers) – Brisbane Lions
22. Xavier O’Halloran (Western Jets) – GWS
23. Jez McLennan (Central District) – Gold Coast
24. Ian Hill (Perth) – GWS
25. James Rowbottom (Oakleigh Chargers) – Sydney
26. Rhylee West (Calder Cannons) – Western Bulldogs (father-son)
27. Tom Sparrow (South Adelaide) – Melbourne
28. Xavier O’Neill (Oakleigh Chargers) – West Coast
29. Will Kelly (Oakleigh Chargers) – Collingwood (father-son)
30. William Hamill (Dandenong Stingrays) – Adelaide
31. Luke Foley (Subiaco) – West Coast
32. Luke Valente (Norwood) – Fremantle
33. James Jordon (Oakleigh Chargers) – Melbourne
34. Kieren Briggs (Pennant Hills) – GWS (academy)
35. Bailey Williams (Dandenong Stingrays) – West Coast
36. Thomas Berry (GWV Rebels) – Brisbane Lions
37. Laitham Vandermeer (Murray Bushrangers) – Western Bulldogs
38. Irving Mosquito (Gippsland Power) – Essendon
39. Jarrod Cameron (Swan Districts) – West Coast (next generation)
40. Thomas Joyce (East Fremantle) – Brisbane Lions
41. Jack Bytel (Calder Cannons) – St Kilda
42. Connor McFadyen (Wilston Grange) – Brisbane Lions (academy)
43. Jack Ross (Oakleigh Chargers) – Richmond
44. Justin McInerney (Northern Knights) – Sydney
45. Ben Cavarra (Williamstown) – Western Bulldogs
46. Curtis Taylor (Calder Cannons) – North Melbourne
47. Matthew Parker (South Fremantle) – St Kilda
48. Ben Jarvis (Norwood) – Geelong
49. Bailey Scott (Geelong Falcons) – North Melbourne (father-son)
50. Jacob Kennerley (Norwood) – Geelong
51. Zac Foot (Dandenong Stingrays) – Sydney
52. Jacob Koschitzke (Murray Bushrangers) – Hawthorn
53. Aaron Nietschke (Central District) – Melbourne
54. Nick Hind (Essendon VFL) – St Kilda
55. Noah Answerth (Oakleigh Chargers) – Brisbane Lions
56. Marty Hore (Collingwood VFL) – Melbourne
57. Lachlan Schulz (Williamstown) - Fremantle
58. Fraser Turner (Clarence) - Richmond
59. Brett Bewley (Williamstown) - Fremantle
60. Noah Gown (Gippsland Power) - Essendon
61. Connor Idun (Geelong Falcons) - GWS
62. Luke English (Perth) - Richmond
63. Matthew Walker (GWS Academy) - Hawthorn
64. Lachlan Sholl (Calder Cannons) - Adelaide
65. Darcy Fort (Central District) - Geelong
66. Finbar O'Dwyer (Yarrawonga) - Carlton
67. Robert Young (North Adelaide) - St Kilda
68. Jake Tarca (South Adelaide) - Geelong
69. Joel Crocker (Sandringham Dragons) - North Melbourne (father-son)
70. Ben Silvagni (Oakleigh Chargers) - Carlton (father-son)
71. Caleb Graham (Gold Coast academy) - Gold Coast
72. Brayden Ham (Geelong Falcons) - Essendon
73. Riley Grundy (Sturt) - Port Adelaide
74. Oscar Brownless (Geelong Falcons) - Geelong (father-son)
75. Toby Bedford (Dandenong Stingrays) - Melbourne (next generation)
76. Boyd Woodcock (North Adelaide) - Port Adelaide
77. Atu Bosenavulagi (Oakleigh Chargers) - Collingwood (next generation
78. Will Hayes (Footscray VFL) - Western Bulldogs
Click to expand...
Pretty good draft that

Yet Hawks came in @ 52 by giving away the kitchen sink for Wingard. How well that has worked out….

Yeah our recruiters really know what they’re doing….
 
Ash1337 said:
The last time your club nabbed a NGA off another club it backfired. You seem to be the narky one here talking about JUH when he's not the player in question.
Click to expand...
Mate, have you paid attention to all the gnashing of teeth going on amongst your supporter group over a legitimate draft selection?
 
I’ll give Richmond a C grade in terms of players drafted. We’re limited by how far back our picks were, but we did alright in the circumstances.

We should’ve taken one more player in the National/Rookie Draft though IMO.

If we include the pick swaps to next year, that grade bumps up to a B grade.
 
TheUnicorn said:
We filled needs with all 3 picks whilst also adhering to best available, I’m stoked with our draft, couldn’t ask for much more. 🤷‍♂️

If people can’t acknowledge we did well because dodo, thats fine by me. 😁👍
Click to expand...
Everyone filled their needs? That's the point of a draft.
If that's a criteria for "winning" a draft then the bar is really freaking low.
 
