NFL The Best QB of All Time: Poll

[GreyCrow]

D

Tony Romo is better than Troy Aikman

That's not to say he's a bad QB, but should Aikman really be in a poll for the best QB ever?

Dak>>Romo

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

D

Dak>>Romo

Just no.

 

[AmericanCrow]

Geez, what a mature response - you degenerate. Been a niner since the Jeff "The Real GOAT" Garcia days, still wear his jersey (or my Dwight Clark throwback) on gamedays.


Good call, he's right up there for me as well. 3 MVPs, 3 championships, #3 on my pre-merge QB rankings (behind Johnny U and Starr).

10 championship appearances in 10 years and 7 titles if one counts AAFC titles (which I would given that when Browns were admitted into NFL in 1950 they dismantled 1949 NFL champs in first game and went on to win NFL Championship)

 

[TheGreatBarryB]

It's harder these days. 32 teams, equalisation etc

 

[Robbed]

Uncle Rico, end thread

 

[Wild Bill]

Brady is a sick name.

'Tom Brady' is typical hot high school QB banging the cheer captain name

So goat on and off the field? That's cool.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Elway is the GOAT of the field of QBs

When it's all said and done Elway will go down as the GOAT of the NFL

 

[Wild Bill]

Elway is the GOAT of the field of QBs

When it's all said and done Elway will go down as the GOAT of the NFL

Gisele says no.

 

[GreyCrow]

Elway is the GOAT of the field of QBs

When it's all said and done Elway will go down as the GOAT of the NFL

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

1. Joe Montana - San Francisco 49ers
2. Dan Marino - Miami Dolphins
   
3. Tom Brady - New England Patriots
   
4. Peyton Manning - Denver Broncos
   
5. Roger Staubach - Dallas Cowboys
   
6. Jon Elway - Denver Broncos
   
7. Steve Young - San Francisco 49ers
8. Aaron Rodgers - Green Bay Packers
   
9. Brett Farve - Green Bay Packers
10. Terry Bradshaw - Pittsburgh Steelers

My top 10 order

 

[nobbyiscool]

I find it a little interesting that people keep listing Manning with the Broncos. I understand that Manning won a SB with the Broncos - but lets be honest, Broncos Manning was an absolute shadow of Colts Manning.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Quantity yes quality no

 

[Broken]

So yeah, that Brady guy didn't do his legacy any harm today

 

[Wild Bill]

Brady - end thread.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Brady moves into top 4 after today

 

[scaryness]

Might have to change my vote.

 

[Wild Bill]

Brady moves into top 4 after today

Top 4 of what? Greatest sportsmen of all time??

Brady, Jordan, Federer and Messi?

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Top 4 of what? Greatest sportsmen of all time??

Brady, Jordan, Federer and Messi?

Best QB's

Best career yes, best QB no

 

[GreyWind]

Top 4 of what? Greatest sportsmen of all time??

Brady, Jordan, Federer and Messi?

It's always hard to compare sports. Just through pure athleticism Brady isn't close to those guys.

On legacy and those intangibles he's an absolute legend.

 

[aussiedude]

I voted Brady a few weeks ago, and even today was one of the best showings by a QB ever. his 4thQ/OT was epic. bringing a team back from 4 scores down late in the 3rd Q against a team with the #1 offence. His 2nd half could be used as his HoF highlight reel.

Right now there are only 2 great QB's currently playing in the NFL. and Brady today was as impressive as Rodgers was in his late season run when he looked invincible.

The next group is a logjam of like 10 QB's

 

[Bobby_]

Top 4 of what? Greatest sportsmen of all time??

Brady, Jordan, Federer and Messi?

lol, Messi?
Please replace that little person with a bloke who won 3 world cups, scored 80 goals for his country, 1280 goals in his career and turned Santos into one of the very best team in the world.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Brady = GOAT

Manning/Marino/Rodgers = Best/Most talented


Brady just did the most epic thing in the history of man kind. It was like watching myself play madden

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Top 4 of what? Greatest sportsmen of all time??

Brady, Jordan, Federer and Messi?

Federer aint even the best tennis player of all time, let alone the best sportsman. At best its a debate. When we talking about best sportsman, its undisputed best at their chosen sport. Thats Jordan and Brady right now.

 

[Wild Bill]

Federer aint even the best tennis player of all time, let alone the best sportsman. At best its a debate. When we talking about best sportsman, its undisputed best at their chosen sport. Thats Jordan and Brady right now.

18 major wins. Federer is clearly goat.

 

[Monocle]

Brady = GOAT

Manning/Marino/Rodgers = Best/Most talented


Brady just did the most epic thing in the history of man kind. It was like watching myself play madden

lol...... I did get a chuckle from that LA.