- Thread starter
- #7,526
May have been serious but also somewhat...............let's be kind............misled.
No....actually it's just a dumb post by someone who's pumping their chest out a little prematurely.
List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc
- Thread starter HARKER
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
May have been serious but also somewhat...............let's be kind............misled.
No....actually it's just a dumb post by someone who's pumping their chest out a little prematurely.
- Sep 5, 2013
- 6,493
- 10,997
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Western Bulldogs
Oh, you mean the Betts Defence? Carlton would never try tha...
Last edited:
What about GAGF
Pick #46 would have gotten Dean Gore, whom Rogers rated #11. On top of that, Jones got given a 3 year contract. This looks to have been a very poor decision.
I'm not saying a 3 contract term wasn't excessive but 46 isn't a huge investment. Dean Gore has yet to debut, so jury still out.
Threatening to delist Jones after 1 year only magnifies the blunder if that's the case. I'd prefer he was given an opportunity to repay the faith under Bolton. It's not like we have a lot of tall options, with Giles and Foster a way off, Hendo and Warnock gone and Watson at the crossroads.
Please, you are the only Richmond supporter stupid enough to post this crap on our board. We know our players are excellent. We know our team is crap right now. We will never give up our best for other's second best. You sound like a loser who wishes people were dumb enough to give them freebies with little in return. Please refrain from posting any more dribble on our board. Trade time will be interesting enough, just wait a few weeks to see what rolls around
Dixon turns 25 next month & with his injury history, at best you get 5-6 years out of him. On the other hand, a nice juicy draft pick could give you a 10+ years player. Do you see the difference?
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
Didn't realise GWS got the ability to utilise Adelaide's list as part of their concessions.
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
I wonder if they have upgraded ed's photo from Adelaide to box Hill yet...
- Jul 22, 2012
- 4,069
- 8,692
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Philadelphia 76ers
Pardon the intrusion. Troy Menzel related question.
I understand that there is a chance Menzel is moved on this offseason (not a certainty, but a chance). Let's say hypothetically that Carlton and Adelaide are working on a trade for him (SA lad, makes sense). Obviously, I would assume Carlton are going to ask for Adelaide's first rounder (or if Dangerfield leaves, one of Adelaide's two first rounders). My question is, do you think that would be the ONLY way a deal would get done or could there be an alternate deal involving Adelaide's 2nd rounder, plus a player? If so, which player(s) from our list (if any) do you think would satisfy Carlton to go along with the 2nd round pick (or perhaps a package of two players with no draft pick? Some names that may be possibilities to be put up for trade for various reasons from our end include Ricky Henderson, Jarryd Lyons, Mitch Grigg, Sam Kerridge, Matt Wright, David Mackay, Cam Ellis-Yolmen and Sam Shaw. Matt Crouch and Tom Lynch are also out of contract but Crouch is extremely unlikely to leave IMO, and Lynch looks set to either stay or go to the Dees who are offering him massive overs.
I guess another possibility might be us giving you a first and second rounder for Menzel and Yarran.
Cheers.
I understand that there is a chance Menzel is moved on this offseason (not a certainty, but a chance). Let's say hypothetically that Carlton and Adelaide are working on a trade for him (SA lad, makes sense). Obviously, I would assume Carlton are going to ask for Adelaide's first rounder (or if Dangerfield leaves, one of Adelaide's two first rounders). My question is, do you think that would be the ONLY way a deal would get done or could there be an alternate deal involving Adelaide's 2nd rounder, plus a player? If so, which player(s) from our list (if any) do you think would satisfy Carlton to go along with the 2nd round pick (or perhaps a package of two players with no draft pick? Some names that may be possibilities to be put up for trade for various reasons from our end include Ricky Henderson, Jarryd Lyons, Mitch Grigg, Sam Kerridge, Matt Wright, David Mackay, Cam Ellis-Yolmen and Sam Shaw. Matt Crouch and Tom Lynch are also out of contract but Crouch is extremely unlikely to leave IMO, and Lynch looks set to either stay or go to the Dees who are offering him massive overs.
I guess another possibility might be us giving you a first and second rounder for Menzel and Yarran.
Cheers.
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 24,117
- 56,399
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
If Menzel was looking to go home to Adelaide we wouldn't be looking to do the Adelaide Football Club any favors in a trade. You forced us to take unders in a trade for Jacobs because you had the leverage and then you signed Betts - perhaps somewhat underhandedly. If Menzel was to return to South Australia I think you may find that we're more likely to work with Port Adelaide than Adelaide.
ESKIE
Keeping it Cool.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 31,816
- 53,446
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Richmond LOL
would we part the Kruezer pick for Trelor?
Pretty sure MK will stay
#gutfeel
- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,677
- 49,688
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Really like Ellis-Yolmen, personally - would take him and an early second-rounder if you can conjure one up from another trade (anywhere between 20 and 25). That might be slightly overs for you guys, but Menzel's got a bit of x-factor about him when he's on song, and your midfield does bat pretty deep.
That being said, I think a pick around 12-15 is probably better value for you guys than CEY and an early 20's pick. You'd still be in the first round of the draft with your original pick (I imagine the Danger-compo is the one we get, not your first) and you retain a guy who's shown he's capable of performing well in your engine-room as well as grabbing a slider.
Furthermore, we need talls this draft, so picks in the first round are going to be top of our wishlist, especially if we're giving up blokes we recruited to kick goals.
- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,677
- 49,688
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Peter Wright (GC)?
Any takers?
Then hopefully grab Weitering
Don't think they'd part with him - they obviously rated him pretty highly to grab him early in the last draft, and they've got other ruckmen not getting regular games that they'd part with first.
- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,677
- 49,688
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Would rather keep 14 and leave Brisbane out of it...
That may just be the worst trade scenario I have ever seen in the history of 10 years on bigfooty lolol! Would you trade Lennon & vlaustin for Liam jones & David ellard?
McDonuts struggles to get a game. Thomas is very much old, fringe & s**t!
Go away imbecile
The issue wasn't with that part it was the 2 potatoes you were giving to the Gold Coast! Clueless
BluStreak
Norm Smith Medallist
How well is R McKenzie developing?
- Status