FootyLad0 said:
Everyone filled their needs? That's the point of a draft.
If that's a criteria for "winning" a draft then the bar is really freaking low.
Click to expand...
It is the point. Sometimes tho they draft best available player instead of need I guess. And you're right.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

un_eggs said:
The Ugle-Hagan gift isn’t enough to keep you from moaning about a fair draft pick, taking a kid in the range that was expected? Or would you prefer the AFL to adjust the rules by a couple of picks so you can have your cake and eat it too 🙄
Click to expand...
Not to mention he was originally in our academy.
 
mike ross said:
It is the point. Sometimes tho they draft best available player instead of need I guess. And you're right.
Click to expand...
I think most team's draft BPA and then go need later down the order. You'd rarely find teams going Need > BPA early in the Draft.

If you're lucky to get BPA that fills a need then it's a double tick but i think that's pretty rare within the first 10 selections.

I feel more confident Dons did better with Lual and Roberts pickups than Caddy but maybe because i think Caddy has high bust potential?
That's just me though i don't think the Curnow comaprisons make sense at all...the kid could prove me totally wrong though and i look like an idiot.

They already have a guy of similar build in Langford where they aren't KPF height and weight but they aren't small either. Kind of a weird tweener build.

Still, having 2MP, Langford, Stringer and Caddy is a potent offesive unit to go with their smalls.
 
BuddysBiggestFan said:
D

A 170cm small forward that will get found out against the hard bodies in AFL.

2 F/S, not much effort went into recruiting these 2, and Bodie Ryan that will never see a senior game.

Will languishing around the bottom mid year and hopefully that means Mitchell gets the ass and the recruiters get when overhaul too. Still waiting for top 10 picks DGB and Mackenzie to show us what our amazing recruiters saw in them….
Click to expand...
Still waiting for you to come up with a relevant point

Life must suck eh
 
BuddysBiggestFan said:
Pretty good draft that

Yet Hawks came in @ 52 by giving away the kitchen sink for Wingard. How well that has worked out….

Yeah our recruiters really know what they’re doing….
Click to expand...

Clueless. That was a different recruitment regime AND that was Clarko driven. That whole "top-up on the run" was Clarko's doing. It didn't work, obviously, but he had earned the right to make that call.
 
Judd2Sewell said:
Clueless. That was a different recruitment regime AND that was Clarko driven. That whole "top-up on the run" was Clarko's doing. It didn't work, obviously, but he had earned the right to make that call.
Click to expand...
Don't talk facts to him

Wouldn't have an original thought if they tried
 
BuddysBiggestFan said:
How about stick to your beloved Hawthorn board. Out here we’re allowed an opinion on the coaching board and recruiters. You don’t get banned for criticizing coaches and players.
Click to expand...

Genuine question...

What are Hawthorn currently doing well? From list management to individual players. Just want to gauge how legitimate and reasonable your criticisms are.
 
Sigh.

The DTFA board is not the place to circulate rumours about specific players.

If you wish to go down that path, find a more appropriate board to engage in such discussions.

We have deleted a lot of posts yet still people persist. Next step; thread bans and infractions.

Please do not test our patience.

Thanks.
 
Blackhawk42 said:
Genuine question...

What are Hawthorn currently doing well? From list management to individual players. Just want to gauge how legitimate and reasonable your criticisms are.
Click to expand...
Go back through their other posts…. Makes that other known gloomster look like Mary Poppins.
 
Strikes me that in the 2nd round, many clubs took some speculative and or needs first selections instead of so called best available talent still on the board (hence so many sliders)

A lot of talls also went earlier than expected, which is understandable given next year is meant to be somewhat shallow for KPP/bigs but loaded with midfield talent..

In years to come, we may look back on this draft as bit of a boom or bust crop :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

PMBangers
Who DON'T you want your team to draft? 2023 Edition
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
269
Views
25K
Crow till I die
Crow till I die
S
Rookie draft 2023
Replies
4
Views
1K
Vindicater
Vindicater
Ticky009
  • Locked
2023 AFL DRAFT - National Draft completed, PSD & Rookie Draft Wednesday @ 3pm
30 31 32 33 34
Replies
838
Views
45K
Vindicater
Vindicater
dajesmac
Each Club's Draft Needs 2023
2
Replies
49
Views
4K
Vindicater
Vindicater
Jeremias
  • Sticky
Win Prizes 2023 Official Draft Tipping Competition - Join Now!
Replies
15
Views
2K
Lore
Lore
living_in_syd
Live trades 2023
2
Replies
27
Views
2K
Vindicater
Vindicater
Gavin Excell
Trade Period 2023 - winners and losers
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
236
Views
22K
ScrappyDo
ScrappyDo

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top