Daniel Menzel 'returned to footy' progress updates

[4quarter_cat]

Talking about DM, assuming he can make it back and fit, how do people see him fitting into our forward line? because I can't see us playing a 3rd tall and DM.

 

[Bobby_]

also, remember that Menzel was being played in the back line before getting shuffled back to his preferred position for the finals. He's very versatile, wasn't quite a natural defender but you have start learning sometime.

I can't imagine he'd lose any of his athleticism from these knee reco's. When he came back for a third time, his spring, speed and lateral movement was still there. In fact, I was surprised as he literally went straight up off a couple steps so his jumping hasn't been lost at all. Not sure about his kicking penetration though.

 

[Lana]

Talking about DM, assuming he can make it back and fit, how do people see him fitting into our forward line? because I can't see us playing a 3rd tall and DM.

In late 2011 we has a three tall forward line and Menzel also played as a full time forward, it depends on the mobility of the third tall. If Stanley is the third tall then it isn't an issue, if Kersten is the third tall it is.

 

[The rabbi]

In late 2011 we has a three tall forward line and Menzel also played as a full time forward, it depends on the mobility of the third tall. If Stanley is the third tall then it isn't an issue, if Kersten is the third tall it is.

I'm not sure that I agree. Kersten is very quick off the mark. It needs to be kept in mind that while he was far from impressive in the AFl games that he played, I wonder how much, and for how long he was hindered by the knee injury.

 

[goyoucatters]

In late 2011 we has a three tall forward line and Menzel also played as a full time forward, it depends on the mobility of the third tall. If Stanley is the third tall then it isn't an issue, if Kersten is the third tall it is.

If (and it's a massive 'if') Menz can get back and play near his previous best, there won't be any issue around how he fits into our forward line. Any 'third tall' options will be lining up behind him to see if they can merit a spot.

Will be a 'top 10' pick across the entire side if he gets back to senior footy in good shape.

 

[Lana]

I'm not sure that I agree. Kersten is very quick off the mark. It needs to be kept in mind that while he was far from impressive in the AFl games that he played, I wonder how much, and for how long he was hindered by the knee injury.

When is say mobility, I am not talking about top speed in a sprint. Mobility is the ability to cover a lot of ground at a reasonable pace, for a key forward it is the ability to gut run from the forward line to the wings repeatedly. It is the reason why kersten didn't get more than 10 touches in a game.

 

[WaxiesDargle]

Menzel putting his knee through the paces.
Good to see Cowan alive and running.

 

[vinum coupe]

Miracles do happen.
Menzel and Cowan both fit to run at the same time.

 

[The rabbi]

View attachment 90771
Menzel putting his knee through the paces.
Good to see Cowan alive and running.

There is a link to the story here. The players who have come back early from holidays probably are aware that their careers could come to a sudden end if they do not take a turn for the better in 2015.
http://www.geelongcats.com.au/news/2014-11-05/injured-cats-ramp-things-up

 

[ChookNorris]

Article also mentioned smedts, Duncan came back early to train with cowan, menz and vardy. Billie putting in an effort.wonders never cease.

 

[Footy Smarts]

View attachment 90771
Menzel putting his knee through the paces.
Good to see Cowan alive and running.

Cowan, Menzel and Vardy all training together at the same time. Well bugger me. Surely there's a fair bit of cotton wool around for once they're done training for the day.

 

[Daniel McL]

Article also mentioned smedts, Duncan came back early to train with cowan, menz and vardy. Billie putting in an effort.wonders never cease.

He probably just wanted to get a selfie of him in his car driving to pre-season training

 

[Daniel McL]

Cowan, Menzel and Vardy all training together at the same time. Well bugger me. Surely there's a fair bit of cotton wool around for once they're done training for the day.

Hopefully that's enough cotton wool

 

[Partridge]

Article also mentioned smedts, Duncan came back early to train with cowan, menz and vardy. Billie putting in an effort.wonders never cease.

I'm happy to say I have no idea what his efforts are like. Be fairly confident he wouldn't be there if they were substandard.

 

[Partridge]

Cowan, Menzel and Vardy all training together at the same time. Well bugger me. Surely there's a fair bit of cotton wool around for once they're done training for the day.

At this stage it can only be encouraging news.

 

[TheHonestyPolicy]

After losing a few we obviously need some other guys now to step up and have actual input into the season next year.

I think a lot of us felt that wouldn't happen from some of these guys. Fingers crossed from here. Good luck to them.

 

[Willo_]

Interesting that it says Cowan was also there doing extra as well as Billie and Mitch, can that mean that perhaps he is finally fit?

 

[vinum coupe]

After losing a few we obviously need some other guys now to step up and have actual input into the season next year.

I think a lot of us felt that wouldn't happen from some of these guys. Fingers crossed from here. Good luck to them.

Yep. If Vardy, Menzel, and Cowan all get fit then our list does look a lot more balanced with regards to options for best 22.

 

[devonmx]

View attachment 90771
Menzel putting his knee through the paces.
Good to see Cowan alive and running.

Anyone know what that green croquet mallet is used for?
Or did it just come extra with the plastic cones kit?

 

[WaxiesDargle]

Miracles do happen.
Menzel and Cowan both fit to run at the same time.

Anyone know what that green croquet mallet is used for?
Or did it just come extra with the plastic cones kit?

To test Menzel's reflexes? Make sure the knee still has some feeling left in it

 

[The rabbi]

Article also mentioned smedts, Duncan came back early to train with cowan, menz and vardy. Billie putting in an effort.wonders never cease.

Duncan is about the only player whose career in not under some sort of threat due to poor performance or constant injury.

 

[rooie]

To test Menzel's reflexes? Make sure the knee still has some feeling left in it

the guy in the background appears to have a radio control, menzel's knees are now fully robotic and this dude controls them.

 

[Teriyakicat]

View attachment 90771
Menzel putting his knee through the paces.
Good to see Cowan alive and running.

Can't wait to see all that Cowan hair zipping around the field!! I've missed it.

 

[Teriyakicat]

There is a link to the story here. The palyers who have come back early from holidays probably are aware that their careers could come to a sudden end if they do not take a turn for the better in 2015.
http://www.geelongcats.com.au/news/2014-11-05/injured-cats-ramp-things-up

The way that's written, Cowan is out of rehab. Or have I missed something???

Article also mentioned smedts, Duncan came back early to train with cowan, menz and vardy. Billie putting in an effort.wonders never cease.

Duncan coming in early to train with his draft buddies doesn't surprise me. From what I've read over the past few years, they are all very close. (as was Christo - but that's another story!)
Well done Billie, too- I don't think he's ever lacked endeavour. His problem is something else...

 

[Stan The Caddy]

From what I can gather Vardy and Menzel were due back at the club today due to them taking leave throughout the year, whilst the other 3 have come back early by choice rather than being required to.

Some really good signs.