2015 Trade Hypotheticals (Opposition supporters post here)

[SnowRoo]

I would have thought #26 is about his market value. Greenwood went for #25, Bell #31(using the points system) and Redden #17. I would have thought 26 is pretty fair.

North want Aish, thats pretty clear.

It will take an exceptional offer to make anything for Aish fall before Thursday. Accepting 26 or even considering it would be counter productive.

Worst case for us if everything falls over we retain a contracted player.

 

[Bojan KantKick]

I would have thought #26 is about his market value. Greenwood went for #25, Bell #31(using the points system) and Redden #17. I would have thought 26 is pretty fair.

Greenwood was uncontracted and last years draft was far stronger. Points system is largely irrelevant for teams without academies.

 

[lukiuslion]

Bris:
Out: Aish, 39
In: Bastinac, 26

Pies:
Out: 26, Saints 2016 2nd, GWS 2016 2nd
In: 39, 53

North:
Out: Bastinac, 53
In: Saints 2016 2nd, GWS 2016 2nd

Lel

 

[POBT]

North want Aish, thats pretty clear.

It will take an exceptional offer to make anything for Aish fall before Thursday. Accepting 26 or even considering it would be counter productive.

Worst case for us if everything falls over we retain a contracted player.

The issue with coming on to this board and talking tough on a trade is that most of us really don't care all that much whether Bastinac comes or not. I'd say he is seen as a "nice to have" but the place is hardly bubbling with excitement over this possible trade.

So, if your ultimatum is "fine, we'll keep him then", I'd suggest most supporters will respond with indifference.

Of course, I don't make decisions for the club so my views are largely irrelevant. But that goes both ways. Your views on what your club would or wouldn't accept are just as irrelevant.

 

[SnowRoo]

The issue with coming on to this board and talking tough on a trade is that most of us really don't care all that much whether Bastinac comes or not. I'd say he is seen as a "nice to have" but the place is hardly bubbling with excitement over this possible trade.

So, if your ultimatum is "fine, we'll keep him then", I'd suggest most supporters will respond with indifference.

Of course, I don't make decisions for the club so my views are largely irrelevant. But that goes both ways. Your views on what your club would or wouldn't accept are just as irrelevant.

Yes agree totally, just throwing out a perspective from our side.

The longer it drag the greater the chance o Aish coming to us.

Average deals for Basti will still be there late Thursday, no rush from our side.

 

[SizeMatters]

The issue with coming on to this board and talking tough on a trade is that most of us really don't care all that much whether Bastinac comes or not. I'd say he is seen as a "nice to have" but the place is hardly bubbling with excitement over this possible trade.

So, if your ultimatum is "fine, we'll keep him then", I'd suggest most supporters will respond with indifference.

Of course, I don't make decisions for the club so my views are largely irrelevant. But that goes both ways. Your views on what your club would or wouldn't accept are just as irrelevant.

I'd love to get Bastinac in the team. I rate him a better player than Bell!

 

[lionsbest]

For mine 26 is extreme bending over here.

Don't worry the Club will check your prostate at the same time!!!!

 

[pauldrc]

Lol

EFA....

 

[T Factor]

EFA....

Lol

 

[braddsey]

Bris:
Out: Aish, 39
In: Bastinac, 26

Pies:
Out: 26, Saints 2016 2nd, GWS 2016 2nd
In: 39, 53

North:
Out: Bastinac, 53
In: Saints 2016 2nd, GWS 2016 2nd

Yeah I can see why the Pies would be into that... Trading 3 x second round picks for 39 & 53.

 

[SnowRoo]

Yeah I can see why the Pies would be into that... Trading 3 x second round picks for 39 & 53.

Haha i missed Aish, my bad.

Hoping you guys get the 2 x 2016 second rounders out of them now.